Ermogenous v Greek Orthodox Community of SA Inc
Ermogenous v Greek Orthodox Community of SA Inc (2002) 209 CLR 95
The arrangement was religious, not commercial. Does that settle whether the parties meant to be legally bound?
What happened?
Archbishop Spyridon Ermogenous claimed unpaid annual leave and long service leave from the Greek Orthodox Community of SA Inc, saying it had employed him since 1970. An Industrial Magistrate awarded him $23,989.35 for annual leave and $10,672.80 for long service leave; a single judge and then the Full Court of the Industrial Relations Court both dismissed the Community’s appeals. The Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia then allowed it, by majority, holding there had been no intention to create legal relations ([1]–[2]).
What did the Court decide?
The appeal was allowed. The intention challenge failed: the Full Court’s inference that there was no intention to create legal relations “was not open on the facts that had been found at trial” ([45]), so the contract the Industrial Magistrate had found stood. What the Court did not decide was whether that contract was a contract of employment — the Community had run that as a separate ground below, the Full Court never reached it, and it was remitted for further argument ([46]–[47]).
Kirby J agreed in the result in separate reasons.
Proposition
What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis
Principle analysis
Whether parties intended to create legal relations is an objective assessment of the state of affairs, taking account of the subject matter, the status of the parties, their relationship and the surrounding circumstances, and it would be wrong to formulate rules prescribing the kinds of case in which such an intention should be found. The language of presumptions is of doubtful utility here: at best it identifies who bears the onus of proof, which lies on the party asserting the contract.
This was the reasoning of Gaudron, McHugh, Hayne and Callinan JJ at [25]–[27]. The mistake at [27] was concrete: the courts below had moved from saying that intention was not to be presumed to saying that arrangements for a minister’s remuneration generally would not create enforceable obligations. That shift supplied an answer to the dispute rather than leaving the Archbishop to prove his contract.
Ratio and obiter
Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.
Ratio · Gaudron, McHugh, Hayne and Callinan JJ
Read judgment: [25]–[27] (PDF p 15) (opens in a new tab), [45] (PDF p 24) (opens in a new tab)
The objective inquiry and rejection of a presumed absence of contractual intention supplied the legal basis for rejecting the Supreme Court’s approach to this religious engagement. At [45], the joint judgment held that the inference of no intention was not open on the facts found: it depended on an unsupported separation of church and Community or an unduly general rule drawn from earlier cases. The appellant still bore the onus of proving a contract. These principles form part of the reasoning necessary to that ground of decision; the passing reference to family arrangements at [26] does not decide how every domestic agreement should be treated.
Why does this case matter?
Count the hearings. The Archbishop won before the Magistrate, won before a single judge, won before the Full Court of the Industrial Relations Court, lost in the Full Court of the Supreme Court, and won in the High Court — and the litigation still was not over, because the Community had run a separate ground, that any enforceable contract was not a contract of employment, which the Supreme Court majority never reached and which went back with the case. He filed in September 1994 and the High Court gave judgment on 7 March 2002: seven and a half years, over roughly $34,700 in leave entitlements, to establish that the question of intention had been approached the wrong way.
The identity of the organisation mattered in practical terms. The Community had previously recruited and employed clergy as part of preserving Hellenic and Orthodox culture ([40]). Its functions extended beyond religion, and its members were not all observant practitioners of the Greek Orthodox faith ([41]). The agreement found at trial was with that Community, rather than some subset of its members or a larger group ([42]). A reader following the litigation needs to keep that particular respondent in view.
Exam and application relevance
Trace each claimed entitlement to its legal basis. For the Archbishop’s leave claims, identify which findings concerned the existence of a contract and which concerned its classification as employment. In a problem involving a paid office-holder, explain what further issue remains after a court finds a binding agreement. Keep the relief sought in view when stating what an appeal has resolved.
Check your understanding
The Archbishop won his appeal, and the contract found at trial survived it. So what was still undecided, and why did his leave entitlements turn on it?