Confidential information

An equitable action, not a registered right

Breach of confidence is an equitable action. This means it comes from equity, a branch of law separate from contract or statute.

Sometimes confidentiality also appears as a term in a contract, written or implied. In that case the two overlap.

This action has no registration system. There is no application, no examination, and no register to check.

It also has no fixed statutory term. Protection can last indefinitely, as long as the information stays confidential and has not become public.

The elements

Coco v AN Clark (Engineers) Ltd set out three elements for breach of confidence. In Australia, the Full Federal Court uses four, confirmed in Optus Networks Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd. The key difference is in the last element.

First, the information must have “the necessary quality of confidence”. This means it cannot already be public knowledge, and must be identified precisely, not just labelled generally as “commercial information”. Trivial or well-known information does not count, even if it feels sensitive to the person claiming confidentiality.

Second, the information must have been received in circumstances importing an obligation of confidence. This means the recipient knew, or should have known, it was confidential. This can arise from an express agreement (like a non-disclosure agreement), from relationships such as employment or professional advice, or from how the information was obtained — for example, Wilson v Ferguson held that secretly copying private videos from someone’s phone was itself enough to create this obligation.

Third, there must be unauthorised use or disclosure, or a threat of it. Coco required this use to cause detriment to the confider, but the Full Federal Court’s test only requires actual or threatened misuse without consent. Whether detriment is still a separate requirement is doubted (noted in Wilson v Ferguson). Detriment should be considered where it exists on the facts, but it is not settled that a claim fails without it.

Relationship to registered IP rights

Breach of confidence works alongside registered IP rights, not against them. An inventor can choose secrecy over a patent. This trades a sure, enforceable monopoly for protection that might last forever, but could also be lost through no fault of the confider.

Two things get confused. If a rival independently discovers the information, or lawfully reverse engineers a product they legitimately bought, that rival owes no duty of confidence. They can use what they found out.

But this does not free other people who are bound by confidence. The duty continues against a confidant as long as the information stays confidential. It usually only ends once the information becomes public — for example, if the rival publishes it.

The same information can also attract other rights. It might be in a document protected by copyright, or relate to a brand a trader plans to register as a trade mark later. These rights do not cancel each other out. A well-advised client often uses several, at different stages.

Remedies

Remedies for breach of confidence are equitable and discretionary. This means a court can choose whether to grant them, based on fairness.

A court may order an injunction. This stops further use or disclosure of the information.

A court may also award equitable compensation. This covers loss the confider has suffered.

Where the recipient has profited from unauthorised use, the court may order an account of profits. This means the recipient must hand over those profits.

Finally, a court may order delivery-up or destruction. This applies to material that embodies the confidential information.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by pinning down the exact information claimed to be confidential. Check it is not already public, and not too vague to protect.

Next, look at how the information was shared. Ask if the recipient knew, or reasonably should have known, it was confidential.

Then identify any unauthorised use or disclosure, whether it has happened or is only threatened, and any harm to the person who shared it. This harm element comes from the Coco case, but Australian law doubts it is really a separate requirement.

Also check if a registered right could apply to the same facts. Think about whether relying on confidentiality is a deliberate choice, or just a fallback option.

Finally, match the remedy to the harm. An injunction suits stopping future use; a financial remedy suits use that has already occurred.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.