Confidential information: public domain, public interest and government secrets

When the information has become public

Confidential information can lose its protected status once it becomes public. How much publication is needed depends on the circumstances.

In Commonwealth v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd, newspapers wanted to publish parts of a book containing classified government documents. The court refused to stop publication, partly because the book had already been sold, including to the countries most affected. An injunction (a court order stopping an action) would not have undone the harm the government feared.

The court noted that in other cases, even limited circulation (around 100 copies) might not be enough to destroy confidentiality. The key question is how widely the information has spread, and whether stopping publication would still serve any purpose.

A contract cannot preserve confidentiality once information is genuinely public. In Maggbury Pty Ltd v Hafele Australia Pty Ltd, an inventor disclosed a product idea under a contract promising confidentiality “forever.” The invention later became public through the inventor’s own patent application.

The High Court said such confidentiality clauses are usually read as applying only while the information remains secret. A clause meant to continue after disclosure must say so clearly. Here, the clause did say so explicitly.

But once the information was public, the clause worked instead as a restraint of trade (a term limiting someone’s ability to compete or use information freely). Such restraints are invalid unless shown to be reasonable, and that had not been argued here.

The majority left open whether a short “head start” restraint, lasting only a limited time after disclosure, might be reasonable. Two judges dissented (disagreed with the outcome).

Government information: a different test of detriment

In Fairfax, the Commonwealth claimed it could protect any non-public information, just like a private person. Mason J rejected this argument.

Equity (a branch of law focused on fairness) normally protects personal and private interests. But when protecting government information, courts apply a different test.

It is not enough for the government to show that publication exposes it to criticism. Courts ask instead whether disclosure would actually harm the public interest. If not, the information won’t be protected.

Courts will stop publication if it would harm national security, foreign relations, or the ordinary business of government. Some cases are difficult to decide either way.

The same case also shows confidence and copyright are different legal claims. Mason J refused to stop publication based on confidentiality, but did grant an injunction (a court order stopping an action) based on copyright. He noted that copyright only protects the specific form of a document, not the ideas or information inside it.

The public interest defence

Even if the person who confided information was private, a public interest defence can still defeat their claim. In Fairfax, Mason J confirmed this common law defence exists, but said it is limited.

The defence allows publication of confidential information to protect the public from destruction, damage or harm. It covers breaches of national security, breaches of law (including fraud), and dangers to the public.

Mason J considered whether the defence could answer a copyright claim. He noted that applying it to diplomatic advice, to expose supposedly cynical policy, would “break new ground”.

So the defence is narrow. It is not enough that the public would simply find the information interesting.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by checking the elements of the equitable action for breach of confidence. This is the claim based on fairness, not contract. Only after that should you ask if any limit or defence applies.

Next, ask whether the information is still confidential. Look at how widely, and by whom, it has been published. If the person who originally held the secret (the confider) published it themselves, check whether a contract clause now works as a restraint of trade, limiting someone’s freedom to work or compete.

If the confider is a government, focus on what harm disclosure could cause the public. Do not ask whether disclosure would simply embarrass the government.

Where a public interest defence is raised, test it against the categories Mason J described. These include breach of national security, breach of the law (including fraud), or danger to the public.

If the information was obtained by intrusion, first decide whether it is private enough to count as confidential. Then consider whether an individual plaintiff may also have a separate claim under Schedule 2 to the Privacy Act.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.