The objective theory of agreement
The objective test
In Toll v Alphapharm, the High Court said contracts are judged objectively. What matters is not what the parties actually believed, but what their words and conduct would have led a reasonable person in the other party’s position to think.
This means a private belief does not decide what was agreed, unless a reasonable person in the other party’s position could have known of it. Whether that private belief might still matter for some other kind of relief is a separate question, not answered here.
Agreement can be shown by conduct, not just by written or spoken words. The Court also said that working out what a contract document means usually requires looking at the text, the surrounding circumstances both parties knew, and the purpose of the transaction. That is about interpreting documents, a topic covered elsewhere.
In Pacific Carriers Ltd v BNP Paribas, a bank officer signed letters of indemnity. The High Court said her personal intention did not matter, nor what she privately told someone else about it. The carrier did not know her thints; only the documents conveyed meaning. The Court treated this as a clear example of why commercial documents are interpreted objectively.
Finding agreement where there is no clean offer and acceptance
Offer and acceptance is the usual way courts check if parties agreed. But it is not the only way to find agreement.
In the NSW case Brambles Holdings Ltd v Bathurst City Council, Heydon JA said offer and acceptance analysis does not explain every case. It is a useful tool, but not always necessary or sufficient. He said rules like “rejection ends an offer” cannot be universal rules either.
Heydon JA instead asked: looking at all the circumstances, can agreement be inferred? Did the parties show mutual assent? Would a reasonable person in each party’s position think there was a concluded bargain? This is the same objective test from Toll, applied to the whole dealing, not just single messages.
Mason P agreed, saying the case shows the danger of pushing classical offer-and-acceptance theory too far.
In Brambles, the Council sent a letter setting conditions for higher fees. The defendant first rejected these terms, but later charged the higher fees anyway. Heydon JA held this conduct would make a reasonable person in the Council’s position believe the defendant had assented to the terms. The Court of Appeal dismissed the defendant’s appeal.
One key point from the judgment: taking a benefit can count as assent. Quoting McHugh JA in Empirnall Holdings Pty Ltd v Machon Paull Partners Pty Ltd, if someone has a fair chance to reject an offer of goods or services, but instead takes the benefit knowing payment is expected, a court can find they accepted the offer on its terms.
Applying this in a problem question
First, list what each party said and did, in order. Keep going past the documents if the parties kept acting afterward.
Then ask what a reasonable person in the other party’s position would have understood from that. Ignore a private belief a reasonable person could not have known about. Note anything the other party knew, since that may matter later for mistake.
If offer and acceptance do not fit neatly, say so. Ask the broader Brambles question: can an agreement be inferred from all the circumstances? Brambles is a New South Wales Court of Appeal case, persuasive elsewhere.
If conduct is said to show assent, check it can prove every essential element of the agreement. Also check what the other party knew about the terms, and whether they had a reasonable chance to reject them.
If a document was signed, start with the signature principle from Toll. Then check for fraud, misrepresentation, non est factum (signing a document fundamentally different from what you believed you signed), or a statutory power to relieve. Only name a specific statute if you have actually read it.
If a party claims mistake, first identify what kind of mistake it is before deciding its effect. For unilateral mistake, Toll reports from Taylor v Johnson that the contract binds at common law unless equity avoids it. Non est factum, if proven, is a ground the Court said makes the contract void at common law. Then consult the mistake article.
Self-check
Check whether you asked what the other party reasonably understood, not what the first party actually meant. This reflects the objective theory of agreement.
Use Pacific Carriers only to explain why courts apply an objective test. Do not treat it as a rule for deciding whether a contract was formed.
Remember Brambles is a New South Wales Court of Appeal decision. It is persuasive, not binding, in other jurisdictions.
Make sure any conduct relied on as assent actually proves every essential element of the agreement, not just part of it.
Treat a signature as a starting point only. Still check it against the grounds the High Court identified in Toll for displacing that starting point.
Where the authority sits
The High Court’s decisions in Toll and Pacific Carriers set out the objective approach. These bind every Australian court, but only on what those two cases actually decided.
Heydon JA’s reasoning in the New South Wales Court of Appeal covers agreement by conduct, and questions that arise when offer and acceptance don’t fit neatly. This reasoning is persuasive (meaning courts may follow it, but don’t have to) in other States.
Taylor v Johnson, Empirnall, Integrated Computer Services, Sullivan v Constable and L’Estrange v Graucob appear here only because the cited judgments quote or describe them. They are not independently relied on as authorities in this article.
This article does not deal with intention to create legal relations, certainty, formalities, or ways to set an agreement aside in equity or by statute. Each of those topics has its own separate article.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.