Dishonesty and claim of right in property offences

What the High Court said about “fraudulently”

Mr Macleod, a company director, used over $2 million of investors’ money for himself. He was charged under s 173 of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW), as it stood in the 1990s, with fraudulently applying company property for his own benefit. The High Court dismissed his appeal[^cite:macleod-v-the-queen-dishonesty].

Three points from the joint reasons matter. First, the sole shareholder’s “consent” did not excuse him. A self-interested consent given to further a crime against the company is not the company’s consent.

Second, the Court treated “fraudulently” as meaning the same as “dishonestly”. But it warned against borrowing reasoning from other offences without checking the specific section’s wording, scope and purpose.

Third, the Court adopted the approach from Peters v The Queen[^cite:peters-v-the-queen-dishonesty]. The trial judge identifies what knowledge, belief or intent is said to make the conduct dishonest. The jury decides whether the accused had that state of mind, and if so, whether the act was dishonest on that account. Where the question is dishonesty by ordinary notions, it is enough to ask whether ordinary, decent people would see it that way. McHugh J, writing separately, agreed with these same three steps.

The joint reasons added something important: there is no need to show the accused realised the conduct was dishonest by current standards of ordinary people. This rejects an extra step from the English case R v Ghosh, which required the accused to also realise that ordinary people would view the conduct as dishonest.

In Peters, the judges had split on this point. Kirby J said he preferred his own reasoning, but joined Toohey and Gaudron JJ to secure a majority holding. Macleod decided this point only under s 173, not under any other provisions.

Claim of right

Macleod treated claim of right this way: the prosecution must prove the intent that the crime requires. An honest belief that conflicts with that intent is a defence, even if the belief is unreasonable.

The claim of right must relate to an entitlement under civil law. Not knowing the criminal law is no claim of right at all.

The claim must be honest. It can still be unreasonable or unfounded, but then it is less likely to create reasonable doubt.

The accused carries the evidential burden, meaning they must point to some evidence of the claim. The prosecution then carries the persuasive burden of disproving it.

Where “fraudulently” means dishonest by ordinary standards, an honest, good-faith claim is inconsistent with fraud. No extra direction on a “subjective” claim of right was needed here.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by naming the State and the offence. Find the exact word the statute uses, such as “dishonestly”, “fraudulently”, or another defined term.

Check whether the statute actually defines that word. In New South Wales look at s 4B; in Victoria, s 73; in Queensland, ss 391, 408C(3) and 22(2).

Separate the facts showing what the accused knew, believed or intended from the separate question of whether those facts count as dishonest.

If the accused claims an entitlement to the property, ask three things: is it a claim to a civil right, was it honestly held, and which provision applies. Then identify who carries the evidential burden (the burden of pointing to some evidence) and who carries the persuasive burden (the burden of proving the point).

Do not assume that willingness to pay, an intent to restore the property, or the owner’s consent automatically answers the charge. Check this against the specific provision instead.

Remember that Macleod settled the position under s 173 only. For current State provisions, treat it as a guide, not a binding ruling.

Self-check

Check that you’ve correctly described Macleod. It deals with s 173. The High Court adopted the reasoning of Toohey and Gaudron JJ in Peters, but the Justices in Peters were themselves divided on this point.

Check you’ve used the right State’s statutory definition. Don’t borrow a definition from a different State’s Act.

Check you’ve explained claim of right correctly. It means an honest claim to a civil entitlement. Make sure you’ve said who carries each burden of proof.

Check you haven’t said the New South Wales definition overrules Macleod, or that it’s governed by Macleod. Neither claim is correct.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.