Trust money and trust accounts under the Uniform Law

States the trust-money scheme in Chapter 4 Part 4.2 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law for the three jurisdictions in which that Law is in force: what counts as trust money and what is excluded, which account the money must go into and by when, how it may be held, disbursed and withdrawn, the prohibition on intermixing, the deficiency offence, and the record-keeping, irregularity-reporting and annual external-examination machinery.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
nsw, vic, wa
Subjects
ethics-and-professional-responsibility
Topics
trust-account-awareness

Learning outcomes

  • Characterise money received by a law practice as trust money or not under s 129 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law, including the six categories s 129(2) excludes, and state the written notice s 134 then requires.
  • State where trust money must be deposited and by when, and explain how a written direction, controlled money, transit money and cash each change the answer.
  • State how trust money must be held, disbursed and withdrawn, identify what a practice may lawfully take for its own legal costs, and apply the prohibition on intermixing.
  • Apply the trust-account deficiency offence on its own terms, and identify the record-keeping, irregularity-reporting and annual external-examination obligations that make a deficiency discoverable.

Money a law practice receives is either trust money or it is not, and that characterisation decides where it must be deposited, who may deal with it, and whether a shortfall is a bookkeeping failure or a criminal offence. Chapter 4 Part 4.2 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law answers those questions provision by provision; why client money is held separately is treated in Trust account awareness. This article states that Part as it applies in New South Wales, Victoria and Western Australia, the three jurisdictions whose own Acts give the Uniform Law force.1

What counts as trust money, and what does not

Trust money is “money entrusted to a law practice in the course of or in connection with the provision of legal services”, and expressly includes legal costs received in advance of the services, controlled money, transit money, and money subject to a power exercisable by the practice or an associate to deal with it for another person.2

Six categories are then carved out by s 129(2), and the carve-outs are where the obvious answer inverts: money for legal services already provided and billed; money for a managed investment scheme or mortgage financing undertaken by the practice; money for a financial service requiring an Australian financial services licence or provided as another’s representative; money for investment purposes, unless the ordinary-course conditions in s 129(2)(d) are met; money determined under s 152 not to be trust money; and money the Uniform Rules so declare.

Money outside the definition still attracts a duty: where it is non-trust money under s 129(2)(c)-(f), other than money for payment of legal costs due to the practice, s 134 requires written notice to the person who provided it that the money is not trust money, that the trust-money provisions do not apply, and that no fidelity fund claim can be made for it.

Where trust money must be deposited

A practice must deal with trust money “in accordance with this Law and the Uniform Rules and not otherwise”, and only the practice or an associate may deal with it (s 135).3 It may not receive trust money at all unless a principal holds a practising certificate authorising receipt, or the Uniform Rules authorise it (s 150).

Trust money other than cash must go into the practice’s general trust account — an account with an authorised deposit-taking institution, which a practice receiving trust money to which the Part applies must maintain in the jurisdiction (s 136(1)) — as soon as practicable after receipt. That obligation yields to a written direction from a person legally entitled to give one, to controlled or transit money, and to money subject to a power (s 137).

Controlled money — money the practice is directed in writing to deposit in an account it will exclusively control rather than the general trust account — must be held exclusively for the person on whose behalf it was received and disbursed only under that direction or a later written one (s 139). Transit money must be paid or delivered to the third party as its instructions require, or else as soon as practicable (s 140). Cash is stricter still: trust money received as cash, other than controlled money, goes into the general trust account even where a written direction says otherwise, and may be dealt with under the direction only once deposited (s 143(1)).

Holding, disbursing and withdrawing

Trust money in a general trust account must be held “exclusively for the person on whose behalf it is received” and disbursed only in accordance with that person’s direction, subject to a court order or other authority of law (s 138).4 Withdrawal may be made only by cheque or electronic funds transfer (s 144(1)).

