Sullivan v Moody
Sullivan v Moody (2001) 207 CLR 562
The harm was foreseeable, so surely a duty was owed. Why do courts keep saying it is not that simple?
Clarified by Mallonland Pty Ltd v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd [2024] HCA 25
THE COURT HAS SAID WHAT “WEIGHING FACTORS”
DOES NOT MEAN, and the warning is aimed at exactly the way this proposition is most often used. Mallonland Pty Ltd v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd [2024] HCA 25, the joint reasons of Gageler CJ, Gordon, Steward, Gleeson, Jagot and Beech-Jones JJ. At [36] their Honours quote this case: “[d]ifferent classes of case give rise to different problems in determining the existence and nature or scope, of a duty of care ... The relevant problem will then become the focus of attention in a judicial evaluation of the factors which tend for or against a conclusion, to be arrived at as a matter of principle.”
THEN THE LIMIT, at [37]: that reference to “factors ... for or against” recognition of a duty in a novel case “should not be understood as inviting any form of ‘instinctive synthesis’ of competing considerations ‘without a chain of reasoning linking these factors with the ultimate conclusion’”. And their Honours say what is required instead: “[t]his is why an incremental and analogical approach, paying close attention to relevant precedents and any risk of incoherence in the principles they establish, is necessary.”
WHAT TO DO IN AN ANSWER, because this is the difference between a pass and a good mark on a novel duty question. Naming salient features and announcing a conclusion is the thing [37] refuses. Work from the closest precedents outwards, say which feature does which work, and show the chain from the features to the conclusion -- including where recognising the duty would be incoherent with principles already established. Paragraphs [36]-[37] precede Edelman J’s separate reasons at [58] and so are the joint reasons’.
AND ONE JUSTICE WOULD CONFINE THE APPROACH AS NARROWLY AS POSSIBLE. Mallonland, EDELMAN J. He applies it, and says why only reluctantly: at [59] the salient features approach “has been strongly criticised”, but “the respondent producer did not challenge Caltex or its progeny”, so he agrees with its application and with dismissing the appeal -- while adding that the recognition of a duty to avoid pure economic loss in circumstances of salient features “has given rise to the highly unsatisfactory state of the present law with the effect that until Caltex and its progeny are challenged or rationalised, a duty of care based upon ‘salient features’ must be confined as narrowly as possible”. He repeats that at [104].
HIS CRITICISM IS WORTH KNOWING BECAUSE IT NAMES WHAT THE APPROACH REPLACED. At [93]: the approach is “on one view, little more than an insistence that each case will turn upon its own facts, with undetermined and indeterminate salient features relevant to a relationship to be identified from those facts”, which is “indistinguishable from an assessment of ‘proximity’, which was, for a time, the approach that was at the forefront of cases concerning novel duties of care in Australian law”. A student who knows that proximity was abandoned and that salient features is said to be proximity under another name has something to say about the approach rather than only within it.
THE LIMITS: these are the reasons of one Justice of seven, he applied the approach rather than declining to, and his criticism is directed at PURE ECONOMIC LOSS cases descending from Caltex rather than at novel duty questions generally. This case’s proposition stands; what is contested is how far the approach should reach and how much it explains.
What happened?
Two fathers, suspected of abusing their children after medical examinations, sued doctors and social workers in negligence.
In Thompson, charges followed but were dropped; he claimed psychiatric harm. In Sullivan, no charges were laid, but allegations ended his marriage.
Both statements of claim were struck out for disclosing no cause of action. Both appeals were dismissed.
What did the Court decide?
No duty of care existed. The joint judgment refused to use any single general test for deciding this. Different situations raise different issues, and here the problem was coherence with other duties. The respondents’ child-protection role required treating children’s interests as paramount, so a duty to the suspects couldn’t fit.
Proposition
What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis
Principle analysis
Novel duty of care questions are resolved by weighing multiple salient features of the relationship between the parties, not by applying one single test such as reasonable foreseeability alone.
Ratio and obiter
Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.
Ratio · Gleeson CJ, Gaudron, McHugh, Hayne and Callinan JJ
Read judgment: [50] (PDF p 22) (opens in a new tab), [62] (PDF p 25) (opens in a new tab), [64] (PDF p 26) (opens in a new tab)
The joint reasons required evaluation of the particular duty problem by reference to principle at [50]. That approach was applied in refusing the duties claimed: at [62], protecting suspected abusers from harm would conflict with the respondents’ investigative functions and their obligation to treat the children’s interests as paramount; at [64], the fathers’ claims ultimately rested on foreseeability, which was insufficient. These are reasons for the no-duty conclusion in these appeals. The proposition’s description of weighing multiple salient features is a synthesis, not the Court’s terminology or a holding prescribing a universal checklist. Its ratio support lies in the need to go beyond foreseeability and examine the relationship and coherence of the proposed duty with existing obligations.
Why does this case matter?
The fathers suffered foreseeable harm, yet lost at the pleading stage. Not on facts or breach — the claim couldn’t be framed at all.
The Court rejected deciding this by “fairness” alone ([53]). Its reasoning drew on analogy, indeterminacy, defamation’s privilege rules, and the defendants’ statutory duties ([54]).
So check: does the argument engage the empowering legislation? Does it ask which other law already governs the complaint?
Exam and application relevance
If novel, argue each salient feature, don’t just list them. For coherence, show the duties would be irreconcilable, not merely coexisting. Tie any statute’s requirements to the claimed duty’s cost.
Check your understanding
The doctors plainly owed duties to the children they examined. Why was that not by itself a reason to deny a duty to the fathers, and what more did the Court need?