Performance, timing and revocation in contract formation
When an acceptance takes effect
The general rule is that a contract forms only when acceptance is actually communicated to the offeror.
In Tallerman v Nathan’s Merchandise, Dixon CJ and Fullagar J discussed an exception called the postal rule. Under this exception, posting a letter completes the contract, but only if the offeror intended acceptance to occur by that act of posting.
Their Honours said this inference is sometimes easy to draw. But where solicitors were conducting hostile correspondence, actual communication would likely be seen as essential instead.
This view was not part of the actual decision. Their Honours decided the case on a different, agreed assumption, so the postal rule question remained unresolved.
In Wardle v Agricultural and Rural Finance, Campbell JA (with two other judges agreeing) confirmed this point was never decided by the High Court. His Honour advised that, until a case turns on it, courts should keep following the English authorities on the postal rule.
So a student should state the general rule, mention the posting exception and its condition, and note that Australian law on this point remains unsettled.
The postal rule also affects where a contract is made. If posting completes acceptance, the contract is treated as made where the letter was posted. This mattered in Tallerman, where the parties assumed posting in Sydney meant the contract was made in New South Wales.
Revocation and options
An offer can usually be withdrawn any time before acceptance. A bare promise to keep it open, without consideration, is not binding. Griffith CJ stated this in Goldsbrough, Mort & Co Ltd v Quinn.[^cite:goldsbrough-mort-v-quinn-option-for-value]
The exception is an option. Quinn was paid five shillings for a promise to let the company buy his land within a week. He tried to withdraw, calling it a repudiation (a refusal to be bound), before the company accepted.
Griffith CJ held that because consideration was paid for the promise, it was binding. An option given for value cannot be revoked. O’Connor J reasoned that a withdrawing offeror is liable at law, and that equity would ignore the withdrawal and treat the offer as still open. The High Court allowed the company’s appeal; O’Connor J held it was entitled to specific performance, subject to the usual equitable requirements.
So the label used matters less than whether consideration was given. An offer merely said to stay “open for seven days” can still be revoked early. A genuine option, paid for, cannot.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by checking what the offer actually asks for. If it asks for an act, not a promise, this may be a unilateral contract (a contract accepted by doing something, not promising). Check whether the claimant knew of the offer and whether their act was objectively a response to it.
Next, ask whether the offeror set out a required method of acceptance. If so, check whether that method needs the acceptance to actually reach the offeror.
If acceptance was posted, ask whether the offeror can be taken to have intended that posting itself completes acceptance. Note that the High Court has not settled this postal rule point in a case that depended on it. Where posting does complete the contract, the contract is formed where the letter was posted.
If acceptance was sent electronically, identify the proper law governing the contract and which electronic transactions provision applies. State what that provision says about dispatch and receipt, but remember it does not itself fix when acceptance takes legal effect.
Finally, if the offeror tried to withdraw the offer, ask whether anything was given in exchange for a promise to keep the offer open. If something was given, treat the arrangement as an option, meaning the withdrawal will not stop a valid acceptance.
Self-check
Before finalising your answer, run through these checks.
Did you ask whether the performance actually responded to the offer? This is different from just checking if it matched the act described.
Did you credit Dixon CJ and Fullagar J with the posting condition? Remember to note that its legal status remains unsettled.
Did you name the jurisdiction first, before citing any electronic transactions provision?
Did you check whether a promise to keep the offer open had consideration? Only then should you treat the offer as revoked.
Where the authority sits
Most of the rules here come from High Court decisions. These are “common law”, meaning law made by judges, not parliament. Every Australian court must follow what the High Court actually decided.
The warning about the postal rule comes from the New South Wales Court of Appeal. This is only “persuasive” elsewhere, meaning other courts can consider it but do not have to follow it.
The electronic transactions rules are different. They come from statutes (laws made by parliament), and these statutes vary between states. This article only covers the Commonwealth Act and the New South Wales Act.
The article does not cover everything. It leaves out tenders, auctions, clashes between standard terms, and what happens when a revocation never reaches the offeree.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.