Interpreting the Constitution: text, structure and history

What the Engineers’ case rejected

The joint judgment rejected two arguments. First, it rejected an “implied prohibition” — an unwritten limit on a granted power — based on “necessity”. It held this failed because political necessity changes with the power, the State and the time. Possible abuse of a power is no reason to narrow its wording.

Second, it rejected reading s 107 as reserving to the States any power already granted to the Commonwealth under s 51. The judgment called this a “fundamental and fatal error”, unless such a reservation is clearly stated.

The Court also said American case law was not a safe guide to Commonwealth-State relations. Australia’s system differs because all parts of the British Empire share one sovereignty, and because of responsible government (ministers answerable to parliament).

The Court held that States, when actually parties to industrial disputes, are bound by Commonwealth legislation under s 51(xxxv), if that legislation is properly read as applying to them. This holding is still limited by a structural implication discussed in the next section.

History as an aid: Cole v Whitfield

Cole v Whitfield (1988) shows how courts use history to interpret the Constitution. Seven Justices gave joint reasons in this case.

They said history is not used to find what the founders subjectively wanted s 92 to mean. Instead, it helps show the contemporary meaning of the words, what they were addressing, and the goals of the move to federation.

That history showed the colonies wanted to end border duties and discriminatory burdens, and to create free trade between them.

The Court preferred the interpretation supported by history and context. It dropped an earlier doctrine that had lost general support, and did not rely on the United States commerce clause to explain s 92.

The practical result for s 92 is explained in [Section 92](/articles/section-92).

What does not fix the meaning

Two things do not settle the Constitution’s meaning.

First, foreign law. In Engineers, the High Court refused to use American decisions to measure Australian federal power. In Cole v Whitfield, it refused to use the United States commerce clause to explain s 92.

Second, a failed referendum to change the Constitution. In the Work Choices case, the Court said you cannot reason from a failed amendment proposal to a conclusion about the Constitution’s meaning. Failed referendums gave no help in deciding that case.

This is because altering the Constitution and interpreting it are separate processes.

Applying this in a problem question

Start with the actual words of the constitutional provision in question. Ask what those words naturally mean, on their own.

Then read those words in context. A provision elsewhere in the Constitution might restrict the meaning of the word you are interpreting. Working this out is a matter of construction, meaning careful interpretation of the text.

Sometimes an argument claims a power is limited by State interests or a “federal balance”. If so, ask what specific text or structural feature actually creates that limit, and what the limit covers. Keep this separate from a vague claim that an entire topic simply belongs to the States. A structural limit, such as one protecting the States’ continued existence, is different from that broader claim.

History can help too, but only for certain purposes. Use it to understand the language, the problem it addressed, and the aims of federation. Do not use history to find out what the framers personally intended.

Finally, be careful with two kinds of material. A failed referendum or a foreign legal model does not settle what the text means. When citing authority, state which court decided the case and what it actually held.

Self-check

Before relying on an interpretation, check your reasoning against a few questions.

Start with the Constitution’s actual words. Do not start with an idea of what powers the States should keep.

Separate two different things. One is an implication drawn from the Constitution’s structure. The other is the older idea of reserved powers or immunities for the States. Keep these distinct.

Use history only to understand what the words mean. Do not use history to guess what the drafters subjectively intended.

If you rely on a “federal balance” argument, first explain clearly what that argument actually means.

Where the authority sits

These three cases are High Court decisions: the Engineers’ case, the Work Choices case, and Cole v Whitfield.

High Court decisions bind lower Australian courts. This means lower courts must follow them.

The High Court can also reconsider its own past decisions. So its rulings are not fixed forever.

The quoted statements from the Work Choices case come from the joint reasons of five Justices. The separate reasons given by Kirby J and Callinan J are not covered here.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.