Proportionality under the human rights charters: reasonable limits in Victoria, Queensland and the ACT

Three limitation clauses

Each jurisdiction asks whether a limit on a human right is reasonable and “demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society.” Each clause also lists factors to help answer that question.

In Victoria, s 7(2) adds that this must be based on human dignity, equality and freedom. Courts “take into account all relevant factors including” five: the right’s nature, the purpose’s importance, the limitation’s nature and extent, the link between limitation and purpose, and any less restrictive options. Section 7(3) stops anyone using the Charter to limit or destroy rights beyond what it allows.

Queensland’s s 13(1) uses the same dignity, equality and freedom wording. Section 13(2) lists seven factors, but says they “may be relevant” — this is permissive, not compulsory. Queensland alone adds a seventh factor: balancing the purpose’s importance against preserving the right.

The ACT’s s 28(1) uses the same reasonable limits test, but drops the “dignity, equality and freedom” phrase. Section 28(2) lists five factors matching Victoria’s list, but makes them mandatory: “must be considered.”

So the three clauses look alike but differ in wording. Queensland’s list is optional, the ACT’s is compulsory, and Victoria’s sits between the two. Only Queensland includes an express balancing factor, and only the ACT omits the dignity, equality and freedom phrase.

How the clause operates in Queensland

In Queensland, an act, decision or statutory provision is compatible with human rights if it does not limit a right, or limits it only “to the extent that is reasonable and demonstrably justifiable” under s 13 (s 8).

It is unlawful for a public entity to act incompatibly with human rights, or to fail to properly consider a relevant right when deciding (s 58(1)). This does not apply in the situations listed in s 58(2)-(4), including where a statutory provision meant the entity could not have acted differently.

The first rule (acting compatibly) is substantive. The second (proper consideration) is procedural.

Proper consideration, under s 58(5), includes identifying affected rights and considering whether the decision would be compatible with them. This is not an exhaustive list. It is a separate exercise from the proportionality test under the first limb.

Applying this in a problem question

First, check the jurisdiction and instrument. A factor used in Queensland cases does not automatically apply in Victoria or the ACT. Always check the local clause’s wording first.

Ask two questions in order. First, does the act, decision or law limit a right? In Queensland, the applicant must show this. Second, is the limit justified? The party relying on the limit carries this onus.

Work through the local clause’s factors. These typically include purpose, the connection between purpose and limit, and less restrictive alternatives. In Queensland, also weigh the overall balance. Each factor needs evidence, not assertion.

Where the Queensland Act applies, keep two questions separate. Section 58(1)(a) asks a substantive question. Section 58(1)(b) asks a procedural question.

Remember the standard of review. Courts conduct supervisory review, not merits review. But this scrutiny is more intensive than mere unreasonableness review.

Finally, note Owen-D’Arcy’s limits. It is a single judge’s decision on the Queensland Act. This article only reports the Victorian authorities as Martin J described them, not independently.

Self-check

Before moving on, check a few things.

Check you used the right clause for your jurisdiction. Remember the three jurisdictions word their proportionality clauses differently, so the wording matters.

Check you placed the onus correctly. The onus (the burden of proving something) sits with the applicant to show a right is limited. The onus then shifts to the party relying on the limit, who must show the limit is justified.

Check you kept the two limbs of s 58(1) separate. This section has a substantive limb (about the actual content of the limit) and a procedural limb (about how that limit was decided). Treat them as different questions.

Check you did not mix up structured proportionality, a method used in constitutional cases, with the charter clauses themselves. Keep these two frameworks distinct.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →