Stalking and protective orders: offence elements and civil protection

Two routes to the same conduct

In Victoria, the same stalking conduct can lead to two different legal responses.

Section 21A of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) makes stalking a criminal offence. It carries a maximum of 10 years’ imprisonment (level 5).

Separately, a court can make an intervention order. This restrains future conduct. It follows an application, not a criminal charge, and does not result in a conviction.

A prosecution focuses on what the accused did and meant. An intervention order application focuses on what protection the applicant needs going forward.

The standards of proof differ. Intervention order Acts require the balance of probabilities — meaning it is more likely than not. This standard appears in s 74(1) of the Family Violence Protection Act 2008 (Vic) and s 61(1) of the Personal Safety Intervention Orders Act 2010 (Vic).

Section 21A itself sets no standard. Instead, the criminal standard comes from s 141(1) of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic): the prosecution must prove its case beyond reasonable doubt.

Facts proved on the balance of probabilities for an intervention order are not automatically proved to the criminal standard. These are separate tests for separate purposes.

Both intervention order provisions also require the court to look ahead. The court must be satisfied the respondent is likely to continue, or repeat, the conduct.

What counts as a course of conduct

Section 21A(1)(a) requires A to engage in a “course of conduct” toward B. Section 21A(1B) explains this needs two things.

First, repetition or duration: A acted on more than one occasion, or the conduct was protracted. Either is enough, so one long episode can qualify.

Second, continuity of purpose: the conduct must show a continuing purpose relating to B. This is the real limiting factor — unrelated incidents between the same people might satisfy the first element but fail this one.

The conduct must also fall within the list in s 21A(2). This includes following B or others, contacting them by any means, publishing material about them online, interfering with their computer, tracking their internet use, loitering nearby, interfering with their property, making threats, abusive or offensive words or acts, giving offensive material, and surveillance. A 2026 addition covers harming or threatening to harm an animal, either in front of B or another person, or where B or another person will learn of it.

Paragraph (g) is a catch-all. It covers any other conduct reasonably expected to cause B physical or mental harm (including self-harm), or to make B fear for their own safety or someone else’s.

Mental harm includes psychological harm and suicidal thoughts (s 21A(8)).

The offence can apply across state lines. Conduct done outside Victoria still counts if B was in Victoria at the time. Likewise, it doesn’t matter if B was outside Victoria, as long as the conduct happened in Victoria (s 21A(6), (7)).

The fault element

Section 21A(1)(c) gives two separate ways to prove fault. They are alternatives, not two versions of the same mental state.

Limb (i) asks what A actually thought. A either intended the course of conduct to cause a result in s 21A(3), or believed it probably would.

Limb (ii) asks what A ought to have understood, given all the circumstances, plus one more thing: the conduct must actually have caused that result. Without proof of actual harm or fear, limb (ii) is not made out.

Section 21A(3) describes these results: physical or mental harm to B (including self-harm), or B fearing for their own safety or someone else’s safety.

This structure is new law in Victoria. Section 67 of the Justice Legislation Amendment (Family Violence, Stalking and Other Matters) Act 2026 (Vic) replaced s 21A(1) and s 21A(3), added ss 21A(1A) and (1B), and removed the old intention wording from the end of s 21A(2). It started on 26 April 2026, under s 2(2) of that Act.

The result is that the fault element now lives entirely in s 21A(1)(c). The list of conduct in s 21A(2) no longer carries any state-of-mind requirement itself.

Breach is where a civil order meets the criminal law

Getting an intervention order is a civil process, but breaching it is a criminal offence. In Victoria, s 123 of the family violence Act and s 100 of the personal safety Act both ban contravening an order. The maximum penalty is 2 years’ imprisonment, a fine of 240 penalty units, or both.

Each offence has a precondition: the person must have been served with the order, or had it explained to them. Under s 123(1), this explanation must be under s 57(1), 60G(1) or 96(1). Under s 100(1), it must be under s 40 or s 76. If an order was neither served nor explained, the contravention offence does not apply.

This 2-year maximum under s 123 or s 100 is much lower than the 10-year maximum under s 21A.

A reform is coming but is not yet law. Section 37 of the 2026 amending Act would insert s 53AAA, requiring courts, where practicable, to consider misidentification of the respondent before making an interim order under s 53(1). This provision is in Division 3 of Part 2, which starts on a proclaimed date, or by 10 November 2026 at the latest. As at 30 September 2026, the consolidated Act does not yet include s 53AAA. So a question about a hearing before that commencement date must be answered using the unamended Act.

Applying this in a problem question

First, work out whether the facts suggest a prosecution, an application for a protective order, or both. State which, since the standard of proof and outcome differ.

Next, identify the jurisdiction. Use that jurisdiction’s own provision. Do not apply a section number or test from a different jurisdiction.

In Victoria, list the occasions involved. Ask if they were more than one or protracted, then separately ask if they show a continuity of purpose under s 21A(1B). Match at least one act to a paragraph of s 21A(2), naming that paragraph.

Deal with the fault element in two separate limbs. Limb (i) looks at the accused’s intention or belief. Limb (ii) looks at what the accused ought to have understood, plus proof the conduct actually caused harm or fear.

Check the exclusion in s 21A(4) and the defence in s 21A(4A). In each case, identify who carries the burden of proof.

For a protective order, ask first whether the parties are family members. If so, the application falls under the Family Violence Protection Act 2008 (Vic). If not, it falls under the Personal Safety Intervention Orders Act 2010 (Vic), s 61(1)(b). Either way, address the forward-looking element.

If an order already exists, first confirm service or explanation under s 123(1) or s 100(1). Only then treat a breach as an offence.

Self-check

Before answering, check a few things.

Say whether you’re dealing with an offence, an order, or both. Name the standard of proof the relevant provision sets out.

Treat repetition and continuity of purpose as two separate requirements. Argue each fault element on its own terms, not together.

State who carries the burden of proof for the exclusion and for the defence.

Decide which of the two Victorian Acts governs the relationship between the parties. Then check whether the other jurisdiction’s provision even requires repetition.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.