Intention to create legal relations: onus, presumptions and government arrangements

What the objective inquiry asks

Quick Read: In Ermogenous v Greek Orthodox Community of SA Inc (2002), Archbishop Ermogenous claimed leave entitlements, saying the Community had employed him. An Industrial Magistrate agreed, but the Full Court majority disagreed, finding no intention to create legal relations. The High Court allowed his appeal and sent the matter back.

The joint judgment made three key points. First, a legally enforceable duty, voluntarily assumed, is essential to contract. Second, surrounding circumstances may show the parties did not intend courts to adjudicate their agreement. Third, courts must weigh the subject-matter, the parties’ status, their relationship, and other circumstances together. No fixed rules can dictate when intention should or shouldn’t be found.

“Intention” here means the same as elsewhere in contract law. It asks what the words and conduct objectively conveyed, given the circumstances. It is not about uncovering what either party privately thought or meant.

So a party’s private belief about whether they meant to be bound doesn’t settle the question. What matters is how their conduct would reasonably appear to an outside observer.

Arrangements with government

Government arrangements often lack intention to contract. There is no general rule about this. Two older High Court cases show how courts have approached it.

In Australian Woollen Mills Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth (1954), a wool manufacturer said the Commonwealth had promised a subsidy through official announcements. The High Court held no contract existed, and found for the Commonwealth.

The Court said contract requires a voluntary assumption of a legally enforceable duty. For an offer accepted by doing an act, the offer must show an intention to create an obligation once the act is done. Without that intention, actual or imputed (treated as present even if not express), there is no contract.

The Court then looked at the circumstances. The announcements came from government bodies, not a party with a commercial interest. The Government had no past practice of contracting on this issue, had no shown reason to bind itself now, and public money was involved. The Court added that if the Government meant to create a legal obligation, you would expect it to seek statutory authority first.

The Court treated these as relevant circumstances, not a fixed test. It also reasoned through offer and consideration, so intention was only one part of its reasoning.

Placer Development Ltd v The Commonwealth (1969) involved a 1952 agreement between the Commonwealth and Placer Development Ltd, called the New Guinea Timber Agreement.

Where the authority sits

All three cases are High Court of Australia decisions. The joint reasons in Ermogenous and Australian Woollen Mills are reasons of the whole Court, so they carry full authority.

The passage from Placer Development is different. It comes from one Justice only, who was in the minority on that issue. This makes it persuasive reasoning, not a binding holding — meaning it can guide but does not have to be followed.

The article treats these as common law principles applying generally, not limited to one State or Territory. This is subject to any statute on the topic, though no such statute is mentioned here.

Ermogenous dates from 2002, while the other two cases are older. Before relying on this article, a student should check whether later cases have affected any of them, including the later history of Australian Woollen Mills itself. No later treatment is covered here.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by saying what’s in dispute and who claims a contract exists. Under Ermogenous, the party asserting the contract carries the onus (the burden of proving it) — here, the Archbishop.

Don’t start from the label given to the relationship. Look at the subject matter, the parties’ status, their relationship, and the surrounding circumstances. Ask what a reasonable person would conclude from what was said and done. A private, uncommunicated belief about enforceability doesn’t settle the question.

If you use a presumption (a starting assumption), say whose onus it affects and what facts support it. Ermogenous doubted how useful these presumptions are, warning they can wrongly harden into fixed rules. So a claim that “such arrangements are usually not binding” needs facts behind it.

If a government is involved, ask what the circumstances show about its intention to be legally bound. Consider whether the document came from a party with a commercial interest or from a government body, whether public money is involved, and whether statutory authority was sought — as in Australian Woollen Mills. Also consider the arrangement’s commercial character and wording, as Windeyer J did in Placer Development. Note that this is only one Justice’s view, and he was in the minority on one issue; the other Justices’ views on intention aren’t covered here.

Finally, reach a conclusion based on all the circumstances. State clearly what these authorities don’t establish — for example, how later cases have treated them.

Self-check

Before finishing, check four things.

Did you identify who carries the onus (the burden of proving intention), not just name a presumption?

Did you base your answer on this arrangement’s own facts, rather than a general rule about the type of relationship?

In Ermogenous, did you credit Kirby J alone with the comment on English decisions, and attribute the doubt about presumptions to the joint reasons instead?

Did you treat the Australian Woollen Mills factors and Windeyer J’s passage as relevant circumstances only, not a test or the whole Court’s holding? Did you note Windeyer J was in the minority on question 4(a)?

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.