Proving the contents of a document
The original document rule is gone
Under the old common law, you generally had to produce the original document to prove its contents.
Section 51 of the Evidence Act changes this. It abolishes the common law rules about proving document contents.
This is a clean break from the old system. Old ideas like “secondary evidence” no longer apply under the Act.
Two limits on the methods
Two rules limit how these methods work.
Section 48(3) limits proof by admission. If a party relies on s 48(1)(a), the admission can only be used in that specific dispute, between the party who made it and the party relying on it. It is not evidence for any other purpose.
Section 49 limits proof for documents located in a foreign country. None of the other paragraphs in s 48(1) can be used for such a document, unless the party relying on it serves a copy on every other party. This must happen at least 28 days before the evidence is used, or whatever other period the regulations or court rules set. The court can also simply direct that the paragraph applies anyway.
Section 49 is narrow. It only limits the paragraphs of s 48(1), so it does not stop a party from tendering the original document itself. It also leaves s 48(4) untouched.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by naming the document. Decide what the party wants to prove: that it exists, or what it says.
If proving contents, check whether the original is tendered, or a s 48(1) method is used instead. Name the method used.
Check s 48(4). This asks if the document is unavailable, or if its existence and contents aren’t disputed. If s 48(4) applies, read s 48(4)(b) of the governing Act before explaining the witness method.
Once contents are proved, return to the ordinary rules. Check relevance, and check hearsay if the document is tendered for the truth of what it asserts (hearsay means using a statement to prove the fact stated, not just that it was said).
Don’t raise arguments about originals versus secondary evidence. Section 51 abolished that old framework.
If relying on the public-document method, work through s 48(1)(f) carefully. Some State and Territory versions of (f)(i) name a person authorised on the government’s behalf; the Commonwealth and ACT versions don’t. But (f)(ii) appears in every Act, and covers printing done under a government’s authority.
Self-check
Before citing s 48(1), name the exact method the party relies on. Don’t just assert the document “is admissible” — be specific.
Check s 48(4) first. Don’t assume the original document is required without checking this.
Keep proof of a document’s contents separate from the question of admissibility — these are different issues.
Some Acts name an authorised government representative under s 48(1)(f)(i); others don’t. Either way, s 48(1)(f)(ii) is always a separate, available option.
Read s 48(4)(b) in the specific Act that governs your case. Don’t assume every Act offers the same witness-based route in identical terms.
If arguing a document is unavailable, identify the specific paragraph of cl 5, Part 2 of the Dictionary you rely on — don’t just assert unavailability.
A worked application
A plaintiff wants to prove a supply agreement’s terms. The defendant holds the signed original. The plaintiff only has an emailed PDF and a summary its manager wrote at the time.
The PDF counts as a copy made by a reproducing device, so s 48(1)(b) applies on its face. The plaintiff need not prove it checked the copy against the original.
The summary is not a copy, so s 48(1)(b) does not help it. But if the original is unavailable to the plaintiff, s 48(4) lets the plaintiff tender the summary, or call a witness to give evidence of the contents instead.
Whether a document is “unavailable” is fixed by clause 5 of Part 2 of the Dictionary, not general impression. A document is unavailable only if one of clause 5’s listed situations applies.
Here, clause 5(e)(ii) fits: the document is outside the plaintiff’s possession or control, and is held by another party (the defendant) who knows, or should reasonably know, its contents may be relevant. This alone makes it unavailable — the plaintiff need not first try and fail to get it produced.
Clause 5(e)(iii) covers a different situation, and should not be confused with (ii). It applies where the other party once held the document, and knew (or should have known) at that past time that it might be relevant. The knowledge required is tied to that earlier possession, not to the present. Other paragraphs, like clause 5(a), impose their own conditions — for example, requiring reasonable inquiry and search. So the particular paragraph relied on must be identified.
If the defendant simply admits the terms, s 48(1)(a) offers the quickest path. But s 48(3) limits what that admission can prove: it only works in the plaintiff’s case against the admitting defendant, or that defendant’s case against the plaintiff. It proves nothing against a second defendant who made no admission.
Finally, if the agreement is held overseas, s 49 adds a further requirement to the s 48(1) methods. Each of s 48(1)(b) to (f) requires serving a copy of the document on every other party at least 28 days beforehand — unless regulations or court rules set a different period.
Where the authority sits
Proof of a document’s contents is set by statute. The Commonwealth Act’s Part 2.2, “Documents”, governs this. Section 51 abolishes the old common law rules about how you prove a document.
The same provisions apply across several jurisdictions: s 51, s 48(1)(a)–(e), s 48(2), s 48(3) and s 48(4)(a). This uniform position holds in the Commonwealth, New South Wales, Victoria, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory. The differences are only drafting ones — the ACT uses “present” instead of “adduce”, and Tasmania’s heading reads “Proof of contents of document”.
The explanatory notes are not consistent, though. New South Wales, Victoria, the ACT and the Northern Territory attach notes to s 48 and s 51 pointing to s 182 and Part 2.2 of the Commonwealth Act. Tasmania’s equivalent sections carry no notes at all.
Two provisions break from the usual pattern of differences. Subparagraph 48(1)(f)(i), the authorised-person printing limb, appears in New South Wales, Victoria, Tasmania and the Northern Territory, but not in the Commonwealth or the ACT. Paragraph 48(4)(b) names a witness in every Act except Tasmania’s, which instead requires oral evidence — so you must identify the relevant court before applying either rule.
Queensland and South Australia have not adopted the uniform scheme for their own courts. Western Australia has enacted it but not brought it into force. Its Evidence Act 2025 (WA) renumbers the scheme’s provisions — the unavailability definition, found at cl 5 of Part 2 of the Dictionary in the uniform Acts, sits at s 8 in the WA Act.
Under the WA Act’s own s 2, only Part 1 and s 384 have commenced so far. That s 2 does not treat the remaining provisions the same way — a distinction that matters if you need a commencement date. Paragraph (e) is the proclamation limb, and proclamation has occurred: Parts 2 to 9, the rest of Part 10, Part 11, and Part 12 Divisions 2 to 7 and 9 to 24 commence on 18 September 2027.
Paragraphs (c) and (d) work differently. They set conditional commencement, tied to other Acts: Part 12 Division 1 depends on s 240 of the Aquatic Resources Management Act 2016, and Part 12 Division 17 depends on s 158 of the Privacy and Responsible Information Sharing Act 2024. Division 17 ends up commencing on 18 September 2027 anyway, through its conditional link. Division 1 does not reach that date — it commences immediately after the Aquatic Resources provision does.
Part 12 Division 8 will never commence. The provision it was meant to amend has been deleted.
None of this changes the answer for this article.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.