Terms implied in law, necessity and the duty to cooperate

Two inquiries, not one

Courts imply terms in different ways. Some terms are implied in fact, to make a particular contract work. Others are implied in law, meaning they apply to a whole class of contract, like employment contracts. The High Court explained these categories in Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Barker [2014] HCA 32.

A term implied in fact depends on the specific contract before the court. A term implied in law attaches to a class of contract. Once recognised, it applies to every contract in that class, unless the parties’ own terms or a statute displace it.

Terms implied in law rest on “more general considerations” than business efficacy, meaning they are not based on what makes this particular deal work. Barker adopted this description.

Even so, the two categories are not completely separate. Barker accepts that a term implied in law can develop from repeated instances of terms implied in fact. In practice, the two kinds of implied term can merge into each other.

The distinction still matters. It tells you whether to focus on the specific contract before the court, or on the class of contract it belongs to.

Necessity for a class of contract

Necessity applies to both types of implied term, but differently. For terms implied in fact into a complete written contract, the five conditions from BP Refinery are the test. For oral or incomplete contracts, McHugh and Gummow JJ in Byrne warned against applying those conditions rigidly, asking instead whether the term is necessary for the contract’s reasonable or effective operation.

For terms implied in law, the test comes from McHugh and Gummow JJ’s reasons in Byrne v Australian Airlines Ltd (1995) 185 CLR 410. A term is necessary where, without it, the contract’s rights would be worthless, pointless, or seriously undermined. They gave the landlord’s covenant for quiet enjoyment as an established example of such a term.

Barker explains what this test is for. Implying terms in law is a form of judicial law-making, so courts do it cautiously. These terms must be justified by what effective performance requires for the whole class of contract, not just the one case. A term being reasonable or desirable is not enough; it must be shown to be necessary.

In Byrne, employees argued an award clause should be implied by law into their employment contracts. McHugh and Gummow JJ found no necessity, since the contracts worked without the clause both before and after it appeared in awards. The appeal was dismissed.

Barker and Byrne are High Court decisions binding on lower Australian courts. Malik v Bank of Credit and Commerce International SA, the House of Lords case Mr Barker relied on, is only persuasive authority here.

The refusal in Barker

Mr Barker’s job was made redundant. He argued his employer breached an implied term of mutual trust and confidence by denying him a chance at redeployment. This term is a duty for employer and employee to treat each other fairly, so trust between them is not destroyed.

The Court allowed the Bank’s appeal. It held the term was not “necessary” for the contract to work, even using the broader test courts use when implying terms in law (terms the law adds to all contracts of a type).

The Court gave several reasons. The term would control the whole relationship, not just how the contract is performed, so it went further than necessary. It would also bind employees, not just employers, but employees had no chance to argue about that burden. The policy choices involved were, in Australia, better suited to Parliament than the courts. Finally, Australian law had not yet accepted this term applies to employment contracts.

The Court also rejected implying the term in fact, meaning as part of this specific contract. Mr Barker’s lawyers pointed to no particular feature of his agreement supporting it. His seniority, long service, and the contract’s silence on trust and confidence were not enough on their own.

The duty to cooperate

Quick Read: the duty to cooperate is a real implied term. It meets the necessity test needed for terms implied in law.

This duty applies to contracts generally. Lord Blackburn’s classic statement in Mackay v Dick explains it: if both parties agree to do something needing joint action, each must do their part to make it happen.

In Barker, the Court noted Mason J’s earlier approach in Secured Income Real Estate (Australia) Ltd v St Martins Investments Pty Ltd. Mason J treated cooperation as a rule of construction, but also called it an implied duty.

The duty to cooperate only concerns contractual performance. That’s why the Court kept it separate from trust and confidence (a different duty). It said trust and confidence is not just one example of the cooperation duty.

On the facts, the Court found redeployment was not a relevant benefit. So the duty to cooperate did not pull the Bank’s redeployment policy into the contract.

Good faith remains open

The majority judges said their decision does not settle whether contracts carry a general duty of good faith. They also left open whether contractual powers and discretions can be limited by good faith and rationality, similar to public law rules.

Justice Kiefel, in a separate judgment, agreed. She noted that Australian law has not yet resolved whether good faith applies generally to contracts.

Be careful here. Barker does not confirm a general duty of good faith, but it does not rule one out either.

The safest approach is to say the issue remains unresolved at the High Court level. Do not use Barker as authority for or against a general good faith duty.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by finding the term being claimed. Check if a statute implies it or displaces a common-law term first. The statute controls, and the general-law inquiry works around it.

Next, decide if the claim is for a term implied in fact (for this specific contract) or implied in law (for this class of contract). Say which one applies. If it is implied in fact, check whether the contract is a formal written one, complete on its face. The BP Refinery conditions apply less strictly when it is not.

For terms implied in law, name the class of contract. Ask whether, without the term, the rights under that class of contract would be nugatory (worthless) or seriously undermined.

Keep necessity separate from reasonableness. Reasonableness alone is not enough to imply a term.

Check whether an express term displaces the implied term. Also consider the duty to cooperate, if one party allegedly hindered the other’s performance.

If the claim is really about good faith, or about trust and confidence, remember Barker. It refused to imply trust and confidence in employment contracts, but left good faith as an open question.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.