Parenting orders and the best interests of the child

The paramount consideration

In parenting cases, the child’s best interests come first. This is called the paramount consideration.

Paramount does not mean the only consideration. Parents’ wishes still matter, but if they clash with the child’s best interests, the child’s interests win.

The court is not asking what a parent is entitled to. It asks what arrangement actually serves the child’s welfare, safety and development.

No fixed formula or presumption

There is no fixed formula for dividing a child’s time between parents. No arrangement — equal time, primary residence with one parent, or anything else — is presumed to be the starting point.

In AMS v AIF (1999) 199 CLR 160, the High Court dealt with a relocation dispute. It held that requiring a custodial parent to show “compelling reasons” for moving was an error. The real question is always the child’s best interests on their own facts.

Best interests depend on each child’s own circumstances. This includes their age, developmental needs, relationships with each parent and others, and any risks involved. The same facts can lead to different results for different children, and courts are not limited to the options the parties suggest.

Courts commonly look at several factors: a meaningful relationship with both parents where safe, protection from harm (including family violence or abuse), the child’s own views (weighed by age and maturity), the practical impact on stability, and each parent’s capacity to meet the child’s needs. No single factor automatically outweighs the others — they are all weighed together for that particular child.

Kinds of parenting orders

A parenting order can cover any part of a child’s care, welfare and development. Three issues come up again and again.

The first is who the child lives with. This is the day-to-day living arrangement. It might be mainly with one parent, shared, or arranged some other way.

The second is who the child spends time with. This includes time with a parent the child does not mainly live with. It can also include other important people, like grandparents.

The third is parental responsibility. This means decision-making power over major long-term matters, such as health, education, religion and name. An order can require parents to consult and agree, or let one parent decide alone.

Parental responsibility is about decision-making, not living arrangements. A parent can have this responsibility without the child living with them most of the time. The reverse is also possible.

Safety as a threshold consideration

Courts will not assume a relationship with both parents is always good for the child. If there are genuine concerns about violence, abuse or neglect, safety comes first. This links to the article on family violence protections, which explains how these concerns are raised and proved.

A key constitutional point has shifted since AMS v AIF. In APLA Limited v Legal Services Commissioner (NSW) [2005] HCA 44, Hayne J said the AMS principles should now be treated as settled law. So AMS was not left undecided by that case.

But Palmer v Western Australia [2021] HCA 5 narrowed this. It held the “intercourse limb” (a test about burdens on movement between states) only applies to burdens that are discriminatory. Kiefel CJ, Keane J and Gageler J explained why APLA does not prevent this narrower approach.

This matters for relocation orders (orders allowing a parent to move with a child). The first question is now whether the burden on interstate movement is discriminatory. Only if it is does the AMS justification test apply.

The law has also changed by statute. The Family Law Amendment Act 2023 (Cth) removed the presumption of equal shared parental responsibility. It added s 65DAAA, which says a court must not reconsider a final parenting order unless it has checked for a significant change of circumstances and is satisfied reconsideration suits the child’s best interests. The court may still reconsider if all parties consent. Both changes began on 6 May 2024. They change the context for applying AMS, but do not answer the relocation question AMS itself decided.

Applying this in a problem question

Start with the paramount consideration. This is the best interests of the child. It drives the whole answer, not just one factor among many.

Do not assume a fixed starting point or formula for parenting arrangements. Each case depends on its own facts.

Work through the child’s actual circumstances. Consider age, relationships, views, stability and any safety concerns.

Pin down which type of parenting order is really in dispute. Living arrangements, time, and decision-making responsibility are separate categories.

Explain how family violence or safety concerns would be weighed. Do not assume these concerns away.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.