Enforcing a money judgment
How each Australian jurisdiction’s enforcement instrument lets an unpaid judgment creditor reach the debtor’s goods, land, debts, earnings and securities, what each order is called and when it attaches, the leave and limitation bars, and the separate bankruptcy notice and statutory demand routes.
Learning outcomes
- Identify the instrument that governs enforcement of a money judgment given by a named Australian court, and use that instrument’s own name for each order.
- Match a judgment debtor’s asset - goods, land, a third party debt, earnings or securities - to the enforcement order that reaches it in the governing jurisdiction.
- Apply the leave and limitation provisions to an old judgment, and distinguish a leave requirement from an outright bar.
- Explain when a judgment creditor’s unsatisfied judgment supports a bankruptcy notice or a statutory demand instead of an enforcement order.
A money judgment is an entitlement to be paid; it is not the payment, and no court collects it. A creditor who is not paid must apply for a further order aimed at something the debtor has — goods, land, a bank balance, wages or a shareholding — and those orders are the creature of each court’s own Act or rules of court. So the prior question in every enforcement problem is which instrument governs: the orders carry different names, attach at different moments, and face different prerequisites and time bars. This article states the Commonwealth, New South Wales, Victorian, Queensland, Western Australian, Tasmanian, Northern Territory and Australian Capital Territory provisions. It does not state the South Australian position, because no South Australian provision is cited here.
What the enforcement orders are called
Each instrument lists the orders available against a money judgment, and the list is where to start.
- New South Wales. A judgment debt may be enforced by a writ for the levy of property, a garnishee order, or — only on a judgment of the Supreme Court or the District Court — a charging order: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) s 106(1).2 Section 103 leaves the procedure to the rules of court.
- Victoria and the Northern Territory share a list: warrant of seizure and sale, attachment of debts, attachment of earnings, charging order, appointment of a receiver and, where the committal rule applies, committal and sequestration — Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2025 (Vic) r 66.02(1)3 and Supreme Court Rules 1987 (NT) r 66.02(1).8 Each adds that the list does not affect any other means of enforcement.
- Queensland works through enforcement warrants under Chapter 19 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) — for seizure and sale, redirection of debts, redirection of earnings and charging orders — alongside instalment orders and enforcement hearings.5
- The Australian Capital Territory issues one enforcement order, which may contain any order directed to enforcing the original order; r 2001(3) of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) lists eleven kinds, among them seizure and sale, debt redirection, earnings redirection and charging orders.9
- Western Australia has its own statute and vocabulary: under the Civil Judgments Enforcement Act 2004 (WA) s 17 an enforcement order is a time for payment order, an instalment order, an earnings appropriation order, a debt appropriation order, a property (seizure and sale) order, or an order under s 86. Section 7(1) abolished the writs, warrants and orders previously available at common law, in equity or under a written law to enforce a judgment, so the older names have nothing to attach to.6
- Tasmania keeps those older names: the Supreme Court Rules 2000 (Tas) provide for writs of execution and of fieri facias, attachment of debts, attachment of wages and salaries, and charging orders.7
- The Federal Court borrows. Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 41.10(1) lets a party apply for an order, a writ or any other step “that can be taken in the Supreme Court of the State or Territory in which the judgment or order has been made as if the judgment or order was a judgment or order of that Supreme Court”.1 A federal money judgment is enforced with State machinery, so the State instrument must still be identified.
Finding out what the debtor has
Every one of these jurisdictions can compel the debtor to disclose their finances; the differences lie in who asks and what is asked about.
In New South Wales the court may order a person bound by a judgment to attend to be orally examined as to any material question or to produce documents (s 108), the material questions being what debts are owing to that person and what other property or means of satisfying the judgment they have. Victoria, the Northern Territory and Tasmania use the same “material questions” formula — in Victoria and the Northern Territory under the heading discovery in aid of enforcement (r 67.02), and in Tasmania with separate subrules for a corporate and a non-corporate debtor (r 889).
Queensland and the Australian Capital Territory hold an enforcement hearing instead. Queensland’s r 803 states its purpose plainly: “to obtain information to facilitate the enforcement of a money order”, and under r 813 a person summoned must attend to give information, answer questions and produce documents, and may be examined about the debtor’s property and other means of satisfying the order debt. The Australian Capital Territory’s enforcement hearing is to the same effect, and unless the court orders otherwise the examination on oath may be conducted by the court and the enforcement creditor (r 2109).
