Worked example: an older person entering residential aged care in South Australia

The facts

Mrs K is 84 and lives alone in Adelaide. South Australia. After a fall and hospital stay, she cannot safely return home. Her daughter R found a residential aged care place starting next week.

Mrs K signed an advance care directive four years ago. It says no resuscitation, and that she would “prefer to stay in my own home as long as possible”. She has no enduring power of attorney. She owns her home and has modest savings.

Mrs K is intermittently confused. On good days she says she does not want to enter care. R claims her mother has “lost capacity”. R wants to sign admission paperwork herself, sell the house, and admit her mother.

Step 1 — Split the jurisdiction before advising on anything

Two different legal systems apply here, and each answers separate questions.

Commonwealth law covers the aged care side. This includes whether the home is a registered provider, what fees Mrs K can be charged, means testing, and any accommodation payment or refundable deposit. These rules come from the Aged Care Act 2024 (Cth): registration under s 104, with funding, fees, means-testing and accommodation covered elsewhere in the Act.

South Australian law covers Mrs K herself. This includes her capacity (her mental ability to make decisions), whether her advance care directive applies, who can make decisions for her, who can deal with her house, and whether her daughter can be authorised to act.

R’s plan does not separate these two systems. That is why, as currently proposed, it will not work.

Step 2 — Capacity is not a global finding

Saying Mrs K has “lost capacity” is not a legal conclusion in South Australia. Two provisions explain why.

Section 3 of the Guardianship and Administration Act 1993 (SA) defines mental incapacity. This means being unable to look after one’s own health, safety or welfare, or manage one’s affairs, because of a brain or mind impairment, or a physical condition stopping communication of wishes.

Section 7(2)(d) of the Advance Care Directives Act 2013 (SA) adds a safeguard. A decision is not treated as showing impaired capacity just because it may lead to an adverse outcome.

So Mrs K’s refusal to enter care does not, by itself, prove impaired capacity merely because it might end badly. The real question under s 7(1)(a) is whether she can understand, retain and use the relevant information, and communicate her decision.

Intermittent confusion may be relevant to capacity. Simply disagreeing with her daughter is not.

If capacity is genuinely doubtful, it must actually be assessed. That assessment must focus on the specific decision in issue, not capacity in general.

Step 4 — There is no enduring power of attorney, so R cannot deal with the house

R cannot sell Mrs K’s house. In South Australia, power over someone’s property and money comes from the Powers of Attorney and Agency Act 1984 (SA). Mrs K never made an enduring power of attorney under s 6, and her directive does not create one (s 13). So R has no authority over the house or savings. If she tried to sell the house, it would not be a valid sale.

There are two possible paths forward, depending on Mrs K’s capacity.

If Mrs K still has capacity, she can make an enduring power of attorney now, following the s 6 requirements. This is the less restrictive option and should be tried first. If R is appointed, she would have a duty under s 7 to act with reasonable diligence to protect Mrs K’s interests once Mrs K loses capacity. She would also have to keep accurate records under s 8 — failing to do so is an offence. Under s 9, she could not give up the role during Mrs K’s incapacity without the Supreme Court’s permission. R should know this before agreeing.

If Mrs K no longer has capacity, someone must apply to SACAT for an administration order under s 35. Section 5(d) says the order chosen must be the least restrictive option for Mrs K’s rights and independence, while still protecting her properly. So the application should ask only for what is truly needed, not a broad order just because it is easier.

A guardianship order under s 29 is separate. It deals with personal and lifestyle decisions, like where Mrs K lives. These two types of orders should not be confused — SACAT can grant one without the other.

From 9 July 2026, a guardian has a new power relevant to Mrs K’s situation. While she is a patient at an incorporated hospital, her guardian may decide she should move to a specified aged care facility on discharge. The guardian may also authorise her detention while being taken there (s 31(2)). R cannot use this power unless SACAT appoints her guardian. Because Mrs K sometimes objects, this power must be sought and shaped using the least restrictive principle in s 5(d).

Step 6 — If things go wrong later

If things go wrong later, South Australia offers two main routes.

The first is a complaint about the home. Section 24 of the Health and Community Services Complaints Act 2004 (SA) lists who may complain. Mrs K herself can complain, but so can a substitute decision-maker under her advance care directive (s 24(da)). A person approved by the Commissioner may also complain, where the Commissioner is satisfied it is unreasonable to expect Mrs K to complain personally (s 24(g)).

The second route concerns abuse or neglect, including financial abuse by a family member. This falls under the Ageing and Adult Safeguarding Act 1995 (SA). Mrs K is a “relevant adult” if she may be vulnerable to abuse (s 3(1)). Abuse means conduct within a relationship of trust, dependency, or imbalance of power (s 4(1)).

Reporting abuse under this Act is voluntary, not compulsory (s 22(4)(a)). The safeguarding response is consent-based, meaning it generally requires the adult’s agreement, subject to exceptions in s 28(2). Each exception still needs the Director’s approval. SACAT may authorise action even if Mrs K has refused it (s 33(1)(c)).

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.