Vitiating factors: an overview
A map of the doctrines that attack a properly formed contract because of how agreement was reached, and the difference between void, voidable and unenforceable.
Learning outcomes
- Distinguish void, voidable and unenforceable.
- Identify which vitiating factor fits a fact pattern.
- Explain the bars to rescission.
A contract may be properly formed and still be attacked because of how the agreement was reached. These are the vitiating factors, and they share a structure worth holding onto: each identifies a defect in consent or conduct, and each carries its own remedy.
This article maps the territory; each factor has its own treatment.
The factors
- Mistake — one or both parties were mistaken about something fundamental. Narrow at common law; equity is somewhat more flexible, and will rescind a written contract for one party’s serious mistake about a fundamental term where the other party knew of circumstances indicating the mistake and deliberately set out to keep the mistaken party from discovering it.
- Misrepresentation — a false statement of fact induced the contract. Remedies depend on whether it was fraudulent, negligent or innocent.
- Misleading or deceptive conduct — the statutory prohibition on such conduct in trade or commerce (Australian Consumer Law s 18), which in practice has largely displaced misrepresentation in Australian commercial disputes because it requires no proof of fault and carries a flexible remedial discretion.
- Duress — illegitimate pressure, whether to the person, to goods, or economic.
- Undue influence — improper use of ascendancy over another’s will, which may be actual or presumed from a relationship of trust and confidence.
- Unconscionable conduct — in equity, exploitation of a party’s special disadvantage. The statutory prohibition on unconscionable conduct in trade or commerce (Australian Consumer Law s 21) is not limited by that general law doctrine, and can apply to a system or pattern of conduct without any particular disadvantaged individual being identified.
Illegality and incapacity are sometimes grouped here too, though they are better understood as affecting enforceability and formation respectively.
Void, voidable, unenforceable
The vocabulary matters, and students lose marks on it:
- Void — no contract ever existed. Common law mistake, where it applies, has this effect.
- Voidable — a contract exists, and the innocent party may elect to rescind it. Most vitiating factors work this way. The right to rescind can be lost by affirmation, or by an inability to restore the parties substantially to their former positions;1 delay and the intervention of third-party rights can also bar it.
- Unenforceable — a valid contract a court will not enforce, typically for want of statutory formality.
Choosing between them
Overlap is common, and a good answer addresses more than one route rather than picking a favourite:
- Where a false statement was made in trade or commerce, statutory misleading conduct is usually the strongest starting point: no need to prove intention or negligence, and remedies are discretionary and broad.
- Unconscionability and undue influence often arise on the same facts; the former looks at the stronger party’s exploitation of a disadvantage, the latter at the quality of the weaker party’s consent.
- Duress requires illegitimate pressure, which is a higher bar than hard bargaining.
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the conduct complained of, and who did what to whom.
- Run the statutory route first where a false or misleading statement was made in trade or commerce.
- Then the general law factors that fit the facts, in the alternative.
- State the consequence precisely — void, voidable or unenforceable — and address bars to rescission.
Where the authority sits
A mixture of common law, equity and statute, and the statutory provisions increasingly carry the weight. Where equity and statute both apply, address both.