Easements

Creation

There are four main ways an easement can be created.

Express grant or reservation is the usual way. A grant gives the easement to the purchaser. A reservation lets the vendor keep it. Under Torrens title, the legal easement exists once registered. Before registration, an equitable easement (one enforced in fairness, not yet formal) can arise if there is an enforceable agreement, made for value, to grant one. Whether this binds a later owner is a separate question.

Implication happens automatically on subdivision, in a few forms. An easement of necessity arises only if the land would otherwise be completely cut off — mere convenience is not enough. An easement of common intention arises where it is needed to fulfil the parties’ shared plan for using the land in a specific way. Under the rule in Wheeldon v Burrows, a purchaser gets existing quasi-easements (informal arrangements) that were obvious, ongoing, reasonably needed, and in use at the time of the grant. None of these implied easements will arise if the grant’s terms, or an underlying contract, say otherwise.

Prescription means an easement arises from long, open use — without force or permission — for the required period. It matters less under Torrens title, and some jurisdictions have cut it back or abolished it.

Statute is becoming more significant. In some jurisdictions, courts can impose an easement if it is reasonably necessary for using the dominant land, fits the public interest, and compensation is paid.

Extinguishment

At common law, an easement ends in three ways: express release, unity of ownership and possession of both tenements, or abandonment. Statute can change these common law rules.

In New South Wales, an easement created under s 88B of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) survives even if the benefited owner gains a greater interest in the burdened land (s 88B(3)(c)(iii)).

Abandonment needs more than long disuse. Courts need proof of an intention to give up the right permanently, and are reluctant to assume this.

Separately in New South Wales, the Registrar-General can cancel an easement’s record if unused for 20 years (Real Property Act 1900 (NSW) s 49). This power has exclusions and requires a notice process first.

Most jurisdictions also give courts statutory power to modify or end easements. This usually applies when an easement is obsolete, or blocks reasonable use without giving real benefit.

Remedies

If an easement is interfered with, the dominant owner can seek an injunction, a court order stopping the interference. Damages may be awarded instead, or as well.

The servient owner must not substantially interfere with the dominant owner’s use of the rights granted. This test does not weigh the servient owner’s wishes against the dominant owner’s rights (Lowe v Kladis, a carriageway case).

Self-help by abatement is available, meaning the dominant owner can remove an obstruction themselves. But doing this without notice is risky: if they are wrong about their rights, they may be liable for trespass.

When the extent of the parties’ rights is unclear, a declaration setting out the easement’s scope is often more useful. This is commonly sought alongside an injunction.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by asking whether the claimed right can be an easement. Apply the four characteristics in order, and say which one is doubtful.

Then check it is not really a licence, or, if the use is close to exclusive, a lease.

Work out how the easement was created. If implication might apply, name the specific form of implication and apply its own test, not a single general doctrine.

Under Torrens title, ask if the easement is registered. If it is not, find the specific statutory exception in the relevant Act, rather than relying on general principle. If the claim is an implied easement against a later registered proprietor, ask whether that proprietor’s conduct, or conduct of people they are responsible for, creates a personal equity (a personal claim against them based on fairness).

Finally, consider whether the easement has been extinguished, especially if the facts show long disuse or a change in ownership.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.