Aged and disability care law in Victoria

Commonwealth or State?

The Commonwealth funds and regulates aged care and disability services. This happens under the Aged Care Act 2024 (Cth) and the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). These Acts cover registration, quality standards, reportable incidents, and worker screening.

Victoria handles different matters: capacity, consent, restrictive practices, and complaints. Victoria also registers social service providers generally.

This means two registration systems can apply to the same provider at once — a Commonwealth one and a Victorian one. Watch for this overlap.

Capacity: will and preferences

Victoria’s current law is the Guardianship and Administration Act 2019 (Vic). Section 9 sets out decision-making principles based on the person’s will and preferences. Section 8(1)(b) supports these principles.

Section 30 is strict. VCAT can only make a guardianship or administration order if three things are all true: the person lacks decision-making capacity for that particular matter because of a disability, the person needs a guardian or administrator, and the order will promote their personal and social wellbeing (s 30(2)(a)–(c)). Capacity is judged matter by matter, not as a general state. An extra condition applies under s 30(2)(d) if the order concerns administration for someone who lives outside Victoria. All conditions must be met; lacking capacity alone is not enough for an order.

The Act also allows supportive orders. These do not transfer decision-making power to someone else. They are still a type of VCAT order (s 30(1)(a)(iii)–(iv)), but have different conditions under s 87(2): the person must consent, must have capacity for the matter if given practical support, and the order must promote their wellbeing.

Section 8(1)(c) requires VCAT, and anyone else using powers under the Act, to use the option that least limits the person’s ability to decide and act for themselves.

Advance treatment decisions: two kinds of directive

In Victoria, an advance care directive under the Medical Treatment Planning and Decisions Act 2016 can contain two things: an instructional directive, a values directive, or both (s 12(2)). If a statement is not clearly labelled an instructional directive, it counts as a values directive (s 12(3)(a)).

An instructional directive states a decision. It takes effect as if the person had consented or refused treatment themselves. A values directive instead states the person’s preferences and values. It guides decisions but does not bind anyone.

Section 60(1)(a) says a health practitioner must, so far as reasonably practicable and subject to s 51, follow a relevant instructional directive. This means withholding or withdrawing refused treatment, or giving consented treatment if the practitioner thinks it clinically appropriate.

Section 61(1) sets a substituted judgment standard for medical treatment decision makers. This means the decision maker must choose what they reasonably believe the person would have decided, not what seems objectively best. Only if the person’s preferences and values cannot be worked out or applied does s 61(3) direct the decision maker to consider the person’s personal and social wellbeing instead.

For exams or advice, first classify the directive before deciding what it requires. The common mistake is treating a values directive as binding, or an instructional directive as merely a guide.

Powers of attorney, and the supportive attorney

This section looks at Victoria’s Powers of Attorney Act 2014 (Vic). Section 21 sets out least-restrictive and participation principles. These apply when an attorney acts for a principal who lacks capacity for a matter. Section 21(2)(a) says the attorney must give all practicable and appropriate effect to the principal’s wishes.

The Act’s new idea is the supportive attorney, found in ss 85 to 89. A supportive attorney can only access information, communicate the principal’s decisions, and carry them out. The principal still makes the decision (s 85(2)) — the supportive attorney never decides for them.

This appointment has limits. It cannot cover medical treatment or medical research (s 85(1)). The power to give effect to decisions does not extend to a significant financial transaction (s 89(1)).

Victoria has four separate arrangements: supportive attorney, enduring attorney, supportive order, and guardianship or administration order. These are not steps on a ladder — each has its own test. A supportive order needs the person’s consent and capacity with support (s 87(2), 2019 Act). A guardianship or administration order needs incapacity, need, and benefit (s 30(2)).

When advising, check which arrangements are actually available on the facts. Keep in mind the least-restrictive principle in s 8(1)(c) of the 2019 Act, and consider less restrictive options before seeking guardianship or administration.

Complaints, and carers

The Health Complaints Act 2016 (Vic) uses a two-tier complaints process. Section 5 and s 6 say a complaint usually goes to the health service provider first.

Sometimes a complaint can go straight to the Commissioner instead. This applies where a provider complaint would be unreasonable or inappropriate (s 5(2)(a)), or if it is not resolved within three months (s 5(2)(c)). Check which route applies before telling a client to skip the provider.

The Carers Recognition Act 2012 (Vic) defines a “care relationship” in s 4. This depends on who the parties are and four grounds of need.

Sections 7 and 8 set out principles for carers and for the people they care for. Under s 10, these principles give no enforceable legal right or entitlement.

Section 6 says other Acts prevail over any inconsistency with this Act. The exception is s 12, which requires care support organisations to report on their compliance.

A working order for a Victorian problem

This is a step-by-step approach to Victorian aged and disability care problems.

First, split the jurisdiction. Check whether Victorian provider registration under the 2021 Act also applies.

Second, assess capacity for the specific matter, not generally. Apply the will and preferences principles in s 9.

Third, compare the options — supportive attorney, enduring attorney, supportive order, guardianship or administration order — against their statutory conditions. Consider the least-restrictive principle in s 8(1)(c) before seeking an order under s 30.

Fourth, classify any advance care directive as instructional or values-based before deciding what it requires.

Fifth, apply substituted judgment under s 61(1) to a medical treatment decision maker’s choice, not best interests. Substituted judgment means asking what the person themselves would have wanted.

Sixth, for a restrictive practice, check for Authorised Program Officer authorisation. Also check whether Senior Practitioner approval is needed.

Seventh, for a complaint, check if the direct-to-Commissioner route is available before bypassing the provider.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.