Identification evidence: the warning the jury must be given
The s 116 direction
Section 116(1) applies once identification evidence has been admitted. The judge must tell the jury there is a special need for caution before accepting it. The judge must also explain why, both generally and based on the specific case.
Section 116(2) says no fixed wording is needed for this warning. The ACT text uses stronger language, saying the judge “must tell” the jury.
A different warning covers picture identification, like a photo. Under s 115(7), this only applies if the defendant asks for it. The judge must then tell the jury the picture was taken after the defendant was in custody, or otherwise warn jurors not to assume the defendant has a criminal record.
Only where reliability is disputed: Dhanhoa
Section 116, read literally, seems to require the warning in every case where identification evidence is admitted. In Dhanhoa v The Queen, the High Court narrowed this. The victim had picked the accused’s photo as “very similar” to one of the attackers, but by trial the accused admitted being at the scene; his defence was that he left before the attack happened.
Gleeson CJ and Hayne J said a literal reading would be absurd when the truth of the identification is not disputed. They held s 116 only requires the warning “where the reliability of the identification evidence is disputed”. They noted the common law rule in Domican has the same limit. McHugh and Gummow JJ agreed: no warning is needed if identification is not actually in issue. The appeal was dismissed.
Callinan J agreed with this general approach, that s 116 applies only when identity is in issue. However, he dissented on the facts, finding identification was genuinely disputed here, since whether the accused was among the attackers remained contested.
Victoria: the Jury Directions Act
Victoria has its own law on this, in Part 4 Division 4 of the Jury Directions Act 2015 (Vic). Either the prosecution or defence can ask the judge for a direction on identification evidence. They must specify the significant matters that could make the evidence unreliable (s 36(1)-(2)).
Under s 14(1), the judge must give a requested direction, unless there are good reasons not to. Under s 16(1), the judge must give an unrequested direction if there are substantial and compelling reasons for it.
The direction itself must do several things (s 36(3)). The judge must warn the jury to be cautious about accepting the evidence and deciding its weight. The judge must also tell the jury about the significant matters that may make it unreliable.
The judge must explain that a witness can honestly believe their identification is right, yet still be mistaken. Mistaken evidence can still sound convincing. Where relevant, the judge must also warn that several witnesses can all be mistaken together, and that mistaken identification has caused innocent people to be convicted.
Division 4 defines “identification evidence” itself (s 35). This definition covers recognising an object, not just a person.
Section 37 limits the duty to direct: outside Division 4, judges need not warn juries about unreliable identification evidence. This section also abolishes any contrary common law rule.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by checking if the evidence fits the Dictionary definition of identification evidence. This means an assertion (or a report of one) that the accused was, or resembles, a person seen at or near the scene.
Next check admissibility under ss 114 and 115. These apply in the Commonwealth, New South Wales, Victorian, ACT and Northern Territory Acts, but not in Tasmania, which has not enacted them. Also check whether the defendant asked for a s 115(7) warning about pictures.
Then ask whether the reliability of the identification is actually disputed by the end of the evidence. If it is not disputed, Dhanhoa holds that s 116 does not require a warning.
If reliability is disputed, test the warning against Domican. The judge must identify the specific weaknesses of that identification, speaking with the authority of their office. A general warning or reliance on counsel’s arguments is not enough.
An inadequate warning cannot be excused by pointing to the strength of other evidence. The warning must be given as though the jury could convict on the identification evidence alone.
In Victoria, also apply ss 36 and 37 of the Jury Directions Act 2015 (Vic). Start by asking whether a direction was requested, and what matters were specified.
Where the authority sits
Section 116 exists in the Commonwealth, New South Wales, Tasmanian, ACT and Northern Territory Acts. Victoria has repealed its own s 116. Victoria now uses Part 4 Division 4 of the Jury Directions Act 2015 (Vic) instead.
Tasmania has not enacted ss 114 and 115.
Dhanhoa interprets the New South Wales version of s 116. Domican instead states the common law, meaning judge-made law rather than a statute. High Court decisions bind lower Australian courts, but the High Court can later reconsider its own past decisions.
Western Australia’s Evidence Act 2025 (WA) has its own counterpart provision, s 135. Under s 135, the judge “must inform” the jury. This Part does not commence until 18 September 2027.
Queensland and South Australia are not addressed in this passage.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.