International human rights instruments in Commonwealth legislation: definitions, the Commission and parliamentary scrutiny

Three Commonwealth definitions of ‘human rights’ by reference to international instruments (ss 3(1) and 46A of the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 and s 3(1) of the Human Rights (Parliamentary Scrutiny) Act 2011), what the Commission may do with a human rights complaint, and the Parliamentary Joint Committee and statements of compatibility.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
human-rights-and-anti-discrimination-law
Topics
international-human-rights-instruments

Learning outcomes

  • State which international instruments each of the three Commonwealth definitions of ‘human rights’ names, and explain why they are not the same list.
  • Describe the Australian Human Rights Commission’s inquiry function for acts or practices inconsistent with a human right, its limits, and the outcome it can produce, and distinguish it from the court route for unlawful discrimination.
  • State the functions of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Human Rights and the effect, on a court and on validity, of a statement of compatibility.

Commonwealth legislation refers to international human rights instruments in several places, and each reference does a different job. Before relying on a treaty in a Commonwealth problem, a student must ask which statute names it, how that statute defines “human rights”, and what the statute lets anyone do with the definition: inquire, report, scrutinise or enforce. This article states three Commonwealth definitions of “human rights” by reference to international instruments, the Australian Human Rights Commission’s functions in relation to them, and the parliamentary scrutiny scheme. It builds on International human rights instruments, which explains why an unincorporated treaty is not itself enforceable in an Australian court, and it does not state the human rights Acts of the States and Territories or the anti-discrimination Acts, which are dealt with in Human rights charters and Acts and Commonwealth anti-discrimination Acts.

Three definitions, three lists

The Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) defines “human rights” as “the rights and freedoms recognised in the Covenant, declared by the Declarations or recognised or declared by any relevant international instrument” (s 3(1)).1 The Covenant is the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, whose English text is in Schedule 2 “as that International Covenant applies in relation to Australia”. The Declarations are three United Nations declarations set out in Schedules 3 to 5: on the Rights of the Child (1959), on the Rights of Mentally Retarded Persons (1971) and on the Rights of Disabled Persons (1975). A “relevant international instrument” is an instrument in respect of which a declaration under s 47 is in force: the Minister may, by legislative instrument, declare an instrument ratified or acceded to by Australia, or a declaration adopted by Australia, to be an international instrument relating to human rights and freedoms for the purposes of the Act.

Part IIA of the same Act, concerning the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Social Justice Commissioner, uses a different definition: the rights and freedoms recognised by the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (set out in the Schedule to the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth)), by the Covenant, and those declared by the Declarations or recognised or declared by any relevant international instrument (s 46A).

The Human Rights (Parliamentary Scrutiny) Act 2011 (Cth) uses a third, a closed list of seven instruments: the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women, the Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, the Convention on the Rights of the Child and the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (s 3(1)).2 The rights and freedoms are read as they apply to Australia (s 3(2)).

The lists are not the same. The Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, for example, is named in the 2011 Act; the 1986 Act’s own definition names the Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and three declarations, and reaches other instruments only if a declaration under s 47 is in force, which must be checked for each instrument. A student who treats “human rights” as one fixed set across the Commonwealth statute book will misstate the scope of at least one function.

The Commission’s human rights functions

The Commission’s functions include examining enactments, and proposed enactments when the Minister asks, to ascertain whether they are or would be inconsistent with or contrary to any human right, and inquiring into any act or practice that may be inconsistent with or contrary to any human right and, if appropriate, trying to settle the matter by conciliation (s 11(1)(e), (f)). Subject to the grounds in s 20(2), it must perform the inquiry function when the Minister requests it, when a written complaint is made by or on behalf of a person aggrieved by the act or practice, or when it appears desirable to do so (s 20(1)).

