Taylor v Johnson

High Court of Australia · 1983

ContractVitiating Factors

Taylor v Johnson (1983) 151 CLR 422

Ten acres, and a price of $15,000. The seller thought that was the price per acre. The buyer suspected something was wrong with her figure — and made sure it stayed that way.

What happened?

Mrs Johnson granted an option over ten acres of land at a price of $15,000. She believed that figure was the price per acre — roughly ten times what the document provided, which set it for the whole. The option was granted to Laurence Taylor; his children were the contractual purchasers. He believed she was mistaken as to price or value, avoided reopening the subject, and told her untruthfully that he had no copy of the option to give her. When she realised, she refused to complete, and the purchasers sued for specific performance.

What did the Court decide?

The contract was set aside and specific performance refused. Mrs Johnson was not held to a sale of ten acres at a tenth of what she believed she was getting. Dawson J dissented.

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

A contract may be set aside in equity where one party entered it under a serious mistake about the contents of a written contract concerning a fundamental term, and the other, aware of circumstances indicating a serious mistake as to that term’s content or its subject matter, deliberately acted to prevent its discovery.

The parties’ knowledge requirements differ. The party seeking relief must have been seriously mistaken about what the written contract said on a fundamental term. The other party need not have known precisely what was misread: the majority addressed a lack of precise knowledge arising from wilful ignorance, coupled with deliberate conduct to inhibit discovery. Its formulation was confined to circumstances where that party had not materially altered their position and strangers’ rights had not intervened.

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Ratio · Mason ACJ, Murphy and Deane JJ

Read judgment: pp 432–433 (opens in a new tab)

The joint majority formulated this narrow equitable rule as the ground for disposing of the appeal and applied it to Mrs Johnson’s mistake about the written price term and Mr Taylor’s deliberate prevention of discovery. It was necessary to uphold rescission and dismiss the purchasers’ appeal. Precise knowledge of her actual mistake was unnecessary where his ignorance was wilful; the formulation was expressly confined to circumstances in which he had not materially altered his position and strangers’ rights had not intervened.

Why does this case matter?

It is the Australian answer to a question the common law handles badly. At law a contract is formed on what the parties objectively appeared to agree, which in a case like this produces a binding bargain at a tenth of what the vendor thought she was selling for. Equity does not contradict that; it gives a remedy against enforcing it.

That structure matters for how you argue. The contract is voidable rather than void, so the relief is discretionary, delay and third-party rights can defeat it, and the party seeking it must come to equity in the ordinary way.

Exam and application relevance

Identify the significance of the written price term and explain why Taylor’s conduct mattered beyond obtaining a favourable bargain.

Check your understanding

Mrs Johnson misread her own document. What did the purchaser do that made the contract unenforceable against her?