Aged and disability care law in Victoria

A wayfinding guide to Victoria’s seven aged and disability care statutes: the will-and-preferences model, the two kinds of advance care directive, the supportive attorney, and the Social Services Regulator.

Learning level
Application
Jurisdictions
vic, au-commonwealth
Subjects
health-disability-and-elder-law
Topics
health-disability-and-elder-law-framework, guardianship-and-administration, advance-care-directives-and-consent-to-treatment

Learning outcomes

  • Separate the Commonwealth questions in an aged or disability care problem from the Victorian ones, including the two registration regimes a Victorian provider may face.
  • Apply each condition in s 30(2) of the Guardianship and Administration Act 2019 (Vic) and assess capacity for the particular matter.
  • Distinguish an instructional directive from a values directive under s 12 of the Medical Treatment Planning and Decisions Act 2016 (Vic).
  • Compare the Victorian support and substitute decision-making arrangements, from supportive attorney to guardianship order, by their statutory conditions.

This article is a wayfinding guide. It states the law of Victoria, and identifies where Commonwealth law governs instead. For each question it names the Act and section that answers it: cite that Act and section, name Victoria expressly, and read the linked article on the statute for the detail.

Victoria’s guardianship, medical treatment and powers of attorney statutes were all remade between 2014 and 2019 around a single idea — will and preferences rather than best interests — and in 2021 it enacted a general social services regulator.

Commonwealth or State?

The Commonwealth funds and regulates the service under the Aged Care Act 2024 (Cth) and the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth): registration, quality standards, reportable incidents and worker screening obligations under those schemes.98

Victoria governs capacity, consent, restrictive practices, complaints — and the general registration of social service providers. The last of those is the feature to watch: Victoria regulates providers as well, and the two registration systems coexist.

The seven statutes, and what each answers

The questionThe ActThe decision-maker
Can this adult decide, and who decides if not?3Guardianship and Administration Act 2019 (Vic)VCAT
What did this person decide in advance about treatment?4Medical Treatment Planning and Decisions Act 2016 (Vic)The medical treatment decision maker; VCAT
Who deals with property and money, and who merely supports?5Powers of Attorney Act 2014 (Vic)The attorney or supportive attorney; VCAT
May this restrictive practice be used?6Disability Act 2006 (Vic)Authorised Program Officer; Senior Practitioner
Is this provider registered, and to what standards?7Social Services Regulation Act 2021 (Vic)The Social Services Regulator
Who hears a complaint about a health service?1Health Complaints Act 2016 (Vic)The provider first; then the Commissioner
Which care relationship principles apply to this unpaid carer?2Carers Recognition Act 2012 (Vic)Care support organisations

Capacity: will and preferences

The Guardianship and Administration Act 2019 (Vic) is the modern model.3 Section 9 sets decision-making principles directed by the person’s will and preferences, and s 8(1)(b) works with them.

Section 30 is the operative provision and it is strict. VCAT may make a guardianship or administration order only if satisfied that, because of the person’s disability, the person does not have decision-making capacity for the particular matter — capacity is assessed matter by matter, not globally — that the person is in need of a guardian or administrator, and that the order will promote the person’s personal and social wellbeing (s 30(2)(a)–(c)); an administration order for a person who does not live in Victoria carries a further condition in s 30(2)(d). Each condition must be satisfied: a person who lacks capacity is not, for that reason alone, a person for whom an order may be made.

The Act also provides for supportive orders, which do not transfer decision-making authority at all. A supportive order is itself a VCAT order (s 30(1)(a)(iii)–(iv)), but its conditions are different: under s 87(2) the person must consent, must have decision-making capacity for the matter if given practicable and appropriate support, and the order must promote their personal and social wellbeing. Section 8(1)(c) requires VCAT, like anyone exercising a power under the Act, to have regard to the principle that powers be exercised in the way least restrictive of the person’s ability to decide and act.

Advance treatment decisions: two kinds of directive

The Medical Treatment Planning and Decisions Act 2016 (Vic) divides the advance care directive in two. A directive may contain an instructional directive, a values directive or both (s 12(2)), and any statement not expressly identified on the face of the document as an instructional directive is a values directive (s 12(3)(a)).

Section 12 distinguishes an instructional directive — a statement of a decision that takes effect as if the person had consented or refused — from a values directive, a statement of the person’s preferences and values that guides rather than binds. Section 60(1)(a) then requires a health practitioner, as far as reasonably practicable and subject to s 51, to give effect to a relevant instructional directive: by withholding or withdrawing treatment the directive refuses, or by administering treatment it consents to if the practitioner considers that clinically appropriate.

Section 61(1) imposes a substituted judgment standard on the medical treatment decision maker: the decision maker must make the decision they reasonably believe the person would have made with decision-making capacity, not what is objectively best for them. Only where the person’s preferences and values cannot be ascertained or applied does s 61(3) direct the decision maker to the person’s personal and social wellbeing.

