Section 21 of the Australian Consumer Law: the statutory standard in practice

The matters in section 22

Section 22 lists factors a court may consider. These are not the only matters it can look at.

Section 22(1) applies when the defendant is the supplier. Section 22(2) mirrors this for a defendant who is the acquirer. So first work out which side the defendant was on.

Each list has twelve paragraphs. This article groups them into themes to help study, though the statute itself does not group them this way.

Some factors concern bargaining position: relative strength, and whether the other party had other options or prices available elsewhere.

Others concern the contract terms themselves: conditions going beyond what protects the defendant’s legitimate interests, willingness to negotiate, and any one-sided right to vary terms.

A further group covers understanding and pressure: whether the other party could understand the documents, any undue influence or unfair tactics, and unreasonable failure to disclose risks or intentions.

The last group concerns consistency and fairness: whether the defendant treated similar parties consistently, relevant industry codes (including ones the other party reasonably expected to apply), and good faith by both sides.

Importantly, a factor can cut either way. For example, the absence of pressure can count in the defendant’s favour. The court weighs all these factors together, rather than simply counting how many favour each side.

The standard: how the High Court divided in *Kobelt*

ASIC v Kobelt applied s 12CB of the ASIC Act, not the ACL. That section bans conduct that is “unconscionable in all the circumstances” and lists relevant matters, just like ss 21 and 22. Gageler J said the older s 51AB and the current s 21 are materially identical to s 12CB.

A storekeeper in a remote South Australian community ran “book-up” credit for Anangu customers. He typically held their debit cards and PINs, taking their wages or welfare payments when paid. ASIC argued this was a system of unconscionable conduct.

The primary judge agreed, but the Full Federal Court overturned that finding. The High Court then dismissed ASIC’s appeal, four Justices to three. The judges gave different reasons for the outcome.

Kiefel CJ and Bell J said “unconscionable” has its ordinary meaning: conduct is unconscionable if it is objectively against conscience. They said earlier cases required a special disadvantage and someone unconscientiously taking advantage of it. They found no such advantage was taken here.

Gageler J said the section sets a normative standard, judged on the totality of circumstances. He stressed that “unconscionable” carries equity’s full weight, not a diluted “equity-lite” version. The conduct must fall so far outside accepted commercial behaviour that it deserves condemnation.

Keane J agreed the appeal should fail, because it wasn’t shown the storekeeper exploited his customers’ vulnerability.

Nettle and Gordon JJ, and Edelman J, dissented. They would have found the system unconscionable.

So Kobelt has no single majority reasoning on the standard — that is just a summary of the split, not a legal holding.

The Full Federal Court addressed this gap in ACCC v Quantum Housing Group Pty Ltd. The primary judge there had read Kobelt as requiring exploitation of some vulnerability or disadvantage. The Full Court (Allsop CJ, Besanko and McKerracher JJ) said this was wrong: exploiting vulnerability will often be present in unconscionable conduct, but is not always required.

Applying the section: *Lux*

ACCC v Lux Distributors Pty Ltd is a Full Court decision. It does not bind the High Court or State courts, though Gageler J in Kobelt treated its approach as correct.

Sales staff rang elderly women, offering a free maintenance check. The Court called this a deceptive ruse to get into their homes, after which staff sold new vacuums following long demonstrations.

Mrs Baird, 89, was the case under s 21. The other two women’s claims arose under s 21’s predecessor, s 51AB of the Trade Practices Act. The primary judge dismissed all claims, but the Full Court found the conduct unconscionable.

The Court used a “normative standard of conscience”, shaped by community values like honesty and fairness. It said justice, fairness, vulnerability, advantage and honesty were all central.

The deceptive entry was treated as the launching pad for everything after, giving the seller strength in the home. For Mrs Baird, this was worsened by a breach of the ACL requirement to state the visit’s purpose. The women’s ability to otherwise look after themselves did not answer the case.

The Court applied s 21 as it stood then, including five listed matters in s 21(2). Those same five matters now appear as s 22(1)(a)-(e), within a longer list.

System cases and remedies

Some unconscionable conduct cases involve a system of conduct, not just one customer. Kobelt was like this: ASIC claimed a whole system of credit supply was unconscionable, affecting 117 customers. By contrast, Lux focused on conduct toward each individual customer.

Section 21(4)(b) allows a claim to rely on a pattern of conduct. The claimant need not point to one specific person. The court still must decide whether the conduct, as a system, was unconscionable.

Remedies for breach sit in Part 5-2 of the ACL. Courts may order pecuniary penalties (s 224), injunctions (s 232), damages within six years (s 236), and compensation orders (s 237), including orders affecting the contract itself (s 243).

Penalty amounts depend on when the conduct happened, because of amendments taking effect from 28 March 2026. The passage does not state the earlier amounts, only the current maximums under s 224(3A).

Applying this in a problem question

First, pick the right provision. If the case involves supplying or acquiring goods or services, check s 21 first. Remember s 131A removes financial services and financial products from the Commonwealth ACL. If s 21 doesn’t cover the conduct, consider s 20, which uses an equitable test instead.

Next, identify who supplied and who acquired, and whether this happened in trade or commerce. Check whether s 21(2) limits the claim, that is, conduct done only because of legal proceedings or arbitration. Also check s 21(3), the foreseeability requirement.

Then work through the s 22 factors, either s 22(1) or s 22(2), looking at points favouring the defendant. Consider the contract’s terms and how it was actually performed.

State the standard: conduct is judged against community standards of conscience, meaning serious wrongdoing, not minor unfairness. The Justices disagreed on this test in Kobelt. Ask whether the defendant exploited the other party’s vulnerable position, since this often shows the standard was breached. But note the Full Court in Quantum Housing held exploitation of vulnerability isn’t essential under s 21, unlike Keane J’s view.

Decide whether the facts show one isolated dealing, or a system or pattern of conduct under s 21(4)(b).

Finally, identify who may bring a claim and which remedy fits: a penalty, an injunction, damages, or compensation orders, including voiding or varying the contract.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.