Consideration, variation and part payment

Part payment of a debt

If a creditor promises to accept less than a debt already owed, that promise needs consideration. Paying only the smaller sum is not enough consideration.

In Foakes v Beer, a debtor paid part of a judgment debt. The creditor promised not to sue if the rest was paid by instalments. The House of Lords held the debtor already owed the whole debt, so paying it did not count as consideration for the creditor giving up interest.

Foakes v Beer is an English case. It only persuades Australian courts; it is not binding here. The passage does not show how Australian courts have since treated it, so check further before relying on it.

There are limits to the rule. A promise made “under seal” (a formal, signed and sealed document) binds without needing consideration at all. Quoting Pinnel’s Case, the judges said paying a lesser sum earlier than due, at a different place, or paying something other than money (like a horse), can count as good satisfaction of the debt.

Lord Selborne said a benefit the creditor already risked losing — like part payment instead of none in insolvency — isn’t a real “benefit” for consideration purposes; it must be some separate, independent benefit. Lord Blackburn agreed with the outcome, but thought Lord Coke’s original reasoning about commercial practice was factually wrong.

Promising more for what is already owed

This section covers the opposite problem: promising extra money for something already owed under a contract. The old rule, from Stilk v Myrick, says performing an existing contractual duty is not consideration for an extra promise.

Williams v Roffey Brothers qualified this rule. A main contractor promised a sub-contractor more money to finish carpentry work the sub-contractor already had to do.

Glidewell LJ said a practical benefit can count as consideration if four things are present: the promisor doubts the other party will finish; the promisor offers extra payment for that performance; the promisor actually gets a benefit or avoids a loss; and the promise was not caused by economic duress or fraud. Economic duress means illegitimate pressure that forces someone to agree.

On these facts Glidewell LJ held the benefit could be consideration. He described this as refining and limiting Stilk v Myrick, not overruling it. Purchas LJ and Russell LJ reached the same result for different reasons. Russell LJ noted he would have liked to hear argument on estoppel, meaning a rule stopping a party going back on a representation, but that argument was not raised.

Williams v Roffey Brothers is an English Court of Appeal case. In Australia it is only persuasive, not binding. The passage does not say what Australian appellate courts think of it, so do not treat it as settled Australian law.

The case contrasts with Foakes v Beer, where a practical benefit of getting some money from a debtor was not enough. Here, a practical benefit of finishing a building contract was enough. The duress condition links this topic to the separate law of economic duress.

Choosing the route

This article looks at three possible ways to make a variation enforceable. They are an organising framework only, not a full list of every route Australian law allows.

The first route is fresh consideration. This means giving something new in exchange, like a different benefit. English law also allows a “practical benefit” to count.

The second route is a deed. A deed binds the parties without needing consideration.

The third route is equitable estoppel. This needs an assumption the other party relied on, suffered detriment from, and where going back on it would be unconscionable.

The passage notes that its sources do not fully establish the Australian law of accord and satisfaction. So other routes may exist beyond these three.

Each of the three routes can fail, but for different reasons. If a variation fails for lack of consideration, estoppel might still save it, but only if there was reliance, detriment, and unconscionability.

Finally, even a variation supported by consideration may still be challenged. If it was obtained by pressure, it can be attacked for duress.

Where the authority sits

Two High Court cases bind us here: Waltons Stores v Maher, and Sidhu v Van Dyke on the question of relief (the remedy a court can give).

The rules on part payment and practical benefit come from English cases. These are only persuasive in Australia, not binding.

For the general rules on consideration, see the earlier article. For more detail on the equitable doctrine of estoppel, see the article on estoppel.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by finding the original obligation and the new promise that changes it. Work out who is trying to enforce that new promise, the variation.

Then ask what that party is giving that they did not already have to give. If it is just part payment of an existing debt, this raises the Foakes v Beer issue. That case is English, so it is persuasive only in Australia. Check Australian authority before assuming it applies.

If instead someone promises to pay more for the same performance, ask whether the promisor got a practical benefit, meaning some real advantage from the deal. Williams v Roffey Brothers deals with this, but it is also English and only persuasive here.

Always check whether there is a deed, a formal signed document that does not need consideration. Also check whether the variation was obtained through economic duress or fraud, meaning improper pressure or dishonesty forced the agreement.

If consideration is missing, ask whether the other party relied on the promise to their detriment, meaning they acted on it and would be harmed if it were broken. Then ask if it would be unconscionable, or unfair, for the promisor to go back on it. This comes from Waltons Stores v Maher. Note that Brennan J’s reasoning limited relief to only what is needed to undo that detriment.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.