Western Australia calls it a means inquiry, and s 26 makes it wider than the debtor alone: the court determines the debtor’s means to pay having regard to the income, assets and liabilities of the debtor and, if applicable, of the debtor’s spouse or de facto partner and any dependants; whether there are earnings or an available debt that might be appropriated; and the existence, whereabouts and value of seizable property.
Reaching goods, land, debts and earnings
In New South Wales a writ for the levy of property is sufficient authority for the Sheriff to do five distinct things, and the verbs differ: to “seize and to sell” the debtor’s goods, to “seize” money belonging to the debtor, to “seize and to realise” cheques, bills of exchange, promissory notes, bonds, specialties or other securities for money belonging to the debtor, to enter into possession of and sell the debtor’s land, and to take and sell choses in action or equitable interests in goods or land held by the debtor (s 106(2)). Money is seized, securities are seized and realised, and it is the goods and the land that are sold. The writ binds the land from delivery to the Sheriff, though a judgment by itself does not bind or affect any land (s 112). Western Australia uses a property (seizure and sale) order authorising the sheriff to seize and sell the debtor’s property to wholly or partially satisfy the judgment debt (s 59(1)). The Australian Capital Territory divides the order by court: the Supreme Court’s reaches all real and personal property, other than exempt property, in which the debtor has a legal or beneficial interest, the Magistrates Court’s only personal property, again other than exempt property (r 2200).
A debt owed to the debtor by a third party is the most commonly useful target, and a bank balance counts. In New South Wales a garnishee order attaches all debts due or accruing from the garnishee to the debtor at the time of service, to the extent of the amount outstanding, and a credit balance with a financial institution is taken to be a debt owed by that institution (s 117). The moment of attachment then differs, and within Victoria it differs between two kinds of debt. A debt due or accruing to the debtor on the day the order for filing and service of the garnishee summons is made is attached and bound on service of the summons (r 71.08(1)); a debt not yet due or accruing on that day, but which becomes due or accrues between that day and the hearing day named in the summons, is attached “when it becomes due or accrues” (rr 71.02(b), 71.08(2)).3 Queensland and the Australian Capital Territory each fix the test at the day of service, but not in the same words. In Queensland the warrant may authorise redirection only of “specified debts certainly payable” (r 840(1)), and a debt may be redirected “only if the debt, or the part of the debt belonging to the enforcement debtor, is payable to the enforcement debtor from the third person on the date the enforcement warrant is served on the third person” (r 840(3)) — a test that does not reach a debt merely accruing on that date — although r 840(4) takes a regular redirection under division 2 outside that restriction.5 In the Australian Capital Territory a debt may be redirected “only if the debt is payable or accruing to the enforcement debtor by the third person on the day the order for redirection of the debt is served on the third person” (r 2301(3)), so a debt accruing on the service day is within the order there.9
Against wages, New South Wales attaches wage or salary payable while the order is in force, or amounts equivalent to the instalments where an instalment order has been made, and the order ceases when the debt is satisfied (s 119). Victoria and the Northern Territory require the court to be satisfied that the debtor is a person to whom earnings are payable or likely to become payable, and either that at least $20 was due and unpaid when the application was made or that the debtor has persistently failed to comply with an order about the judgment (r 72.03). Tasmania begins with a provisional order, which a judge, the Registrar or a district registrar may make without requiring any attendance, directing the garnishee to deduct the prescribed amount each pay-day and hold it until the order is made final or discharged (r 921).
Instalment orders, and the orders that must wait for one
An instalment order turns the judgment into a payment plan, and in New South Wales execution of a money judgment is stayed while such an order is in force (s 107). Queensland may make one when the money order is made or at any later time before it is satisfied, on application without notice, and r 869 requires regard to the debtor’s employment, means, living expenses and other liabilities — expressly without an enforcement hearing first. The Australian Capital Territory allows the order on application by either party or on the filing of an instalment order agreement (r 2150).
Two jurisdictions sit outside that pattern. In Victoria the power is not in the rules at all. The Judgment Debt Recovery Act 1984 (Vic) s 5 lets the court order payment by instalments when giving judgment, and s 6 lets either party apply afterwards to the proper officer of the court, who may make or refuse the order without notice and whether or not either party is before the officer, with either party then able to object and send the matter to a hearing.4 In Western Australia the instalment order is a gateway, not an alternative. A time for payment order, an instalment order and an earnings appropriation order may only be made at or after a means inquiry (s 21(1)), and an earnings appropriation order “must not be made unless an instalment order has been made in respect of the judgment debt and has been disobeyed and cancelled” (s 35(3)).
