Regent v Millett
Regent v Millett [1976] HCA 40; (1976) 133 CLR 679
An oral promise to sell a house, nothing in writing, and a couple who moved in and started paying the mortgage. Can equity enforce it?
What happened?
A contract for the sale of land was not supported by the writing the statute required. The acts relied on as part performance were the purchasers’ entry into possession, repairs they carried out, later renovations and additions, and their payment of the mortgage instalments.
The appellants argued two things: that the acts were not unequivocally referable to some such contract as the one alleged, and that a narrower test applied, under which nothing short of performance compelling the inference of a contract would do.
What did the Court decide?
The contract was enforceable. The High Court dismissed the appeal with costs, leaving the order for specific performance in place.
Proposition
What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis
Principle analysis
Equity will enforce an oral contract for the sale of land where the acts of part performance are “unequivocally, and in their own nature, referable to some such agreement as that alleged” — it is enough that they are “unequivocally and in their own nature referable to some contract of the general nature of that alleged”. Unequivocal referability remains the requirement; what is rejected is the narrower test that the acts “must necessarily imply the existence of the contract”. Taking possession, given pursuant to the contract, can satisfy it by itself.
Gibbs J adopted the Earl of Selborne LC’s formulation in Maddison v Alderson and rejected the appellants’ narrower formulation. On the facts, the circumstances in which possession was given made it referable to a contract of the kind alleged. Giving and taking possession sufficed, so the Court did not decide whether the repairs, renovations or mortgage payments would also have sufficed, separately or together. The purchasers were entitled under the contract to take possession; they did not have to be contractually bound to do so (Gibbs J, 133 CLR 683–684).
Ratio and obiter
Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.
Ratio · Gibbs J (Stephen, Mason, Jacobs and Murphy JJ agreeing)
Read judgment: p 683 (opens in a new tab)
Gibbs J adopted the Earl of Selborne LC’s unequivocal referability test and explained that reference to a contract of the general nature alleged suffices. This supplied the governing test needed to reject the appellants’ narrower formulation and determine whether possession supported enforcement; the quoted formulation originated in Maddison v Alderson.
Ratio · Gibbs J (Stephen, Mason, Jacobs and Murphy JJ agreeing)
Read judgment: pp 683–684 (opens in a new tab)
The giving and taking of possession was sufficient because its circumstances made it unequivocally referable to a contract of the kind alleged. The purchaser need only have been entitled, rather than contractually bound, to take that possession. This reasoning disposed of the appeal; the sufficiency of repairs, renovations and mortgage payments, alone or together, was expressly left undecided.
Why does this case matter?
The judgment records several acts relied on by the purchasers, but a list of acts in the reasons is not a finding that each satisfies the doctrine. Distinguish the ground on which the Court disposed of the appeal from the questions it left undecided. That distinction matters when using the case to support an argument based on different conduct.
Exam and application relevance
Set out the alleged agreement and a chronology of the conduct relied on. Which passage in Gibbs J’s reasons supports your argument about each act? Identify the factual similarities and differences before deciding how far the case assists your client.
Consider the appellants’ two objections separately. What did each objection ask the Court to require, and how did Gibbs J answer it? Explain which questions remained open after the appeal.
Check your understanding
Your client paid a deposit and nothing else. Why is that the hardest act to run, and what would you look for to support it?