Worked example: a restrictive practice used on an NDIS participant in Victoria
The facts
J is a 27-year-old NDIS participant with an intellectual disability and autism. He lives in supported accommodation in Victoria, run by registered provider Kestrel Care.
J has become distressed and damaged property over three months. Staff shortages have followed two resignations. The supervisor now locks the front door from 7pm, stopping J from leaving.
A support worker has twice given J a sedative. A GP prescribed it “as needed for agitation.”
There is no behaviour support plan. The supervisor calls the locked door “just a house rule.” She says the medication is a medical matter, not a restrictive practice.
J’s mother has no formal appointment giving her authority. She has been told she may consent for J anyway.
Step 2 — What the Commonwealth actually requires
People often think the Commonwealth bans the practice, or that the NDIS Commission can authorise it. Both ideas are wrong.
Sections 8(2), 9(2)(a), 10(2)(a) and 11(2)(a) of the Rules link this to Kestrel Care’s registration conditions. These sections point to State and Territory law for prohibition and authorisation.
The Commonwealth only does two things. It requires authorisation to exist, and it makes a failure to get it a breach of registration conditions. The NDIS Commissioner can enforce this against the provider.
The Commonwealth does not grant the authorisation itself. It also does not make the conduct unlawful against J.
Step 4 — The staffing point disposes of part of the case anyway
The house was short-staffed, and that is why the locking started. Even if authorisation is granted later, this staffing fact still matters.
South Australia’s law states this principle clearly. Section 23M of the Disability Inclusion Act 2018 (SA) bans using a restrictive practice as punishment, for convenience, or because staffing, equipment or facilities are inadequate.
This SA section does not apply in Victoria — it is a different jurisdiction. It is mentioned only to explain the principle. Victoria achieves the same result through its own s 136 authorisation requirements.
The practical advice is the same regardless of jurisdiction. A restrictive practice used because a service lacks staff is not a genuine behaviour support measure. An authorisation application should not be based on staffing convenience.
Step 5 — J’s mother cannot consent
J’s mother has not been appointed as his decision-maker. Under Victorian law, being a parent does not automatically make her one for an adult child.
If someone is genuinely needed to help decide, Victoria has options. These should be tried from least to most restrictive.
First, a supportive attorney (under ss 85 to 87 of the Powers of Attorney Act 2014 (Vic)). This person can access information and help carry out J’s decisions, but the decision stays J’s. If J can decide with support, this is the right option.
Second, an enduring attorney (under the same Act). Section 21’s principles of least restriction and participation control how this power is used.
Third, a VCAT order (under s 30 of the Guardianship and Administration Act 2019 (Vic)). This only applies if J lacks capacity for the specific matter, and only if the order would promote his personal and social wellbeing. Both conditions must be met. Capacity is assessed separately for each matter — so being unable to manage a tenancy says nothing about deciding on medication.
Section 9 requires every decision under that Act to follow J’s will and preferences. Arguing that a guardian is needed simply because J’s behaviour is difficult for staff does not meet the test in s 30 at all.
Step 6 — What Kestrel Care should do now
Kestrel Care must stop the unauthorised practices straight away. Section 135 bans them, and continuing risks a registration consequence under the Commonwealth Rules.
Each practice needs classifying under s 6 of the Rules. This classification must be recorded.
The staffing shortage is a staffing problem, not a reason for authorisation. A practice should not be authorised just to cover a roster gap.
Kestrel Care needs a behaviour support plan first. Then it needs the Authorised Program Officer’s authorisation under s 136(1)(a). Senior Practitioner approval is also needed, but only where the practice requires it.
The advice given to J’s mother was wrong. She has no legal authority over J. A supportive attorney appointment could instead let J make decisions with help.
A guardianship order should not be the first step. Section 30 has two limbs, and less restrictive options must be tried first.
Finally, expect the regulator to examine the past conduct, not just future plans. The registration condition was already breached while the practices were unauthorised.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.