The practical consequence in an exam or in advice: read the directive and classify it before asking what it requires. A values directive that is treated as binding, or an instructional directive that is treated as merely indicative, is the standard error.

Powers of attorney, and the supportive attorney

The Powers of Attorney Act 2014 (Vic) states least-restrictive and participation principles in s 21 for a person acting under an enduring power for a principal who lacks decision-making capacity in relation to one or more matters, and requires an attorney deciding such a matter to give all practicable and appropriate effect to the principal’s wishes (s 21(2)(a)).

Its innovation is in ss 85 to 89: the supportive attorney appointment. A supportive attorney may exercise only the powers specified in the appointment — to access information, to communicate the principal’s decisions and to give effect to them — and the decision remains the principal’s (s 85(2)). The appointment cannot extend to medical treatment or medical research matters (s 85(1)), and the power to give effect to decisions does not reach a significant financial transaction (s 89(1)). This is supported decision-making given statutory form: unlike an enduring attorney, a supportive attorney never decides for the principal.

Victoria therefore offers distinct arrangements — a supportive attorney, an enduring attorney, a supportive order, and a guardianship or administration order — and they are not rungs of a statutory ladder. Each has its own conditions: a supportive order needs the person’s consent and capacity with support (s 87(2) of the 2019 Act), a guardianship or administration order needs incapacity, need and benefit (s 30(2)). Advice should identify which arrangements are legally available on the facts and, with the least-restrictive principle in s 8(1)(c) of the 2019 Act in mind, consider the less restrictive ones before a guardianship or administration order is sought.

Restrictive practices

The Disability Act 2006 (Vic) supplies the authorisation that the Commonwealth National Disability Insurance Scheme (Restrictive Practices and Behaviour Support) Rules 2018 require.10 Section 135 prohibits a disability service provider or registered NDIS provider from using a regulated restrictive practice unless an Authorised Program Officer’s authorisation under s 136 is in force and, where required, the use has been approved by the Senior Practitioner under s 143. Approval is always required for seclusion, physical restraint or mechanical restraint, and also for any form of practice, or any person or class of persons, that the Senior Practitioner has specified by direction. Sections 137 and 145 are the exceptions, s 145 dealing with emergencies.

In a problem question, that means two steps: the officer’s authorisation under s 136, and then, where ss 135 and 143 require it, the Senior Practitioner’s approval.

The Social Services Regulator

The Social Services Regulation Act 2021 (Vic) establishes Victoria’s integrated regulator. Section 1 states its purposes: to establish the Social Services Regulator, to provide for registration of social service providers, to require compliance with the Social Services Standards, and to establish a worker and carer exclusion scheme. Sections 7 and 8 then state the Regulator’s objects and the guiding principles it must apply.

For a problem question, this means a Victorian provider may face two registration regimes at once — Commonwealth registration under the NDIS or aged care schemes, and Victorian registration under this Act — with two sets of standards and two regulators. Identify both before advising on a provider’s obligations.

Complaints, and carers

The Health Complaints Act 2016 (Vic) sets a two-tier structure. Section 5 and s 6 provide that a complaint is ordinarily made to the health service provider first, with defined routes permitting a complaint directly to the Commissioner — for example, where a provider complaint would be unreasonable or inappropriate (s 5(2)(a)), or where a provider complaint is not resolved within three months (s 5(2)(c)). Identify the applicable route before advising a client to bypass the provider.

The Carers Recognition Act 2012 (Vic) defines a care relationship in s 4 by reference to either party and four grounds of need, and states principles in ss 7 and 8 for carers and for the persons being cared for. Those principles create no right or entitlement enforceable at law (s 10), and under s 6 any other Act prevails over an inconsistency with this Act other than s 12, which requires care support organisations to report on their compliance.

A working order for a Victorian problem

  1. Split the jurisdiction, and check whether Victorian provider registration under the 2021 Act is also engaged.
  2. Assess capacity for the particular matter, not generally, and apply the will and preferences principles in s 9.
  3. Compare the available arrangements — supportive attorney, enduring attorney, supportive order, guardianship or administration order — by their statutory conditions, and have regard to the least-restrictive principle in s 8(1)(c) before seeking an order under s 30.
  4. Classify any advance care directive as instructional or values-based before asking what it requires.
  5. Apply substituted judgment under s 61(1) to a medical treatment decision maker’s decision, not best interests.
  6. For a restrictive practice, identify both the Authorised Program Officer authorisation and whether Senior Practitioner approval is required.
  7. For a complaint, establish whether the direct-to-Commissioner route is available before bypassing the provider.

Self-check

  • Have I applied the decision-making standard the particular Act requires — will and preferences under the 2019 Act, substituted judgment under s 61 of the 2016 Act?
  • Have I addressed every condition in s 30(2) — incapacity for the matter because of disability, need for a guardian or administrator, and promotion of personal and social wellbeing?
  • Have I considered a supportive attorney or supportive order before a guardianship order?
  • Have I classified the directive before applying it?
  • Have I checked whether the provider is registered under the Social Services Regulation Act 2021 as well as federally?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.