First Nations peoples and Australian law: an overview
The constitutional starting point
The Constitution does not say much about this area directly. What it does say gives Parliament power to make laws. It does not itself give people rights.
Section 51(xxvi) lets the Commonwealth Parliament make laws for “the people of any race for whom it is deemed necessary to make special laws.” This is a head of power, meaning it authorises legislation. It does not create individual rights on its own.
Other rights come from elsewhere. Native title rights come from the common law, as the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) preamble and s 223(1)(c) recognise. Other schemes come from statute.
Section 25 of the Constitution still exists. It affects how a State’s population is counted under s 24 if that State bars a race from voting for its lower house.
The Native Title Act’s preamble explains the history behind it. It notes Australians voted to allow special laws for Aboriginal peoples, and that Australia ratified an international convention against racial discrimination and passed the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth).
The preamble also describes the Native Title Act’s provisions as special measures, meaning actions to fix past injustices. This label matters because the Racial Discrimination Act treats special measures differently from other race-based laws.
Native title is recognised, not granted
The Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) does not create native title rights. It only recognises and protects rights that already exist.
Section 10 says native title is recognised and protected “in accordance with this Act”. Section 11(1) says native title cannot be extinguished contrary to the Act.
Section 11(2) limits this further. Legislation made on or after 1 July 1993 (Commonwealth, State or Territory) can only extinguish native title if it falls under Division 2B or Division 3 of Part 2, or validates past acts and intermediate period acts.
Section 223(1) defines what native title actually means. It covers rights and interests held under traditional laws and customs observed by the peoples concerned.
This statutory definition, not just common law, is the source of native title claims. The full recognition case and detail of this definition are covered in a separate article on native title recognition and the statutory framework.
Statutory land rights: a different route to land
Statutory land rights work differently from native title. A land rights Act grants land under its own rules, instead of recognising a surviving traditional right.
Under the Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (Cth), the Minister may set up Aboriginal Land Trusts. These trusts hold land for Aboriginals entitled by tradition to use or occupy it.
Section 50(1)(a) gives the Aboriginal Land Commissioner a function on a traditional land claim application. The Commissioner must find out whether the applicants, or any other Aboriginals, are the traditional owners. The inquiry can look beyond just the applicants.
If the Commissioner finds traditional owners, they must recommend a grant to the Minister under ss 11 and 12. This recommendation is not discretionary once that finding is made. But new applications under this route are now barred, since more than ten years have passed since the time limit began.
New South Wales takes a different approach. Section 36 of the Aboriginal Land Rights Act 1983 (NSW) lets Aboriginal Land Councils claim “claimable Crown lands.” This test looks at the land’s status, not traditional ownership.
The land must be vested in the Crown and lawfully able to be sold, leased, reserved or dedicated under the named Crown lands statutes. It must not be lawfully occupied, and not needed, or likely needed, for an essential public purpose. It also must not be land that a Crown Lands Minister believes is needed, or likely needed, as residential land — so this last criterion depends on the Minister’s opinion, not on fact.
Section 36 still names two older statutes. But the High Court has explained these are now read, through s 68(3) of the Interpretation Act 1987 (NSW), as references to the Crown Land Management Act 2016 (NSW) (La Perouse Local Aboriginal Land Council v Quarry Street Pty Ltd [2025] HCA 32, Gageler CJ at [4]).
Racial discrimination: equality supplied by statute
The Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) has two separate mechanisms. Don’t mix them up.
Section 9(1) makes an act unlawful. This covers acts that distinguish, exclude, restrict or prefer based on race, colour, descent or national or ethnic origin, where the act’s purpose or effect is to nullify or impair equal enjoyment of a human right or fundamental freedom in public life.
Section 9(1A) extends this to requiring compliance with an unreasonable term or condition. The person must be unable to meet it, and requiring compliance must have the purpose or effect of nullifying or impairing equal enjoyment of a human right or fundamental freedom, for people of the same race, colour, descent or national or ethnic origin.
Section 10(1) operates differently — on a law, not an act. If a Commonwealth, State or Territory law gives people of one race lesser enjoyment of a right than another race enjoys, s 10 steps in. “Notwithstanding” that law, the disadvantaged group gets the right to the same extent, by force of s 10 itself. The section supplies the remedy directly, rather than invalidating the law.
Section 8(1) excludes special measures covered by Article 1(4) of the Convention from this scheme. But this exclusion doesn’t apply where s 10(1) applies, because of s 10(3).
Where traditional laws and customs stand
Traditional laws and customs matter differently depending on the law involved. Under the Native Title Act, they are the source of the rights it recognises. Elsewhere, the relevant statute decides their place.
For federal sentencing, Parliament has made the rule explicit. Section 16A(1) of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) requires a sentence that fits all the circumstances.
Section 16A(2A) then says the court must not use customary law or cultural practice to excuse, justify, authorise, require or lessen the seriousness of the offending. The same exclusion also stops customary law or cultural practice being used to make the offending seem worse.
This exclusion is not absolute. Section 16A(2AA) says it does not apply to a specific list of cultural heritage offences, including s 22 of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act 1984 (Cth) and ss 69 and 70 of the Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (Cth).
Section 16A only applies to federal offences. It says nothing about sentencing under State or Territory laws.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by naming what is actually in dispute. It might be rights in land, a grant of land, harm to a place or object, unequal treatment by race, or the legal effect of traditional law. Identify which legal regime governs that dispute before applying any test.
If the claim is about land rights, work out whether it is a native title claim or a land rights Act grant. Apply that instrument’s own criteria, not the other one’s. Then work through the relevant jurisdiction’s Act, checking whether a native title claim or determination excludes or qualifies the land.
For harm to a place or object, start with the State or Territory heritage statute. The Commonwealth declaration power is separate and only applies if someone makes an application.
For alleged race-based unequal treatment, separate two questions: s 9 asks about an act, s 10 asks about the operation of a law. Also check whether s 8(1) applies.
Before using customary law or cultural practice in sentencing, check the governing sentencing statute first. For federal offences, s 16A(2A) limits using this to excuse, justify, authorise, require or lessen (or, under paragraph (2)(ma), aggravate) seriousness of the offending. This limit is itself subject to s 16A(2AA).
Self-check
Before answering, check a few things.
Work out which body of law actually applies. Do not default to the law you know best.
Keep native title and statutory land grants separate. Apply each Act’s own rules, not one set for both.
State which jurisdiction’s statute applies. Do not treat one Act as the general rule everywhere.
Remember s 51(xxvi) is a head of power. It lets Parliament make laws; it does not itself give rights.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.