Section 144(2) preserves what a practice may still take for itself: a lien, including a general retaining lien, for legal costs reasonably due and owing where it is otherwise entitled to one; a withdrawal for legal costs owing to it, if the Uniform Rules’ procedures are complied with; and dealing with a balance as unclaimed money after deducting costs properly owing. Against that stands s 146, which forbids mixing trust money with other money unless the designated local regulatory authority has authorised it, on its conditions.

Section 145 gives the separation effect against third parties: money standing to the credit of a trust account is “not available for the payment of debts of the law practice or any of its associates”, and is not liable to be attached or taken in execution against the practice or an associate. It does not protect money to which the practice or associate is entitled.

Deficiency, records and external examination

Section 148 is where a shortfall becomes an offence. A law practice, an Australian legal practitioner or any other person must not, without reasonable excuse, cause “a deficiency in any trust account or trust ledger account” or a failure to pay or deliver any trust money; the penalty is 500 penalty units or imprisonment for 5 years, or both.5 The section states no element of dishonesty: causing the deficiency without reasonable excuse is what it prohibits. Elsewhere the sanction is a civil penalty — 50 penalty units for most of the obligations stated here, 100 under s 137 and 250 under s 150.

Trust records must be kept in permanent form and in accordance with the Uniform Rules, in a way that “at all times discloses the true position in relation to trust money received” and lets them be conveniently and properly investigated or externally examined, for seven years after the last transaction entry or the finalisation of the matter, whichever is later (s 147). A legal practitioner associate of the practice, an authorised deposit-taking institution or an external examiner aware of an irregularity in a trust account or trust ledger account must notify the designated local regulatory authority in writing as soon as practicable (s 154).

A practice must also, once in each financial year, have its trust records externally examined by a suitably qualified person appointed under the Uniform Rules, who reports in writing to that authority as soon as practicable after completing the examination (ss 155(1), 159(1)). A practice whose only trust money in a financial year is transit money need not have its records examined for that year (s 155(4)).

What the Part leaves to other law

Part 4.2 applies only in connection with legal services the practice provides, and whether it reaches money received outside the jurisdiction depends on where the practice has offices (s 130).6 The Uniform Rules may disapply or modify specified provisions, and the regulatory authority may exempt a particular practice on conditions. Much of the operating detail sits in those Rules rather than in the Law (s 168) and is not stated here, nor are the trust-money rules of Queensland, South Australia, Tasmania, the Australian Capital Territory and the Northern Territory: those five are not Uniform Law jurisdictions and each has its own legal profession statute.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Confirm the jurisdiction is a Uniform Law jurisdiction: New South Wales, Victoria and Western Australia are, and a section number quoted for any of the other five is unsupported.
  2. Characterise the money first. Work through s 129(1), then every limb of s 129(2), asking whether a bill has already been given; if the money falls outside, ask whether s 134 requires written notice.
  3. Work out which category the money falls into, and note that a written direction does not decide all of them. Controlled money is money in respect of which the practice has a written direction to deposit it in an account other than a general trust account over which the practice has or will have exclusive control; transit money depends not on a written direction but on instructions to pay or deliver the money to a third party other than an associate of the practice; and money subject to a power given to the practice or an associate to deal with it for another person is dealt with separately again (s 128, s 137(c)). Section 137 requires trust money other than cash to go into the general trust account as soon as practicable unless one of those three things applies, or unless there is a written direction by a person legally entitled to give it to deal with the money otherwise. Cash is governed by s 143 and splits two ways: cash that is not controlled money goes into the general trust account even if there is a written direction to deal with it some other way, and may then be dealt with in accordance with that direction (s 143(1)), while controlled money received as cash goes into a controlled money account and is dealt with under the Uniform Rules (s 143(2)).
  4. For a withdrawal, or a payment of the practice’s own costs, ask whether s 144(2) authorises it; for any mingling of funds, start from s 146.
  5. For a shortfall, apply s 148 on its own terms — caused, without reasonable excuse — not by asking whether the practitioner was dishonest, and identify who had to notify the regulator under s 154.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.