Health complaints and carers recognition in Victoria

Victoria’s two-tier health complaints route under the Health Complaints Act 2016 (Vic), and the care relationship principles that cover both carer and cared-for person.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
vic
Subjects
health-disability-and-elder-law
Topics
health-and-community-services-complaints, carers-recognition

Learning outcomes

  • Explain the two-tier complaints structure in ss 5 and 6 of the Health Complaints Act 2016 (Vic) and when a complaint may go directly to the Commissioner.
  • Identify the grounds of complaint, including failure to comply with the duty of candour.
  • State who is in a care relationship under s 4 of the Carers Recognition Act 2012 (Vic) and why the definition reaches both parties.
  • Explain the effect of s 6 of that Act where another Act is inconsistent with it.

This article states the law of Victoria. Two statutes sit at the edge of the aged care and disability systems: the Health Complaints Act 2016 (Vic), which routes complaints about health services, and the Carers Recognition Act 2012 (Vic), which defines the care relationship and states principles about it.

Complaints go to the provider first

The Victorian scheme is two-tier, and that is its defining feature. Section 5(1) provides that a person may complain to the health service provider about the unreasonable provision of a health service; an unreasonable failure to provide a service sought; an unreasonable failure to act consistently with the health service principles; the provision of a service in an unreasonable manner; any failure to comply with the duty of candour under Part 5A of the Health Services Act 1988 (Vic); or the manner in which the provider dealt with a complaint, including inconsistency with complaint handling standards1.

The duty of candour ground was inserted in 2022 and is worth noticing: a provider’s failure to comply with the statutory duty of candour in Part 5A of the Health Services Act 1988 (Vic) is itself a complainable matter, not merely evidence about something else.

When a complaint may go straight to the Commissioner

Section 5(2) states four routes to the Commissioner, and identifying which one is engaged is the analytical step most often skipped.

First, a complaint may go directly to the Commissioner about anything within s 5(1), without first complaining to the provider, if it would be unreasonable or inappropriate to resolve the matter by a provider complaint (s 5(2)(a)). Second, a complaint may be made about a general health service provider failing to comply or act consistently with an applicable code of conduct, or failing to comply with an interim prohibition order or a prohibition order. Third, a complaint may go to the Commissioner about a matter already complained of to the provider if that complaint is not resolved within three months (s 5(2)(c)). Fourth, a complaint may be made about the manner in which the provider dealt with the s 5(1) complaint.

The three-month route is a hard-edged trigger and the one most likely to decide a problem on the facts.

Section 6 extends both tiers to a complaint about a health service received or sought by another person, so a family member or advocate is not shut out.

Section 7 gives a carer a complaint of their own, about how the carer was treated rather than about the service. A carer of a person may complain to the provider about any unreasonable treatment of the carer by the provider when providing or failing to provide a health service to the person cared for, or in the course of complying or failing to comply with the duty of candour in relation to that person, and about the manner in which the provider dealt with the carer’s complaint (s 7(1)). Section 7(2) then gives the carer three of the routes to the Commissioner that s 5(2) gives the person who received or sought the service: directly, if resolving the matter by a provider complaint would be unreasonable or inappropriate; after three months, if a provider complaint is not resolved; or about the manner in which the provider dealt with the carer’s complaint. “Carer” has the meaning it has in the Carers Recognition Act 2012 (Vic) (s 3), so this is where the two statutes meet1.

In Victoria, then, the first question is one of sequence: has the complaint been made to the provider, and if not, which s 5(2) route takes it straight to the Commissioner? For the New South Wales and South Australian schemes, see complaints and carers recognition in New South Wales and in South Australia.

The care relationship covers both parties

The Carers Recognition Act 2012 (Vic) defines a relationship, not just a carer. Under s 4(1), a person is in a care relationship if he or she provides another person, or receives from another person, care because one of the persons in the relationship has a disability, is older, has a mental illness, or has an ongoing medical condition including a terminal or chronic illness or dementia2.

The phrase “provides another person, or receives from another person” is the drafting to notice. Both parties are in the care relationship, and the Act’s principles run to both: s 7 states principles relating to carers, and s 8 states principles relating to persons being cared for.

Section 7 states that a carer should be respected and recognised as an individual with their own needs, as a carer, and as someone with special knowledge of the person in their care, and be supported including through changes in the relationship. Section 8 states that the person being cared for should be respected, recognised and supported as an individual and as a person in a care relationship, and have their views taken into account together with their needs, cultural identity and best interests.

Section 4(2) extends care relationships to certain arrangements under the Children, Youth and Families Act 2005 (Vic), including permanent care orders and child care agreements.

What the Carers Act yields to

Section 6 is short and consequential: “If there is any inconsistency between this Act (other than section 12) and any other Act, the provisions of the other Act prevail.”

Where the Carers Recognition Act is inconsistent with any other Act, it gives way. The one exception is s 12, which requires a care support organisation to report on its compliance with its obligations under s 11. A student should not deploy the care relationship principles against a specific statutory scheme without addressing s 6 first.

Section 10 makes a separate point: the care relationship principles “do not create, or confer on any person, any right or entitlement enforceable at law”. They guide how carers and the people they care for are treated; they do not found a claim.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify whether the complaint is being made to the provider under s 5(1) or to the Commissioner under s 5(2).
  2. If it goes straight to the Commissioner, name the s 5(2) route relied on, and for s 5(2)(a) explain why a provider complaint would be unreasonable or inappropriate.
  3. Check the three-month trigger in s 5(2)(c) where a provider complaint has already been made.
  4. Consider whether the duty of candour ground in s 5(1)(da) is engaged on the facts.
  5. For a carer question, apply s 4(1) and note that either party may be the one in the relationship, then apply s 7 or s 8 as appropriate. If the carer complains about their own treatment by a provider, the route is s 7 of the Health Complaints Act.
  6. Before relying on the carer principles against another statute, address s 6.

Self-check

  • Have I identified which tier the complaint belongs to?
  • Have I named the s 5(2) route rather than assuming direct access?
  • Have I noticed that the Victorian care relationship reaches both parties?
  • Have I addressed s 6 before relying on the carer principles?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.