Postponing an earlier equitable interest: Heid v Reliance Finance

The facts

Mr Heid owned land at Glenhaven. In 1977 he orally agreed to sell it to Connell Investments for $165,000. Part of the price was to be paid in cash, part deposited with another company, and $50,000 secured by a mortgage.

An unqualified employee, Peter Gibby, was introduced as able to act for both sides. Mr Heid signed a contract and transfer, and the transfer wrongly acknowledged that the full price had been paid. He let the bank release the title certificate to Gibby.

The $100,000 deposit was never paid. It was agreed Mr Heid held a vendor’s lien for that amount. A vendor’s lien is a right a seller keeps over land to secure unpaid price.

Mr McKay used these documents to borrow money. Reliance Finance advanced $80,000 to Connell Investments, relying on the transfer’s false acknowledgment of payment. It registered the transfer before Mr Heid lodged any caveat. A caveat is a notice protecting a claimed interest in land.

Mr Alexander later advanced $40,000 and lodged a caveat, but did not register his mortgage. Neither lender knew of Mr Heid’s claim when they lent the money.

At trial, Kearney J ranked Mr Heid’s lien ahead of both mortgages. The Court of Appeal reversed this, postponing his lien to both lenders’ interests. The High Court dismissed Mr Heid’s appeal.

Gibbs CJ held Mr Alexander was in the same position as Reliance Finance. Although Mr Alexander never saw the transfer, the registered transfer let Connell Investments represent it held good title, subject to Reliance Finance’s interest. This finding was not challenged on appeal.

The starting point and the exception

Gibbs CJ relied on Latec Investments Ltd v Hotel Terrigal Pty Ltd. The general rule: where two equitable interests are equally meritorious, the earlier one wins.

But there’s an exception. If the earlier interest holder’s conduct led the later party to believe no earlier interest existed, priority can shift to the later interest. Mason and Deane JJ agreed with this principle.

On the facts, Mr Heid held the earlier interest. He gave Gibby a completed transfer and the certificate of title, letting Connell Investments appear free of other equitable claims.

The key question was whether this conduct gave Reliance Finance, the later interest holder, the better equity.

Three explanations of the result

All judges reached the same result, but gave different reasons.

Gibbs CJ, with Wilson J agreeing, used the idea of estoppel. This means a person who creates a false impression cannot later deny it, if someone relied on that impression in good faith. He said giving Connell Investments the documents let it appear as the true owner. No direct statement to the lender was needed. Reliance Finance had relied on this appearance. Gibbs CJ also said failing to lodge a caveat (a formal notice protecting an interest in land) was not fatal to the vendor’s case. But lodging one promptly would have warned lenders.

Mason and Deane JJ did not rely only on estoppel. They said estoppel could not explain all postponement cases, especially since the misleading statement usually comes from the third party, not the original interest-holder. Instead, they preferred a flexible test: whichever party has the “better equity” should prevail, after weighing all circumstances.

They said courts must assess the earlier interest-holder’s conduct. The question is whether fairness requires postponing the earlier interest to the later one. A mere causal link between the earlier holder’s conduct and the later party’s assumption may not be enough. What matters is whether it was reasonably foreseeable that such a later interest and assumption would arise.

Applying this, they pointed to two facts: the vendor signed a transfer acknowledging payment that had not occurred, undermining his own lien, and he left that transfer and authority to collect the title certificate with a person he believed was a solicitor, but who actually worked for the purchaser’s associated group.

The caveat and the ordinary solicitor

Two points limit the main rule here. First, not lodging a caveat (a notice protecting an interest in land) does not automatically defeat an earlier equitable owner’s priority. Mason and Deane JJ said it is only one factor in deciding whether it is unfair for that owner to keep priority, even if the later party searched the register and found nothing.

Second, the judges disagreed about solicitors. Gibbs CJ did not decide whether the rule applies when documents go to a solicitor in the normal way. Mason and Deane JJ agreed that normally a vendor’s own solicitor misusing documents is not a foreseeable risk of handing them over.

Murphy J disagreed with this narrower approach. He said it made no difference whether the recipient was genuinely believed to be a solicitor, actually was one, or worked for the purchaser.

For Gibbs CJ and for Mason and Deane JJ, it mattered that the documents went to an employee of the purchaser’s group, alongside the receipted transfer and the lenders relying on it. Murphy J used a broader test instead.

What the case does not decide

Heid v Reliance Finance decides its own facts. The judges did not all agree on one reason for the result.

Mason and Deane JJ reasoned using “the better equity” -- asking whose claim was stronger in fairness. Gibbs CJ used estoppel by arming instead -- this is where someone’s conduct lets another person appear to have more rights than they do. Wilson J agreed with Gibbs CJ.

The case involved unregistered equitable interests in land in New South Wales. Murphy J described it as a contest between unregistered interests under the Real Property Act 1900 (NSW).

This summary does not cover the caveat and priority rules in each State’s legislation.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by classifying each competing interest as legal, equitable, or a mere equity, and noting when it was created. The basic rule is that if the merits are equal, the earlier equitable interest wins.

But check whether the earlier interest holder acted in a way that let someone else believe no earlier interest existed. This could be a signed transfer wrongly acknowledging payment, handing over title documents, or failing to take a protective step.

Then ask whether the later interest holder gave value, had no notice of the earlier interest, and relied on the assumption it did not exist.

Next, consider fairness and estoppel. Mason and Deane JJ asked whether it would be unfair, in all the circumstances, for the earlier holder to keep priority. Gibbs CJ asked a separate question: whether the earlier holder was estopped (stopped from asserting their interest because of their own conduct). In Heid, both approaches reached the same outcome.

A missing caveat (a formal notice protecting an interest in land) is just one relevant circumstance. It does not automatically mean priority is lost.

Finally, state the authority carefully. In Heid, the judges agreed on the outcome but gave different reasons, and the case involved unregistered interests in New South Wales.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.