Automatism and insanity: defences that go to the mind

Two claims, two sections

This section looks at Queensland’s Code, which has two separate provisions.

Section 23(1)(a) says a person is not criminally responsible for an act or omission that happens independently of their will. This section is still subject to the Code’s own rules about negligent acts and omissions.

Section 27(1) deals with mental disease or natural mental infirmity. It excuses a person if that condition stops them understanding what they are doing, controlling their actions, or knowing they ought not to act.

In Falconer, Mrs Falconer shot her husband and claimed to remember nothing from his reaching for her to finding herself beside his body. Psychiatrists said a dissociative state could explain this gap, while still viewing her as sane.

The trial judge rejected this evidence, but the Western Australian Court of Criminal Appeal held it admissible on the question of whether her act was willed, and ordered a new trial. All seven High Court Justices agreed special leave should be granted and the Crown’s appeal dismissed, confirming the evidence was relevant to whether the act was willed.

The Justices did not agree on who bears the burden of proving what. That question is addressed separately.

For s 23, “the act” means the bodily movement plus any qualities it necessarily carries. In Falconer, Mason CJ, Brennan and McHugh JJ identified this as the discharge of the loaded gun, not the finger’s contraction or the resulting death. Gaudron J adopted the same identification.

Where sane and insane automatism part

The judges split sane from insane automatism using one legal test: did the state count as “mental disease or natural mental infirmity”? That’s a question of law. Whether the accused actually experienced it is a question of fact (Deane and Dawson JJ; Gaudron J).

Their tests differed. Gaudron J compared states normal people might experience (like after a head blow) to those they never would; a recurring abnormality suggested an infirm mind. The joint reasons asked if the malfunction was temporary, unlikely to recur, and one an ordinary person could also have suffered.

Deane and Dawson JJ thought non-disease causes would be rare, listing examples like some sleepwalking, some epilepsy, concussion, hypoglycaemia, and dissociative states.

This matters because the verdict differs. In Western Australia, where Falconer arose, s 653 of the Code required the jury to state if acquittal was due to unsoundness of mind, triggering custody until Her Majesty’s pleasure was known. The article doesn’t say what follows such a finding in Queensland today.

The insanity limbs

Section 27(1) of the Code lists three incapacities: not understanding what one is doing, not being able to control one’s actions, and not knowing one ought not do the act. In Falconer, the joint reasons noted the M’Naghten Rules only cover not knowing the act’s nature and quality, or not knowing it was wrong. Incapacity to control one’s actions is something the Code adds.

Section 27(2) deals with delusions. If a person has a delusion about a specific matter, and does not otherwise fit within s 27(1), they are still treated as responsible, as if the delusion were true.

At common law, Dixon J’s directions in Porter were cited in Falconer. Porter was a summing-up to a jury, not a Full Court decision. Dixon J said the mind must show disease, disorder or disturbance, not mere excitability, passion, stupidity, lack of self-control or impulsiveness.

Dixon J also said “wrong” means wrong by the standards of ordinary reasonable people, judged against the particular act and time. But Porter was decided at common law. It remains undecided whether this meaning of “wrong” also defines “ought not” in s 27(1) of the Code.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by naming the jurisdiction and the relevant provisions. If it isn’t Queensland, say the Code analysis may not apply, and check that jurisdiction’s own mental impairment statute instead.

Next, identify the act that caused the offence, and ask whether it was a willed bodily action. The result, like a death, is not the act itself.

Then ask what evidence displaces the presumption that someone who seems conscious acted voluntarily. A mere assertion or memory loss isn’t enough. Look for medical evidence naming the state, its cause, and confirming the accused experienced it.

Classify that state: is it something a healthy mind can experience, or an underlying mental disease or infirmity? Apply both the test from Gaudron J and the test from the joint reasons, noting they differ.

Order your analysis as the four-Justice majority did. First ask if the prosecution has disproved non-insane automatism beyond reasonable doubt. Then ask if unsoundness of mind is proved on the balance of probabilities. State which verdict follows from each answer.

Finally, address the minority’s approach as an alternative route. Note that the consequences of an unsoundness finding depend on statute, which isn’t covered here.

Self-check

Before moving on, check your answer covers these points.

Automatism and insanity are separate defences. Each has its own Code section. Do not treat them as one defence.

For each defence, say who carries the onus (the burden of proving it) and whose view you are stating.

Keep the three-Justice joint reasons separate from the four-Justice majority view on onus. They are not the same thing.

Porter is a common law case. It sets out a trial direction, not a Code provision.

Do not describe Queensland’s procedure after a finding of unsoundness of mind. That is outside this section.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.