Summary judgment: deciding a claim or defence without a trial
What summary judgment decides, and what it does not
Summary judgment is not an interim order. It gives final judgment for one party, not an order that only lasts until trial.
Most summary judgment provisions can resolve part of a claim, not just the whole claim. If only part is decided, the proceeding continues for the rest (Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 26.01(4)).
Strike-out rules work on a pleading (the formal document setting out a party’s case). Summary judgment provisions instead work on a claim, a defence, or the whole proceeding. Their grounds overlap but are not the same test.
South Australia is not covered here. The Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) are not cited in this article, so nothing is said about the South Australian position.
What the statutory test displaced
Before the new tests, courts used a general-law standard from General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways (NSW) [1964] HCA 69; (1964) 112 CLR 125. Barwick CJ said a plaintiff should not be shut out unless it is clearly shown there is no cause of action. He listed phrases like “so obviously untenable that it cannot possibly succeed” and “manifestly groundless”.
Barwick CJ also warned this is not an easy test. He said real argument may be needed to show a case is clearly untenable.
The statutory provisions set a lower bar. Section 31A(3) says a defence or proceeding need not be hopeless or bound to fail to have “no reasonable prospect of success”. Northern Territory r 22.01(3) says the same about defences. The passage warns: do not apply the old General Steel test to this different statutory wording.
In Spencer v Commonwealth of Australia [2010] HCA 28, the High Court unanimously allowed an appeal against a summary dismissal under s 31A(2). The judges gave different reasons on how s 31A should be understood.
The joint reasons (Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ) said General Steel’s formulations required “demonstrated certainty” of failure. Since s 31A(3) removes that certainty requirement, they said s 31A calls for a different inquiry. They called it “dangerous” to explain the new test using the old formulations.
The joint reasons also said no single paraphrase can fully capture “no reasonable prospect of success”. Courts must give weight to the whole phrase: dismissal is only proper if a court is satisfied there is no reasonable prospect of success. They added that this summary power “is not to be exercised lightly”.
Qualifications that decide applications
Even when the test for summary judgment is met, courts can still keep a case going. In Victoria, s 64 lets the court send a case to trial despite no real prospect of success, if a full hearing is needed in the interests of justice or because of the dispute’s nature. This discretion is not found in the other rules discussed.
Some claims cannot use this procedure at all. Tasmania’s r 356(2) excludes defamation, malicious prosecution, false imprisonment and fraud claims. Western Australia’s O 14 r 1(2) excludes probate and admiralty actions.
Time limits vary. Western Australia requires applications within 21 days after appearance, unless the court allows longer (O 14 r 1(1); O 16 r 1(1)). Tasmania gives defendants 10 days (r 367(1)). Queensland and the ACT set no outer limit. Service must occur at least 14 days before hearing in the Federal Court (r 26.01(3)), or 7 days in WA (O 16 r 1(4)).
Evidence is usually by affidavit. The Federal Court requires grounds and facts to be stated (r 26.01(2)). The ACT allows affidavits based on information and belief, if sources are given, and bars cross-examination without leave (r 1149). Tasmania allows hearsay in a defendant’s affidavit if the source is also given, unless a judge says otherwise (r 359(2)).
A cross-claim, meaning a claim brought back against the other party, may continue after judgment. The respondent can seek a stay, pausing enforcement, until it is resolved (Cth r 26.01(5); WA O 14 r 3(2); Tas r 358(2)).
Applying this in a problem question
First, work out which court applies, then find that court’s own test. Check whether the test sits in the rules of court or, as in Victoria, in the governing Act itself.
State the test in the court’s own wording. Don’t assume a “no reasonable prospect” test applies if the rule actually asks whether the defendant has a defence.
Where it is a prospects test, apply the exact statutory phrase, not an older formulation. In Queensland, also check the second condition, and say whether a trial is still needed.
Where it is a no-defence test, identify what the applicant must prove in evidence. Then ask what issue or question the respondent points to as needing a trial.
Before concluding, check the qualifications: any excluded cause of action, the time limit for the application, the service period, and whether evidence or cross-examination is available. In Victoria, also ask whether s 64 would send the matter to trial anyway.
If the application succeeds only in part, say what remains on foot. Note whether any cross-claim continues, or whether enforcement is stayed.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.