Proving undue influence: on the facts and by presumption
What the doctrine asks
The key question is whether the claimant acted freely. In Thorne v Kennedy, five High Court Justices said pressure can remove free choice. This happens when it makes a person substantially subordinate their will to someone else’s.
The person does not need to become a complete “automaton” (someone with no will of their own) for this to apply. But their judgment must become “markedly sub-standard” because of the other person’s influence. The plurality also noted that pressure need not be illegitimate or improper to count towards undue influence.
In Johnson v Buttress, Dixon J explained the purpose of this area of law. It aims to stop someone unfairly using a special opportunity to affect another person’s free will or judgment. Evatt J agreed with this reasoning.
Dixon J added that no prior relationship between the parties is needed. The influence might arise from a particular situation, or be deliberately created by one party. What matters is whether the influence was so strong that the transaction cannot be seen as the other person’s free act.
Where undue influence stops
Undue influence has borders with two other doctrines. In Thorne, the plurality explained where those borders lie.
Duress is different. If pressure comes from the other party and is illegitimate or improper, that belongs to duress, not undue influence.
Unconscionable conduct overlaps more. The same facts can support both doctrines. But they still differ: a finding of undue influence can show “special disadvantage” for unconscionable conduct, though many other circumstances can show it too. The key contrast is this: undue influence means a will that is “overborne” (not truly free), while unconscionable conduct can exist even where the will stays independent and voluntary, but the other party unfairly exploits a disadvantage.
On the facts, five Justices (the plurality) found both undue influence and unconscionable conduct. Gordon J agreed with the outcome but reasoned differently. She found unconscionable conduct only, because Ms Thorne’s judgment and will were not overborne. Nettle J agreed with the outcome too, but gave separate reasons.
So a student citing Thorne on undue influence is really relying on the plurality’s reasoning, five of the seven Justices.
Applying this in a problem question
First, identify the jurisdiction. These rules come from High Court cases on judge-made equity. Still check if any statute covers the transaction.
Next, ask who benefits from the transaction and who used the influence. If a lender took a guarantee because the debtor asked for it, that’s a separate guarantee question, not this one.
Then check if actual influence can be proven from the facts. For financial agreements between partners, use the indicia (relevant factors) from Thorne. These are only a guide for that situation, not strict legal elements.
If actual influence isn’t shown, ask if the relationship is a recognised category, or if one side had ascendancy or influence and the other had dependency or trust. Also check whether the transaction makes sense for ordinary reasons. Don’t assume any relationship, including engaged couples, automatically counts as a recognised category.
If a presumption of undue influence arises, ask whether the other party proved the transaction still came from free choice. Independent advice is just evidence toward this, not proof on its own. Ask whether such advice was actually given and actually followed.
Finally, note that judges can disagree. In Thorne, Gordon J did not find undue influence.
Self-check
Before you argue undue influence, check your own reasoning.
Have you worked out which proof route the facts actually support? Undue influence can be proved directly, or presumed in certain relationships. Don’t just assert it generally.
Did you treat independent advice as one piece of evidence, not as something that automatically defeats the claim?
Have you credited the Thorne reasoning to the five-Justice plurality, and noted that Gordon J reached her conclusion differently?
Finally, have you avoided using the Thorne factors as a rigid checklist? They were stated for financial agreements, not as fixed elements for every transaction.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.