Fiduciary obligations: scope and limits

The undertaking, and the judges who disagreed about it

Quick Read: In Hospital Products Ltd v United States Surgical Corp (1984) 156 CLR 41, a distributor copied the manufacturer’s products using its distributorship. The case sets out signs of a fiduciary relationship, a relationship of trust where one person must act in another’s interests.

Mason J said the key feature is an “undertaking”: acting for or in the interests of another, using a power that affects that person’s interests, leaving them vulnerable to abuse.

But Mason J was in the minority. Gibbs CJ, Wilson J and Dawson J found no fiduciary relationship existed at all. Mason J alone would have found one, limited to the manufacturer’s local goodwill. Deane J was not convinced a fiduciary duty existed, but would still have imposed a constructive trust, a court-ordered duty to hold property for another, based on breach of contract.

The appeal succeeded, so the manufacturer only got contract damages, not fiduciary remedies.

Despite losing, Mason J’s test became the one later courts actually use. The majority in Pilmer adopted it, and French CJ and Keane J relied on his reasoning about why fiduciary duties exist, in Howard v Commissioner of Taxation.

Two more of Mason J’s points are regularly applied. First, someone can be a fiduciary for some activities but not others. Second, where a contract exists, the fiduciary duty must fit around the contract’s terms, not change what the contract was meant to do.

Why commercial and professional dealings are usually not fiduciary

Some things do not create a fiduciary relationship. Gibbs CJ said that one person subjectively trusting another is not enough, and is not even necessary. Unequal bargaining power alone is also not enough.

What matters more is the opposite sign. If a deal is purely commercial, with parties at arm’s length and on equal footing, that weighs heavily against finding a fiduciary duty. Dawson J went further: applying fiduciary remedies here would distort the doctrine and create uncertainty for parties dealing as equals.

Hiring a professional does not change this. In Pilmer v Duke Group Ltd (in liq), accountants were engaged to value a company and give an independent expert opinion, as a listing rule required. They did the work incompetently, and the trial judge found they were not independent.

The majority (McHugh, Gummow, Hayne and Callinan JJ) agreed there was no fiduciary relationship. The accountants were not agents, had no influence or ascendancy over the client, and the client did not depend on them in the relevant sense. Expecting competent, independent work is different from a fiduciary relationship. Kirby J dissented, finding a fiduciary duty existed and was breached.

Fiduciary for what?

Calling a relationship fiduciary does not finish the job. Courts must also work out what the duty actually covers, called its subject matter.

In Breen v Williams, a patient wanted access to her doctor’s records. Brennan CJ accepted the patient trusted her doctor, but found no fiduciary duty applied to this subject matter. The claim failed.

Howard reinforces this point. Directors bought a golf course personally through a joint venture, and recovered compensation after other venturers diverted it. One director argued he held his share on trust for the company.

French CJ and Keane J rejected this. They said fiduciary duties are not unlimited, even though courts sometimes describe them broadly. The duty’s scope must fit the relationship it comes from.

Directors are often also shareholders. Promoting the company’s interests while also benefiting personally does not, by itself, breach their fiduciary duty.

What loyalty does not require

In Breen, the patient lost before all six judges. The key reason: Australian fiduciary law is only proscriptive. This means it stops fiduciaries doing certain things, like taking unauthorised benefits or facing conflicts of interest. If a fiduciary breaches this, they must hand over profits and cover losses.

But fiduciary law does not impose positive duties, meaning it does not force a fiduciary to actively act in the other person’s interests. A right to access records would have been this kind of positive duty. So fiduciary law could not create it.

Gummow J drew a further distinction. A trustee’s specific duties (following the trust’s terms, taking reasonable care) come from being a trustee, meaning someone who holds legal title for others’ benefit. These duties don’t come from being a fiduciary generally.

This means fiduciaries in general don’t have a broad duty to always act in their principal’s best interests. The majority in Pilmer agreed with this reasoning.

Proving the breach, and what follows from it

To prove a breach, the student must show what conflicted, or how the benefit came from the position itself.

On conflict, the majority in Pilmer said the conflicting duty or interest must be clearly identified. Past dealings do not count, since finished dealings usually end any related duty. A general hope of future work does not count either, because most advisers hope good work brings clients back. In Howard, Hayne and Crennan JJ said simply repeating the rule’s wording is not enough for directors.

On the second rule, Hayne and Crennan JJ asked whether the gain came by reason of, or by using, the position, or knowledge or opportunity it gave. Here it did not: the opportunity came through a joint venture, not the office itself. French CJ and Keane J confirmed this: with no conflict and no gain from the position, there is no liability to account.

Where a breach is proven, Gummow J in Breen identified two remedies. The court can order an account of the benefit gained, or, if the breach caused loss rather than gain, equitable compensation under earlier authority. Informed consent, however, can answer what would otherwise be a breach.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by finding the undertaking. Ask what power or discretion it gave one person over another’s interests.

Trust, reliance or unequal bargaining power alone are not enough. They cannot replace an actual undertaking.

If there is a contract, read it first. Ask whether the duty claimed fits the contract’s terms, rather than changing them.

Pin down exactly what the obligation covers. Then test the conduct against that specific subject matter, not against loyalty in general.

Point to the actual conflicting duty or interest. Or show how the benefit gained traces back to the position held.

If the real complaint is carelessness or failure to disclose, that belongs in contract, tort or statute, not fiduciary duty.

Where the authority sits

This section relies on four High Court of Australia decisions. These bind every Australian court, so the principles apply nationwide.

No legislation is cited here. Whether a fiduciary obligation exists, and its extent, are matters of general law, not statute.

In two of the four cases, the judges disagreed on the outcome. In all four, the judges gave separate reasons.

Because of this, you should attribute each proposition to the specific judge whose reasons state it.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.