Defamation
The three elements
These are the three traditional elements of defamation. If the 2021 amendments apply, the plaintiff must also prove serious harm (explained below).
Publication means the matter was communicated to at least one person other than the plaintiff. This is broad: someone who republishes material is usually liable for their own publication. In Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd v Voller (2021) 273 CLR 346, the High Court held that a social media page administrator can publish comments posted by other people.
Publication has limits, though. In Google LLC v Defteros [2022] HCA 27, a 5-2 majority held a search engine was not a publisher merely by showing a search result with a hyperlink to a news article. Kiefel CJ and Gleeson J reasoned that the operator had not approved the article, contributed to it, provided a forum for it, or encouraged defamatory comment — merely facilitating access to another’s webpage was not participating in communication.
Gageler J agreed with that reasoning, and Edelman and Steward JJ reached the same result in separate joint reasons. Keane J and Gordon J dissented. The joint reasons noted that search results themselves could contain defamatory matter, and the case still affirmed the Voller principle: any voluntary act of participation in communicating defamatory matter makes someone a publisher.
In New South Wales, the position of online intermediaries is also set out in statute. The Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) exempts search engine providers, and caching, conduit and storage services, from liability on conditions in ss 10C and 10D. It also gives digital intermediaries a defence under s 31A, for causes of action accruing after these amendments commenced on 1 July 2024.
Whether other jurisdictions have similar provisions depends on their own legislation. The Northern Territory has had its own digital intermediary exemptions and defence since 11 August 2025, under ss 9C, 9D and 28A, with transitional rules in Part 7 Division 2.
Identification means the matter must be reasonably understood to refer to the plaintiff. Naming the plaintiff is not required.
Identification and multiple publications
The plaintiff must be identified by the matter, but does not need to be named. It is enough that reasonable readers who know extra facts would understand the matter refers to the plaintiff. The publisher’s intention does not matter, so even accidental identification counts.
If a group is defamed, a single member can only sue if the group is small enough, or the matter specific enough, to point to them personally.
Most jurisdictions now use the single publication rule. If matter is published to the public, and the same publisher (or someone linked to them) later republishes substantially the same matter, the limitation period runs from the first publication date. For electronic matter, this is the day it was first uploaded or sent, not each later download.
This rule has an exception: it does not apply if the later publication is materially different, for example in prominence or reach. This reverses the old position, where every download started a fresh limitation period.
Applying this in a problem question
First, work out the jurisdiction. Check whether the 2021 amendments apply there, since they affect the serious harm threshold and public interest defence.
Look at each imputation (the plaintiff’s claimed meaning) separately. Ask whether an ordinary reasonable reader, reading the whole publication, would find it defamatory.
Publication and identification usually need little discussion, unless the facts dispute them. Then consider serious harm, but only where the relevant Act includes it as an element. The Western Australian Act has no such requirement (s 33).
Check if a concerns notice is a precondition to suing under the applicable Act, and note what happens if none was given. In Western Australia this is different: under Division 1, a concerns notice only times an offer to make amends. It is not a precondition to suing there.
Next, go through the defences in the order a defendant would raise them. For each, state exactly what the defendant must prove.
Deal with remedies last. Cover the damages cap, aggravated damages (extra damages for the defendant’s bad conduct), and courts’ general reluctance to grant interlocutory injunctions (orders stopping publication before trial).
Self-check
Check which Defamation Act applies in your jurisdiction. Also check whether the 2021 reforms are in force there.
If the applicable Act includes a serious harm element, the plaintiff must prove it. It is not a defence. Western Australia has no such element. There, triviality under s 33 is a separate defence, and the defendant must prove it.
Test whether each pleaded imputation is actually carried. Read the publication as a whole to decide this.
Work out who bears the burden of proof for each defence raised.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.