Assignment and priorities
Assigning a chose in action
A chose in action is a right you can’t physically hand over, like a debt or a contractual right. Shares and trust interests count too. It is assigned in one of two ways.
The first is statutory assignment. Property legislation in each state allows a legal assignment of a debt if it is absolute, in writing signed by the assignor, and notice is given to the debtor. The notice requirement differs by state: NSW needs “express notice in writing” (Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) s 12), Queensland needs “actual notice” (Property Law Act 2023 (Qld) s 190(2)).
Meet all three conditions and the assignee gets the legal right, and can sue the debtor directly. Miss one, the assignment isn’t void, but no legal right passes. It may still work in equity, depending on equity’s own rules. For a gift, equity treats it as complete once the donor has done everything necessary to transfer legal title (Corin v Patton (1990) 169 CLR 540).
The second way is equitable assignment. No particular form is needed, apart from the statutory writing rules above. You just need a clear intention to assign now, and the subject matter must be identifiable.
Notice to the debtor isn’t needed for the assignment to be valid between assignor and assignee (Thomas v National Australia Bank Ltd [1999] QCA 525). But notice still matters practically: it generally stops the debtor validly paying the assignor instead, it cuts off some (not all) defences the debtor could raise against the assignee, and under the rule in Dearle v Hall, it can fix priority against later assignees.
For an account covered by the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth), s 80 sets the position. The transferee takes the debt subject to the contract’s terms, and subject to existing equities, defences, claims and set-offs, plus other claims against the transferor that arose before payment to the transferor stops discharging the debt.
Future property
Future property means things not yet existing or owned, like royalties under an unmade licence. You cannot assign future property at law, because there is nothing yet to assign.
In equity, an attempt to assign future property is treated differently. It is read as a promise to assign the property once the assignor acquires it, as explained in Norman v Federal Commissioner of Taxation. The assignee then gains an equitable interest as soon as the assignor acquires the property, provided it was clearly identified in advance.
This only works if the assignment was made for value. Equity will not help a volunteer, someone who gave nothing in return.
So a gratuitous assignment of future property fails completely. But a gratuitous assignment of existing property can still work, if the assignor does everything needed to complete it.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by identifying the subject matter. Ask whether it is existing property, or future property (property not yet in existence).
Check the assignment against the statutory requirements. If it fails them, ask whether it is still good in equity, and whether value was given.
Classify each competing interest as legal, equitable, or a mere equity (a weaker equitable claim), and note when each arose.
Apply the priority rule for that combination. Then ask whether notice, or conduct that postpones an interest, changes the result.
For an assignment of a debt or account, or one given by way of security, first ask whether the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) applies. This includes its definition of “account” and its exclusions. If it applies, use its priority rules instead.
For land, start with the Torrens statute, not general law principles.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.