Judicial warnings about unreliable evidence
Section 165: evidence of a kind that may be unreliable
Section 165(1) lists kinds of evidence that may be unreliable. The list is not exhaustive. It includes hearsay, admissions, identification evidence, and evidence affected by age, ill health or injury.
It also includes evidence from a witness who might reasonably be supposed to have been criminally concerned in the events, and evidence from a prison informer. These two apply only in a criminal proceeding. There is also unrecorded, unsigned oral evidence of police questioning, and evidence in estate proceedings adduced by the person seeking relief about something the deceased could have addressed.
Section 165(2) sets out the obligation. But it only applies if there is a jury and a party requests it. The judge must then warn the jury the evidence may be unreliable, explain why, and warn about caution in weighing it.
Three qualifications apply. The judge need not comply if there are good reasons not to (s 165(3)). No particular wording is required (s 165(4)). The section does not limit the judge’s other powers to warn the jury (s 165(5)).
Section 165(6) carves out an exception. For a child witness, s 165(2) does not allow a warning about unreliability due to the child’s age. Such a warning can only be given under s 165A(2) and (3). In the ACT Act, this rule is in a separate s 165(7).
Overall, s 165 only applies if requested, not automatically. Saying “the judge must warn the jury” ignores the request requirement, the jury requirement, and the good-reasons exception.
Section 165A: the prohibition about children’s evidence
Section 165A stops judges warning juries that children, as a class, are unreliable witnesses. The judge also must not say a child’s evidence needs more scrutiny just because of age. In criminal cases, the judge must not give a general warning against convicting on a child’s uncorroborated evidence.
This is a prohibition, not a discretion. The judge has no choice here, unlike with other warnings under the scheme.
But s 165A(2) allows an exception. If a party asks, and satisfies the court there are circumstances particular to that child (not just age) affecting reliability, the judge may warn the jury about that child’s evidence specifically. Section 165A(3) also keeps the judge’s other usual powers to warn or inform the jury intact.
So the ban only targets generic, age-based warnings about children as a group. A warning about this particular child remains possible, but only on request and only with a proper reason beyond age alone.
Section 165B: forensic disadvantage from delay
Section 165B deals with forensic disadvantage caused by delay. It only applies in criminal trials with a jury.
The defendant must apply for the warning. Under the Commonwealth, Tasmanian, ACT and Northern Territory Acts, only the defendant can apply. In New South Wales, any party can apply.
If the court is satisfied the defendant suffered significant forensic disadvantage from the delay, the court must tell the jury about it. The disadvantage must come from the consequences of delay, not just delay itself.
The judge does not have to give the warning if there are good reasons not to. There is no required wording, but the judge must not say it would be dangerous or unsafe to convict just because of the delay or disadvantage.
This section is the only way a judge can warn about forensic disadvantage from delay. Other powers to warn or inform the jury on different matters still exist.
The Act defines delay to include delay in reporting the offence. It also says a significant forensic disadvantage is not automatically shown just because there was a delay.
New South Wales and the Northern Territory have an extra provision, s 165B(7), not found in the other Acts. It lists examples that may show forensic disadvantage, such as witnesses dying or disappearing, or evidence being lost.
Applying this in a problem question
Work through these steps in order.
First, check if there is a jury. These rules apply to what a jury is told.
Next, identify the evidence type. Ask if it fits s 165(1), noting the list is inclusive, not exhaustive.
Then check if a party actually requested a warning. Section 165(2) does not apply automatically; someone must ask for it.
If a child gave evidence, check s 165A first. This section bans much of what people might assume about age and reliability.
If the issue is delay, work through s 165B. A party must apply (the defendant, if outside New South Wales), show significant forensic disadvantage, caused by the delay’s consequences.
For ss 165 and 165B, remember the good-reasons exception can excuse a warning, and no fixed wording is required. Neither exception applies to s 165A(1), which prohibits certain comments rather than imposing a duty — but check s 165A(2) separately. Also, under s 165B(4), the judge must not imply a conviction would be dangerous or unsafe merely because of the delay or disadvantage.
Where the authority sits
The rules on judicial warnings about unreliable evidence are statutory. They sit in Part 4.5 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth and NSW).
These provisions are written as directions to a jury. But that does not mean they are irrelevant when there is no jury.
In NSW, s 133(1) of the Criminal Procedure Act 1986 covers criminal trials heard by a judge alone. Section 133(3) says that if a warning would be required for a jury, the judge must take that warning into account instead.
Section 133(2) also requires the judge’s written judgment to set out the principles of law applied and the facts relied on. This means you can check, from the judgment itself, whether the warning was properly considered.
Queensland and South Australia have not adopted this uniform scheme. Their warning rules come from their own legislation and the common law instead.
Western Australia is mid-transition, and the date matters. The Evidence Act 2025 (WA) was assented to on 25 September 2025 and introduces the uniform scheme. Its Part 8 Division 3 holds the warning provisions: s 317 (unreliable evidence), s 318 (warnings about children’s evidence), and s 319 (forensic disadvantage from delay). These match ss 165, 165A and 165B of the Commonwealth Act, and the WA Act itself labels ss 317–318 as comparable provisions.
But “compare” does not mean “identical.” Section 319(1) abolishes the common law rule requiring a Longman warning (a specific warning about delay in prosecution). Section 319(2) requires the judge to “explain” the disadvantage and “direct” the jury to consider it — not simply “inform” them, as the Commonwealth version does.
Section 319(5)(c) goes further: the explanation or direction must not take the form of a warning at all. Sections 320 and 321 add extra directions about delay in making a complaint, with no equivalent in the Commonwealth Act’s Part 4.5.
Importantly, as at 10 October 2026, these WA provisions had not yet commenced. Only Part 1 commenced on assent, and s 384 the next day. The remaining provisions — including Parts 2 to 9 — await a day fixed by proclamation, per s 2(e).
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.