Conflicts of interest

Conflicts between current clients

This conflict happens when a lawyer, or their firm, acts for two or more current clients. It arises if those clients’ interests are, or might become, opposed in the same or a related matter.

This can happen when clients are on opposite sides of a deal or dispute. It can also happen if fully advising one client would mean using or disclosing information that harms another current client.

The problem is that a lawyer owes every current client full loyalty and full disclosure. Often a lawyer cannot give both clients everything they are owed at the same time.

Conflicts between the lawyer’s own interest and a client’s

A lawyer’s own interests can sometimes clash with a client’s. This happens if the lawyer has money riding on the outcome, a personal tie to the other side, or would gain from steering advice a certain way.

Lawyers are meant to give independent, clear-headed judgement. A real personal interest like this can threaten that independence.

This is true even if the lawyer is acting honestly and in good faith.

Responding to a conflict

When a lawyer finds a conflict, there are usually only a few ways to deal with it.

One option is fully informed consent. Each affected client must get full and frank disclosure, then freely agree to the lawyer continuing. Consent without proper disclosure does not count, and some conflicts are too serious for consent to fix at all.

Another option is an information barrier, sometimes called an ethical wall. This is a structural arrangement stopping confidential information passing between lawyers acting for clients with conflicting interests. It can suit some former-client conflicts.

Under Prince Jefri Bolkiah v KPMG, once a former client shows the firm holds relevant confidential information, the firm must prove there is no real risk it will reach the opposing side. Lord Millett said a proper barrier should be part of the firm’s normal structure, not set up just for one case. But he also said barriers can still work even if not pre-existing. In PhotoCure ASA v Queen’s University at Kingston, a single Federal Court judge accepted a barrier made for that matter, since other measures showed no real risk of disclosure.

Finally, the lawyer may need to decline or stop acting. If consent or a barrier cannot properly manage the conflict, the lawyer must refuse the new matter or stop acting for one or more clients. This is often the safest choice, and is required when the conflict cannot be fixed another way.

Why this matters beyond the individual client

Conflicts rules don’t just protect the individual client involved.

They also protect trust in the lawyer–client relationship more broadly.

And they protect the administration of justice (the fair running of court cases), where a conflict could harm proceedings.

This is why clients can’t simply agree privately to waive these rules. The public interest in trustworthy legal representation matters too.

Applying this in a problem question

First, work out exactly which duties clash. This could be current client against current client, the lawyer’s own interest against a client’s, or current client against former client.

Next, ask if a conflict actually exists. Look at the real overlap in the matters and information involved. For current clients, ask whether their interests are adverse, and whether there is a conflict, or potential conflict, between the duties to act in each client’s best interests (in NSW, see ASCR r 11.2). An actual clash doesn’t need to have happened yet. For a former client, ask whether there is a real risk — not just a fanciful or theoretical one — that confidential information will be used against them.

Then consider consent. Has fully informed consent been given, or could it be? Also check whether this type of conflict can be cured by consent at all.

For a former-client conflict, if consent won’t work, ask whether an effective information barrier could remove any real risk of disclosure. But for conflicts between current clients, or between a lawyer’s own interest and a client’s, a barrier alone is not enough to replace consent — check what the relevant conduct rules actually permit.

Finally, if neither consent nor a barrier properly resolves the conflict, the lawyer or firm must decline to act, or stop acting. Explain why that conclusion follows.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.