Family violence protections
State and territory protection orders
Every state and territory has its own laws on family or domestic violence protection orders. They go by different names: apprehended domestic violence orders, intervention orders, or protection orders.
A person can ask a court for an order restraining someone’s behaviour. This might stop contact, require distance, or ban certain conduct.
The order itself is a civil matter, not a criminal one. In NSW, Victoria, Queensland and WA, courts decide on the balance of probabilities (the civil standard), not beyond reasonable doubt. It aims to prevent future harm, not punish past conduct.
In Victoria and WA, a court can make an order even if the respondent already faces criminal charges over the same conduct. In WA, making the order does not otherwise affect the person’s civil or criminal liability for that conduct.
The passage does not say whether making an order appears on a person’s criminal record in these four jurisdictions. Queensland is different: its Act separates criminal history (convictions and charges) from domestic violence history (orders made against a person).
Breaching a protection order is a criminal offence. Once the respondent is legally bound by it — through service, being in court when it was made, or police notification — breaking it can lead to prosecution. The prosecution must then prove the order’s existence and terms beyond reasonable doubt.
The exact elements of this offence, and any exceptions, differ between jurisdictions. The key point to remember: the order itself is civil, but breaching it is criminal.
Family violence within family law proceedings
Family violence also matters inside family law cases, separate from state protection orders. The Commonwealth definition is broad: it covers violence, threats or other behaviour that controls or coerces a family member, or makes them fearful.
Western Australia has its own Family Court Act 1997 (WA), with family violence defined in s 9A in similar terms. Its Part 5A covers de facto relationships. WA’s protection orders are different: they come from the Restraining Orders Act 1997 (WA), which defines family violence separately in s 5A.
In parenting proceedings, family violence affects the best interests test. The court’s first consideration is what arrangements keep the child, and each carer, safe. This includes safety from family violence directed at the child, and from exposure to family violence between adults in the child’s life.
The court must also consider any history of family violence and any family violence order. The benefit of a relationship with both parents only applies “where it is safe to do so”. Parenting orders must, as far as the child’s best interests allow, fit with any family violence order and avoid unacceptable risk of family violence.
Allegations of family violence in family law proceedings are judged on the civil standard, not the criminal standard. This matters when comparing how the same conduct is treated in different legal processes.
In property proceedings, courts must consider how family violence affected a party’s ability to make contributions — for example, by making contributions more arduous. They must also consider its effect on that party’s current and future circumstances.
Why the two frameworks overlap without merging
One event can lead to two legal processes at once. The same violence can support a state protection order and also be raised in a family law case about parenting or property.
These cases often run at the same time. Courts and lawyers manage this overlap, including by sharing information between proceedings.
But the two systems stay legally separate. A protection order is a state or territory civil order, enforced by criminal law if breached.
In family law, the same conduct is just a fact. It is something a court considers when using its Commonwealth (or Western Australian) family law discretion.
Applying this in a problem question
First work out what the question asks about. It may involve a state or territory protection order, a family law proceeding, or both.
Remember a protection order is made on the civil standard (the lower level of proof used in civil cases). Breaching that order is a criminal offence. Don’t say the order itself creates or avoids a criminal record.
Use the correct name for the order in that jurisdiction. Terms for protection orders differ across Australia, so don’t assume one national name.
In a parenting or property case, explain how alleged family violence is weighed within that proceeding’s own analysis. This weighing still happens on the civil standard.
Don’t treat an allegation untested in one proceeding as automatically proven in the other.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.