Three limits matter. First, the function concerns an “act” or “practice”, each of which the Act defines as one done or engaged in by or on behalf of the Commonwealth or an authority of the Commonwealth, under an enactment, wholly within a Territory, or partly within a Territory to the extent done or engaged in there (s 3(1)), where “Territory” does not include the Australian Capital Territory or the Northern Territory, and an act includes a refusal or failure to do an act (s 3(3)(a)); the Act defines the acts that this function reaches. Second, the Commission may decline to inquire or to continue on specified grounds, including that the complaint was made more than 12 months after the act, that the Commission is of the opinion that the complaint is lacking in substance or that another more appropriate remedy is reasonably available to the person aggrieved, or that the Commission is satisfied there is no reasonable prospect of settlement by conciliation (s 20(2)). Third, the consequence of a finding is limited by the Act’s terms. If after an inquiry the Commission finds an act or practice inconsistent with or contrary to a human right, it must serve notice of its findings and reasons and may include recommendations measures to prevent repetition, the payment of compensation and other action to remedy loss or damage; any report it furnishes to the Minister must include particulars of its recommendations and state whether, to its knowledge, the person has taken action (s 29(2)(d)-(e)), and reports furnished under that Part are, with specified exceptions, to be laid before each House within 15 sitting days (s 46). These are findings and recommendations, not orders.

Compare the route for unlawful discrimination. Section 46PO provides for an application to the Federal Court or the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) after a terminated complaint, alleging “unlawful discrimination”, which the Act defines as acts, omissions or practices that are unlawful under specified provisions of the Age, Disability, Racial and Sex Discrimination Acts (s 3(1)). A finding that an act is inconsistent with a human right, as defined above, is not by that fact unlawful discrimination.

Parliamentary scrutiny

The Human Rights (Parliamentary Scrutiny) Act 2011 establishes the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Human Rights, which examines Bills and legislative instruments for compatibility with human rights and reports to both Houses, examines Acts for compatibility, and inquires into matters referred by the Attorney-General (s 7). A member who proposes to introduce a Bill must cause a statement of compatibility to be prepared, including an assessment of whether the Bill is compatible with human rights, and the statement must be presented to the House (s 8(1)-(3)). The rule-maker of a legislative instrument that is subject to disallowance must cause a statement of compatibility, including an assessment of the instrument’s compatibility with human rights, to be prepared, and the statement belongs in the instrument’s explanatory statement (s 9(1)-(2) and note).

The Act then states what these statements do not do. A statement of compatibility is not binding on any court or tribunal (s 8(4); s 9(3)), and a failure to comply with the requirement does not affect the validity, operation or enforcement of the resulting Act or instrument or of any other Commonwealth law (s 8(5); s 9(4)). The mechanism is an obligation of explanation to Parliament, with the Committee’s reports as the follow-up, and not a source of judicially enforceable rights.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the instrument and the Commonwealth statute said to give it effect. If the statute is neither the Commission’s Act nor the scrutiny Act, apply the statute’s own text and the approach in the companion article on incorporation.
  2. Identify which definition of “human rights” applies: s 3(1) or s 46A of the 1986 Act, or s 3(1) of the 2011 Act. Do not assume that an instrument named in one is within another.
  3. For a complaint about an act or practice, check the s 3(1) definitions of “act” and “practice” and the Commission’s discretion under s 20(2) to decline to inquire. If it inquires, the Act provides for conciliation where the Commission considers it appropriate (s 11(1)(f)(ii)), and, on a finding of inconsistency, for notice of findings, recommendations that the Commission may make (s 29(2)) and a report that is, subject to exceptions, tabled (s 46); a finding that no inconsistency is established is dealt with separately (s 29(3)).
  4. For a complaint of unlawful discrimination, move to the discrimination Acts and the court route in Part IIB, and do not describe it as a human rights complaint.
  5. For a Bill or legislative instrument, identify the statement of compatibility, state that it does not bind a court or tribunal and that failure to prepare it does not affect the resulting law’s validity, operation or enforcement, and describe the Committee’s reporting role to Parliament separately.

Self-check

  • Have I said which of the three definitions of “human rights” I am applying?
  • Have I limited the Commission’s human rights function to acts and practices within the s 3(1) definitions, and described its outcome as conciliation where appropriate, findings and recommendations?
  • Have I distinguished a human rights complaint from a complaint of unlawful discrimination?
  • Have I said that a statement of compatibility is not binding on a court and that non-compliance does not affect validity?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.