Lange v Australian Broadcasting Corporation
Lange v Australian Broadcasting Corporation (1997) 189 CLR 520
A former New Zealand Prime Minister sued over a current affairs broadcast. The Court’s answer changed what the implied freedom is — and what it is not.
Doubted by LibertyWorks Inc v Commonwealth of Australia (2021) 274 CLR 1
ONE JUSTICE HAS PUT THE IMPLICATION ITSELF IN QUESTION -- not its content, its existence. LibertyWorks Inc v Commonwealth of Australia (2021) 274 CLR 1, STEWARD J at [298]: “[t]he divergence of views in this Court concerning the test for the application of the implied freedom perhaps may illustrate the tenuous nature of that implication. If the content of the implied freedom cannot even now be agreed upon, then, for my part, that may demonstrate that it was never justified.” He sets out Dawson J’s rejection of the implication in Theophanous v Herald & Weekly Times Ltd, and at [304] goes as far as the case allowed: “[t]he current division of opinion in this Court may, in my view, justify a reconsideration, with leave if necessary, of the existence of the implied freedom.”
AND HE STOPPED THERE, which is the part a student must not drop. At [304]: “neither party challenged the existence of the implied freedom in this special case. For the disposition of this proceeding, it is therefore not appropriate to deny its application here. It should, if required, be a matter for full argument to be considered on another occasion.” So this is a flag for a future case, not a holding. He is one Justice of a bench of seven, and the other four judgments apply the implied freedom.
WHAT SURVIVES EVEN ON HIS VIEW, at [301]: so concluding “does not deny, for example, the ability of this Court to protect the means by which representatives are ‘directly chosen’ by the people for the purposes of ss 7 and 24 of the Constitution”. That matters for this proposition specifically, because the two doubts are different: Steward J questions whether the implication should have been drawn at all, not whether the freedom -- if drawn -- is a limit on power rather than a personal right. The limit-not-a-right characterisation is untouched.
WHAT TO DO IN AN ANSWER: state the proposition as settled law, because it is -- and if the question invites discussion of the implication’s foundations, this is the citation for the view that the continuing disagreement about the test is itself evidence against the implication, together with the reason it has not been acted on.
What happened?
David Lange, a former Prime Minister of New Zealand, sued the ABC over a Four Corners broadcast. The ABC raised the implied freedom of political communication, which earlier decisions had described in terms broad enough to suggest it might operate like a personal right.
What did the Court decide?
The ABC’s defence failed here; its pleaded facts didn’t fit. The Court unanimously remitted the case to the NSW Supreme Court.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
The implied freedom of political communication derives from the text and structure of the Constitution and operates as a limit on legislative and executive power, not as a personal right conferred on individuals.
Why does this case matter?
This case blocks the “valuable speech” argument. It shows the freedom reshaping common law, not just striking statutes down. The justification test has since evolved beyond this foundation.
Check your understanding
A client says a council by-law has infringed their right to free political speech. What is wrong with the way that claim is framed?