He Kaw Teh v The Queen

High Court of Australia · 1985

Criminal Law And ProcedureMistake Of FactFault

He Kaw Teh v The Queen (1985) 157 CLR 523

Heroin in a false-bottomed bag. The trial judge told the jury the Crown need prove no state of mind at all — and that the accused had to prove his innocence of mind.

What happened?

The accused arrived at Melbourne airport and Customs officers found heroin concealed in the false bottom of a bag in his luggage. He was charged under the Customs Act with importing narcotic goods and with having them in his possession. The trial judge told the jury that the Crown did not have to prove any state of mind at all, and that if the accused wanted to rely on an honest and reasonable belief that would make his conduct innocent, it was for him to establish it on the balance of probabilities.

What did the Court decide?

The Court corrected the trial judge’s directions concerning fault and proof. Special leave was granted, the appeal allowed and the matter remitted to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Victoria.

Proposition

What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added

Principle analysis

Where an offence is one of strict liability — not absolute liability, and where the statute does not allocate the burden otherwise — an accused who raises an honest and reasonable mistaken belief in facts that would make the act innocent bears no onus of proving it; raising a reasonable doubt suffices and the prosecution must disprove the belief. This is a different route from a mistake that negatives a knowledge element, which need not be reasonable at all.

Why does this case matter?

Its lasting contribution is the method it insists on. Before this case Australian courts had drifted into treating the presumption of a guilty mind as a weak one, easily set aside for anything that looked regulatory. The Court refused that shortcut and set out what actually has to be weighed: the words of the provision, the seriousness of the penalty and the stigma of conviction, and whether making the defendant liable regardless of fault would do anything at all to improve compliance. That last question is the sharpest of the three, because if there is nothing the defendant could have done differently, strict liability only finds a luckless victim.

It is also a reminder that silence in a statute is not an answer. A provision that says nothing about fault has not thereby excluded it.

Watch the statutory language closely, though. Where Parliament frames the exculpation differently — as a “reasonable excuse”, for instance — the analysis and the onus can both change, and this judgment itself notices that.

Exam and application relevance

When analysing a statutory offence, examine the provision’s words, penalties and purpose before classifying its fault requirements. How would you frame separate jury directions about fault, mistake and proof? Explain how the directions would depend on the construction of the offence. Check the jurisdiction’s statute too, because several have legislated on fault and on mistake since this decision.

Check your understanding

The trial judge allowed the accused to rely on honest and reasonable belief. What was still wrong with the way he put it to the jury?