Charging orders over securities
A charging order charges an interest the debtor holds rather than taking anything. New South Wales applies it to stock and shares in a public company, money on deposit in a financial institution held in the debtor’s own right or on trust for the debtor, and any equitable interest in property; the order charges that interest to the extent necessary to satisfy the judgment and restrains the chargee from dealing with it otherwise than as the creditor directs (s 126(1), (2)). Victoria and the Northern Territory state the power in a sentence — the court may impose a charge on the debtor’s beneficial interest in any securities (r 73.02) — and the Australian Capital Territory lists the interests it reaches, with the same two effects as in New South Wales (r 2401).
Two qualifications are worth carrying. The charge cannot be realised at once — the creditor must wait three months from the date of the order in New South Wales (s 126(4)), and in Queensland three months from service (r 876(3)). And the list of enforcement orders in the Western Australian Act contains no charging order.
Leave, and how long a judgment stays enforceable
The outer limits diverge sharply, and they are the trap in a problem about an old judgment. Six years is the common trigger for needing leave: enforcement proceedings may be started without leave within six years in Queensland (r 799), and Tasmania, Victoria and the Australian Capital Territory require leave once six years have elapsed, as well as where the identity of those entitled or liable has changed and in several other listed circumstances (Tas rr 896, 897; Vic r 68.02; ACT r 2012). New South Wales uses twelve: an application for a writ of execution, a garnishee order, a charging order or an order for examination may not be made except by leave once the prescribed period has elapsed, and that period is twelve years unless the uniform rules prescribe another (s 134). Western Australia also uses twelve years, but not as a leave requirement — s 12 says an order to enforce a judgment “must not be made if 12 years have elapsed since the judgment took effect”. That is a bar, and no application for leave cures it.
When the creditor turns to insolvency
A creditor who concludes that no enforcement order will work has a different route, and it is Commonwealth law in both branches. Against an individual, an unsatisfied judgment supports a bankruptcy notice, which an Official Receiver may issue on the application of a creditor holding a final judgment or final order of the kind described in s 40(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) for an amount of at least the statutory minimum, and must not issue if execution has been stayed. Failure to comply within the time fixed — unless the debtor satisfies the Court of a counter-claim, set-off or cross demand equal to or exceeding the judgment debt that the debtor could not have set up in the proceeding in which the judgment was obtained — is an act of bankruptcy, on which the Court may make a sequestration order on a creditor’s petition.10
Against a company, the equivalent is a statutory demand under s 459E of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for a debt due and payable of at least the statutory minimum, requiring payment, security or compounding to the creditor’s reasonable satisfaction within the statutory period. A judgment creditor is better placed than other creditors: the verifying affidavit s 459E(3) otherwise requires is not needed where the debt is a judgment debt. Failure to comply obliges the court to presume the company insolvent, and so does an execution on a judgment returned wholly or partly unsatisfied, where either happened during or after the three months ending on the day the application was made, rebuttable only so far as the contrary is proved.11 A failed execution is therefore not only a dead end but evidence.
Applying this in a problem question
- Name the court that gave the judgment and open that jurisdiction’s enforcement instrument. For a Federal Court judgment, identify the State or Territory Supreme Court whose machinery r 41.10 imports.
- Date the judgment and check leave and limitation first — six years in Queensland, Victoria, Tasmania and the Australian Capital Territory, twelve in New South Wales, and an absolute twelve-year bar in Western Australia.
- Ask what the creditor knows about the debtor’s finances. If the answer is nothing, start with the examination, enforcement hearing or means inquiry.
- Match the asset to the order using the governing instrument’s own name for it: goods and land to a writ, warrant or seizure and sale order; a bank balance or trade debt to a garnishee, attachment, redirection or appropriation order; wages to an earnings order; securities to a charging order.
- Check when the order attaches and what must already have happened — a debt must usually be payable on the day of service, and a Western Australian earnings appropriation order requires an instalment order that has been disobeyed and cancelled.
- If no order will reach anything, consider the bankruptcy notice or statutory demand.