The tendency and coincidence thresholds: significant probative value and s 101

The two gateway conditions, which are the same for both rules

Sections 97 and 98 work the same way. Evidence is inadmissible unless two things happen: reasonable written notice is given to other parties, and the court thinks the evidence will have significant probative value, alone or with other evidence the party adduces.

The notice rule does not always apply. It drops away when evidence is adduced under court directions made under s 100, or to explain or contradict similar evidence from another party. But the two sections have separate versions of this exception: s 97(2)(b) covers tendency evidence, s 98(2)(b) covers coincidence evidence. They cannot be swapped.

Significant probative value can be shown by the evidence alone, or together with other evidence the same party brings. So weak evidence on its own might still qualify in combination. Whether it actually does remains a separate question.

Notices must follow any regulations or court rules made under s 99. Section 99 itself says nothing about content or timing -- that detail comes from those regulations or rules. The requirement that notice be reasonable and in writing comes from ss 97(1)(a) and 98(1)(a), not s 99.

What each rule actually forbids

Sections 97 and 98 deal with different kinds of reasoning. Using the right one matters.

Section 97 is about tendency reasoning. This means using evidence of a person’s character, reputation or conduct to show they have a tendency to act a certain way or have a certain state of mind.

Section 98 is about coincidence reasoning. This means using evidence that two or more events happened, to argue it is improbable they happened by chance given their similarities. This is used to prove a person did something or had a certain state of mind.

Section 97 asks what the person is like. Section 98 asks how unlikely a pattern is. The same facts can sometimes support both, so it matters which reasoning is being used.

Self-check

Before applying tendency or coincidence reasoning, check s 94 first. Ask what it excludes from the analysis.

In four of the six Acts, s 94(5) stops you using the collusion, concoction or contamination argument when assessing probative value. Collusion, concoction and contamination mean the evidence might be the product of agreement or invention, not genuine similarity.

Know the two gateway conditions and keep them separate. Do not merge them into one test.

Understand when notice is not required, and which section’s exception covers which route.

Remember s 101 asks a second question. It does not simply restate s 97.

Finally, know that s 101 does not restrict every party. Check which party falls outside its limits.

A worked application

Here is a quick example. A defendant faces three fraud charges, tried together. The prosecution wants each charge to support the others.

First, name the reasoning. Arguing the defendant is the type who commits fraud is a tendency argument, under s 97. Arguing three similar schemes are too coincidental is a coincidence argument, under s 98. The prosecution can run both, but must say which applies, since each has its own gateway questions.

Next, check the gateways. Both need reasonable written notice to the defendant. Exceptions exist under s 100, or where the evidence answers tendency evidence the defendant raised (s 97(2)(b)), or coincidence evidence the defendant raised (s 98(2)(b)). These exceptions are separate and must be matched to the right section.

Then consider significant probative value. This can be assessed by looking at the incidents together, not just alone. But this only allows combining the evidence — it does not prove significant probative value exists. That must still be shown separately for each charge, since strength may vary across counts.

Separately, apply s 101. Since this is prosecution evidence against a defendant, its probative value must substantially outweigh any prejudicial effect.

Be precise about what “prejudice” means here. It is not simply the inference from tendency to the charged conduct — that inference is what the scheme allows once thresholds are met. The prejudice is irrational or disproportionate use of the evidence: overweighting it, assuming it must apply to the charged event, or convicting from disapproval rather than genuine proof. Meeting s 97 does not automatically satisfy s 101 — they ask different questions.

Finally, remember the discretions. Satisfying s 101 does not remove the court’s separate discretion under s 137.

Where the authority sits

Part 3.6 of the uniform Acts covers tendency and coincidence evidence. Section 94 sets the boundary, and s 101 adds an extra restriction that applies only in criminal cases.

Most core provisions work the same way across jurisdictions, even where wording differs slightly (for example, “present” versus “adduce”). But four provisions are not uniform: s 101(2), s 98(1A), s 97A, and ss 94(4)-(5). These exist in New South Wales, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory, but not in the Commonwealth or Victoria.

Before applying any of this, check which court you’re in. Queensland and South Australia have never adopted the uniform scheme. Western Australia has enacted it, but it is not yet in force — only Part 1 and s 384 currently operate, with the substantive Parts commencing 18 September 2027.

So in Queensland, South Australia, and (until 2027) Western Australia, this area is still governed by the common law and each jurisdiction’s own evidence statute.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.