Good character evidence: what it proves and what the jury is told
Character is not the same as reputation
Character and reputation are not the same thing. In Melbourne v The Queen, McHugh J said character means a person’s real moral qualities. Reputation means how the public sees that person, whatever their real qualities are.
Courts have not always kept these ideas separate. In Braysich v The Queen, the judges used this distinction. They noted the evidence there showed the appellant’s actual disposition, since witnesses spoke from personal dealings with him as honest.
The uniform Evidence Acts avoid part of this problem. Section 110(1) says certain rules do not block a defendant’s evidence of good character. Those rules are the hearsay, opinion, tendency and credibility rules. This applies where the defendant proves good character directly or by implication, either generally or in a particular respect, such as honesty with money.
Good character “in a particular respect” is a narrower claim than good character generally. Sections 110(2) and (3) let the prosecution respond, matching whichever type of claim the defendant made.
The two uses: propensity and credibility
Good character evidence can affect guilt in two ways. McHugh J said it bears on propensity (the likelihood the accused committed the crime) and on credibility (whether the accused tells the truth). Hayne J described the same two uses in different words.
Neither use applies automatically. Gummow J said the facts of the case and the type of good character evidence shape the jury’s reasoning. In Melbourne, witnesses called the accused quiet, gentle and amiable, with no adverse police record. McHugh J held this said nothing about his credibility; it only went to the unlikelihood he offended.
Good character can also help prove a defence the accused must establish. In Braysich, a stockbroker relied on a statutory defence, bearing the burden of proving he lacked a dishonest purpose, on the balance of probabilities. French CJ, Crennan and Kiefel JJ held his honesty could support an argument that a dishonest purpose was improbable, and was important to whether that burden was met. The Court of Appeal wrongly dismissed it as irrelevant to his subjective purpose. Heydon and Bell JJ dissented.
Is a direction required? Melbourne
In Melbourne, the High Court refused to say a good character direction is always required. McHugh, Gummow and Hayne JJ formed the majority, each giving separate reasons.
Hayence J said there is no fixed rule that a direction must always be given. But if the judge does give one, it must be legally correct.
McHugh J said it is a discretion. The trial judge decides whether to direct, based on whether the evidence bears on propensity (likelihood of guilt from character), credibility, both, or neither. Whether the judge got it wrong depends on the specific facts. Here, he thought a credibility direction would have wrongly favoured the accused.
Gummow J agreed with Hayne J, but also endorsed a view from a dissenting New Zealand judgment: where evidence is genuinely probative and relevant, a direction will almost always follow.
Hayne J also noted one situation where a direction is clearly needed. If prosecution and defence disagree about whether the evidence applies to propensity or credibility, the judge must correct this. The jury must be told it can be used for either or both purposes.
Kirby and Callinan JJ dissented. They thought a credibility direction should have been given. Kirby J preferred the English and New Zealand approach, which treated such directions as standard practice. The majority noted these foreign decisions are only persuasive, not binding, and declined to follow them.
Where the uniform Acts fit
The Commonwealth Act’s Part 3.8 applies only in criminal proceedings (s 109). It governs what character evidence can be led and what reply it allows. Under s 112, cross-examining a defendant on character evidence needs leave first.
Part 3.8 is silent on what juries should be told about using good character evidence. That gap is filled by Melbourne and Braysich.
In Victoria, the Jury Directions Act 2015 also governs jury directions, for provisions where Part 3 applies (s 10 excludes general directions and directions another provision requires or forbids). Counsel must request directions (s 12).
The judge must give a requested direction unless there are good reasons not to (s 14), and must not give one that wasn’t requested (s 15) — unless the judge finds substantial and compelling reasons to give it anyway (s 16).
The passage does not say how this Act applies specifically to a good character direction. Any Victorian answer must start from this Act.
Applying this in a problem question
Work through six steps when answering a problem question.
First, check the evidence is admissible. Ask whether the defendant led good character evidence generally, or about a particular trait, under s 110(1). Then check what reply this opens up under s 110(2) or (3).
Next, work out what the evidence shows. Does it go to propensity (the accused’s tendency to act a certain way), to credibility, to both, or to neither?
Then link the evidence to the trial issues. This includes any defence the accused must prove, as shown in Braysich.
Check whether a direction was sought, and whether the parties disagreed about how the evidence could be used.
Apply Melbourne: a direction is not always required. But if one is given, it must be accurate. If the parties disagree about the use of the evidence, the judge must state the true position.
In a Victorian jury trial, first work through the request provisions of the Jury Directions Act 2015 (Vic), before turning to the common law.
Self-check
Before moving on, test yourself on four things.
First, can you tell the difference between character and reputation? Also check you can separate good character generally from good character in one particular respect, like honesty.
Second, name the two uses of good character evidence. Then say which one fits the facts you are working with.
Third, remember who formed the majority in Melbourne. Also recall what Kirby and Callinan JJ would have held instead.
Finally, explain how good character evidence helped the accused in Braysich. Remember this is despite him carrying the burden of proof on his defence.
Where the authority sits
Section 110 covers how good character evidence is admitted and replied to. The Commonwealth, NSW, Victorian, Tasmanian, ACT and Northern Territory Acts all use the same wording, with minor differences (Victoria says “accused” not “defendant”; the ACT says “presented” not “adduced”).
Two cases guide how this evidence is used and when a jury direction is needed: Melbourne and Braysich. Melbourne came from a Northern Territory murder trial where the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) did not apply. Braysich came from a Western Australian trial under the Corporations Law.
High Court decisions bind all lower Australian courts, but the High Court can later reconsider its own rulings.
Western Australia has passed its own uniform evidence Act, but the main provisions are not yet in force. The linked article explains this transition.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.