Privity of contract

What this covers

This part covers the general rule of privity of contract, and the main judgment that sets it out.

It explains why saying someone is not a party to a contract (privity) is a different objection from saying they gave no consideration.

It covers what Trident decided, but also stresses what Trident did not decide. It also covers the ways a person outside a contract might still get some protection.

This section does not cover the third-party rights created by property legislation in Queensland and Western Australia. Those statutory rights are wider than anything discussed here.

The elements

Privity of contract means only parties to a contract can sue on it. In Coulls v Bagot’s Executor & Trustee Co Ltd, Barwick CJ said a person who is not a party cannot sue to enforce the contract’s terms.

Two points follow. First, whether someone is a party is decided by interpreting the contract, not by what seems fair. In Coulls, the judges asked whether a promise was made to the wife too, or only to her husband. Taylor and Owen JJ held it was made with the husband alone.

Second, privity is a separate issue from consideration (what each party gives in exchange). Barwick CJ warned these are often confused. If lack of privity is really why a claim fails, blaming lack of consideration instead is misleading. Someone can be a party without giving consideration, and someone can give consideration without being a party. Work out which problem actually applies.

How it works in practice

Trident v McNiece is the case usually cited as changing privity of contract. A principal’s liability insurance policy covered its contractors. McNiece, a contractor, was sued and claimed under the policy, though it had not signed it. The appeal was dismissed, so McNiece won.

But the seven judges gave six different sets of reasons. There is no single majority ratio, meaning no one explanation binds future courts.

Mason CJ and Wilson J said principle required McNiece to succeed. Toohey J set out a specific rule: a contractor may sue an insurer where the policy shows both insurer and assured intended to cover contractors like it, and it was reasonable for the contractor to rely on that cover. He said this was despite the contractor not being a party and not providing consideration. He also limited his own rule, saying other situations “must await another day.”

Gaudron J reached the same result differently: once the insurer took the premium, it owed McNiece an enforceable obligation to indemnify. Deane J kept privity intact, relying instead on the idea of a trust. Brennan J and Dawson J dissented, for different reasons.

Because the judges disagreed on reasoning, Trident only establishes that this particular third party won on this policy. Toohey J’s test is the closest thing to a general rule, but it is not a binding majority holding. Any proposition drawn from the case must be attributed to the specific judge who made it.

Where the boundaries are

Privity of contract is the rule that only parties to a contract can enforce it. Brennan J, in dissent, mentioned “privity, trust, agency and estoppel” as a framework, not a fixed checklist. Privity is the obstacle to enforcement by outsiders. Trust, agency and estoppel are just starting points for working out how a third party might still be protected.

Two more qualifications follow. First, if a promise is made to two people jointly, the second person is actually a party, so privity never becomes a problem for them. This was the construction issue in Coulls, discussed by Windeyer J. But Windeyer J limited this: if one promisee gets specific performance (a court order forcing the promise to be carried out) of a promise to pay a third person, that does not give the third person their own right to enforce the contract. The remedy belongs to the party, not the outsider.

Second, statute can override privity. Section 48 does this for general insurance, and some States have broader provisions.

Finally, privity only blocks enforcement, not every kind of relief. In Hobart International Airport Pty Ltd v Clarence City Council, the High Court said lack of privity makes courts cautious about an outsider’s standing (their legal right to bring a claim), but does not always defeat it. In exceptional cases, an outsider with a “sufficient” or “real” interest may seek a declaration about what a contract means. This is not a general right to a declaration whenever someone is interested — standing and caution still apply. But privity by itself does not automatically defeat a claim for declaratory relief.

Applying this in a problem question

When answering a problem question, first ask if the claimant is a party to the contract. Read the contract itself first, before looking for an exception. Coulls shows this approach.

If they are not a party, identify the exact problem. Is it privity, meaning they are not a party? Or is it lack of consideration, meaning they gave nothing of value? These are different problems; do not confuse them.

Then work through the recognised exceptions one by one: trust, agency, estoppel, joint promisee, or statute. Do not simply claim the privity rule has been relaxed in general.

If you use Trident, name the specific judge whose reasoning you rely on, and state what that judge actually held. Do not say Trident created a general exception for third parties. Do not say Toohey J’s approach became a binding majority rule.

Self-check

Before moving on, check you can answer these questions.

First, can you state the privity rule itself? Also say which judge first stated it.

Next, can you explain what Trident decided? Be careful here: no single reasoning won majority support, so there is no settled ratio. You should also be able to state Toohey J’s own formulation of the rule, and note its limit.

Can you explain why s 48 did not apply in Trident, even though the Act was already in force at the time?

Finally, can you describe a joint promisee’s position? You should also be able to explain why a promisee’s remedy is different from a remedy belonging to a third party.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.