Vitiating factors: an overview
The factors
Mistake means one or both parties were wrong about something fundamental. Common law only allows this in narrow situations. Equity is more flexible: it can cancel a written contract if one party seriously misunderstood a key term, and the other side knew and deliberately hid it.
Misrepresentation is a false statement of fact that led someone to enter the contract. The remedy depends on whether it was fraudulent, negligent, or innocent.
Misleading or deceptive conduct is a statutory rule (Australian Consumer Law s 18) banning such conduct in trade or commerce. It needs no proof of fault and allows flexible remedies, so it has largely replaced misrepresentation claims in Australian commercial disputes.
Duress is illegitimate pressure, whether aimed at a person, their goods, or their finances (economic duress).
Undue influence means improperly using power over someone’s decisions. It can be shown directly (actual) or presumed from a relationship of trust.
Unconscionable conduct, in equity, means exploiting someone’s special disadvantage. A statutory version (Australian Consumer Law s 21) also applies in trade or commerce. It isn’t limited by the equitable doctrine, and can cover a general pattern of conduct, not just one identified victim.
Illegality and incapacity are sometimes grouped here too, but they really relate to enforceability and formation, not vitiating factors themselves.
Choosing between them
These vitiating factors often overlap. A good answer should discuss more than one, not just pick a favourite.
If a false statement was made in trade or commerce, statutory misleading conduct is usually the best starting point. You don’t need to prove intention or negligence, and the remedies available are discretionary and broad.
Unconscionability and undue influence often arise from the same facts. Unconscionability asks whether the stronger party exploited the weaker party’s disadvantage. Undue influence instead asks whether the weaker party’s consent was genuine.
Duress is harder to prove. It requires illegitimate pressure, a higher bar than simply hard bargaining.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.