Land contracts in writing: the memorandum and part performance
What a sufficient note or memorandum requires
Pirie v Saunders (1961) 104 CLR 149 is a High Court case on s 54A of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW). The plaintiff said the defendants had orally agreed to lease him shop premises. The only document was a solicitor’s note of instructions for a draft lease, and neither defendant had signed it.
The Full Court below had said the defendants’ printed names could count as signatures, if the defendants recognised the note as an accurate record of their earlier oral deal. The High Court disagreed and allowed the appeal.
First, the Court said a note or memorandum must be recognisable as recording a concluded agreement. This solicitor’s note was just instructions for drafting a lease to send to the other side. It did not show a binding contract existed, and was consistent with there being no contract yet.
Second, the Court said a memorandum does not always have to be made after the contract. A written offer can later become a sufficient note of the resulting contract, if the parties’ conduct shows it was accepted. But the Court held this was not such a case.
Third, the Court gave further reasons, even assuming its first objection was wrong. The note did not properly identify the property, which alone was “a fatal objection”. It also left out terms of the lease, since it still contemplated a special condition to be settled.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by checking the jurisdiction and whether the contract concerns land. In New South Wales, use s 54A(1) of the Conveyancing Act 1919. In Victoria, use s 126(1) of the Instruments Act 1958. In Queensland, use s 7 of the Property Law Act 2023. For any other jurisdiction, find and read its own provision first.
Next, identify the “party to be charged” -- the person the provision says must have signed. Look for writing signed by that party, or by someone authorised to sign for them.
Then check whether any document is a genuine note or memorandum of a finished agreement. A document that only records negotiations or drafting instructions is not enough. As in Pirie v Saunders, the document must identify the property and set out the agreed terms.
If there is no sufficient writing, consider part performance -- this is where one party’s conduct in carrying out the contract may substitute for writing. In New South Wales, s 54A(2) preserves this doctrine. In Queensland, s 10(1)(b) of the 2023 Act does the same. For Victoria, the passage does not explain how part performance applies against s 126. Ask whether the acts relied on, such as taking possession, point unmistakably to a contract of the kind alleged, and whether they might instead be explained by some other arrangement.
Finally, if the contract or signature was electronic, identify the jurisdiction’s electronic transactions provision. Note that this provision alone does not make every electronic document a sufficient memorandum.
Self-check
Check that you named the relevant State or Territory and its section before saying writing is required.
Check that you explained the New South Wales provision only bars an action on the contract. It does not make the contract void.
Check that you tested the document against Pirie v Saunders. Ask whether it reads as a note of a concluded agreement, and whether it describes the property.
Check that you attributed the part performance reasoning to Gibbs J, noting the other Justices agreed with him. Also note what Regent v Millett left undecided.
Check that you avoided stating a Victorian position on part performance. The authorities used here do not establish one.
Where the authority sits
The writing rule for land contracts comes from statute, not common law. The exact wording differs between Australian jurisdictions.
Two High Court cases, Pirie v Saunders and Regent v Millett, interpreted s 54A of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW). These cases bind courts on the specific points they decided.
In other states, and under the 2023 Queensland Act, these decisions may still apply. But this depends on whether the local provision is similar enough.
This article does not cover guarantees, equitable estoppel (a separate doctrine sometimes used instead of part performance), deeds, or other regulatory formalities. A related article on formalities covers these topics briefly.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.