Provisional relevance and inferences about relevance

When relevance depends on a finding not yet made

Section 57(1) applies when whether evidence is relevant depends on the court making another finding first. This includes a finding that the evidence is what a party says it is. The court may find the evidence relevant either if making that other finding is reasonably open now, or on the basis that later evidence will make it reasonably open.

This is why courts sometimes admit evidence “subject to relevance” or on a promise to connect it up later. The party does not need to prove the underlying fact straight away. They only need to show the finding is reasonably open.

Section 57(2) deals with common purpose, meaning two or more people acting together toward a shared goal. Where relevance depends on finding a common purpose existed, the court may use the very evidence in question to decide whether that common purpose existed.

The wording differs in Victoria. Other Australian Acts refer to a common purpose “whether to effect an unlawful conspiracy or otherwise”. Victoria’s Act adds “or as part of involvement in the commission of an offence”, and itself notes this difference from the other Acts.

The passage only establishes that the wording differs, not what that difference means in practice. It does not show the other Acts exclude a common purpose formed through involvement in an offence, since their wording ends with “or otherwise”. Nor does it show exactly what the extra Victorian wording adds. Because this is unresolved, you must always quote the section from the Act actually governing the case.

Why both provisions matter to the order of argument

Relevance is a gateway. If evidence is irrelevant, it is inadmissible, and no discretion can fix that.

Sections 57 and 58 let a court treat relevance as provisional. The court can infer relevance reasonably, rather than proving it conclusively upfront.

This lets a case proceed in a sensible order. Without this, a party would effectively have to prove its case backwards.

Relevance is not a single, final decision made once. Treating it that way misreads how these provisions work.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by naming the relevance question. Identify the fact in issue, and explain how the evidence relates to it.

Sometimes relevance depends on another fact being found first. If so, name that fact and apply s 57. Ask whether it is reasonably open now, or might become open once more evidence comes in.

Where a document or thing’s authenticity or identity is disputed, remember s 58. The court may examine it directly and draw an inference, without needing separate proof first.

A finding of provisional relevance is not final. It can collapse later if the connecting evidence never shows up.

If the question involves common purpose, quote s 57(2) from the relevant Act. Be careful: the Victorian wording differs from the Commonwealth wording.

A worked application

A party tenders a note claiming the defendant wrote it, to show the defendant knew of a defect. The defendant denies writing it, and no handwriting expert gives evidence.

The note is only relevant if the defendant wrote it. So relevance depends on another finding. Section 57(1) lets the court move forward anyway.

The court may find the note relevant if it is reasonably open to find the defendant wrote it. It need not finally decide authorship yet. This is a deliberately low bar, because the question is whether the evidence can be received, not who actually wrote it.

The court may instead admit the note subject to further evidence being led later. This is sometimes called “admitted subject to relevance.” If that later evidence never comes, the provisional basis for admission disappears.

Section 58 adds a further point about documents. Where a document’s relevance is in question, the court may examine it itself and draw reasonable inferences, including about its authenticity. For example, letterhead or handwriting matching an exemplar already in evidence. The court can reason from the document itself, rather than requiring separate proof of authenticity first.

Change the facts: now the relevance of one conspirator’s act depends on a common purpose with another person. Section 57(2) applies the same provisional approach to that finding. The court may use the evidence of the act itself to decide whether the common purpose existed.

In a Victorian court, s 57(2) would be quoted in full. It expressly extends to a common purpose formed as part of involvement in committing an offence.

Where the authority sits

Relevance comes from Part 3.1 of the uniform Acts. Section 55 defines relevance. Section 56 makes relevant evidence admissible, unless another rule says otherwise. Sections 57 and 58 provide the detailed rules.

Subsection 57(1) and s 58 work the same way in the Commonwealth, NSW, Victoria, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory. The ACT and Tasmania just use different wording, not different meaning.

Subsection 57(2) is different: Victoria’s version has an extra part the other five jurisdictions lack. Check which court you are dealing with before relying on this subsection.

Queensland and South Australia have not adopted this uniform scheme for their own courts. Western Australia has enacted its own Evidence Act, but has not commenced it.

Being enacted and being in force are different things. Western Australia’s Act was assented to on 25 September 2025. Under its s 2, only Part 1 and s 384 currently operate; the rest commences 18 September 2027.

So right now, Queensland, South Australia and Western Australia rely on the common law and their own existing statutes for relevance. There is no operative Western Australian section to cite yet.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.