Western Australia’s move to uniform evidence law
Passage is not commencement
Passing an Act is not the same as it starting to operate. This is a general lesson, not just a feature of this Western Australian Act.
Section 2 sets different start dates for different parts. Part 1 starts on Royal Assent. Section 384 starts the next day. The rest of the Act starts on a day fixed later by proclamation, and different provisions can start on different days.
That day has now been fixed as 18 September 2027. Most of the Act starts then, except for two small Divisions dealing with consequential amendments. One of those still depends on another Act. The other will never start, because the provision it would have amended was deleted.
Until 18 September 2027, the old Evidence Act 1906 keeps applying in Western Australia. Section 386, which repeals the 1906 Act, only takes effect on that date too. So it is wrong to treat the new Act as current law, or say the 1906 Act “was replaced,” before then.
Staggered start dates like this are common for large Acts, giving courts and lawyers time to prepare. It means there is no single moment when everything changes at once.
To check what has actually commenced, consult the Western Australian legislation database’s commencement table. That table is authoritative — not media releases, summaries, or memory of when reform was announced.
What changes on commencement
This section is about Western Australia moving to uniform evidence law. Several things change when the new Act commences.
Relevance becomes the main test for admitting evidence. Evidence that is not relevant cannot be admitted. Relevant evidence can be admitted, unless a rule excludes it.
Hearsay changes too. Hearsay is an out-of-court statement used to prove what it says. Instead of the old common law rule, there is now a statutory rule with set exceptions, including special rules for first-hand hearsay (where the person who made the statement is available or unavailable to give evidence).
Opinion evidence, tendency and coincidence evidence, and credibility evidence each get their own statutory rules. Each has its own test for when it can be admitted, and sometimes requires the court’s permission (leave).
Courts can also exclude evidence using statutory discretionary and mandatory exclusion rules. These weigh how useful the evidence is (probative value) against the risk of unfair prejudice to a party.
The Act also protects complainants and vulnerable witnesses. In sexual offence and family violence cases in a superior court, complainants must be treated as special witnesses.
Other protections include pre-recorded evidence, giving evidence remotely, and witness intermediaries to help children or people with communication difficulties. Body-worn camera footage can be used as evidence-in-chief in family violence matters.
The Act also restricts improper questioning of witnesses. It removes any automatic requirement to warn a jury that a delay in complaint affects credibility. Such a warning can still be given, but only if the accused asks for it and the circumstances justify it.
Many of these reforms follow recommendations from the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse.
Working in a jurisdiction mid-transition
Western Australia is moving to uniform evidence law. While this change happens, three habits help.
First, date the proceeding. Section 389 says the 2025 Act applies to proceedings starting on or after it commences, and to later parts of earlier proceedings. But if a hearing began before the 1906 Act was repealed, and continues past that day, it stays under the 1906 Act.
Second, do not assume an answer from the Commonwealth or New South Wales Act applies in Western Australia. Until commencement, Western Australian proceedings are governed by the 1906 Act, so such answers are at best persuasive. Check the court first: the Commonwealth Act applies in all federal courts, and some of its provisions, mainly about proving official and public documents, apply in every Australian court.
Third, expect old authority to matter less once the uniform scheme starts. Other uniform jurisdictions’ decisions become useful, while 1906 Act cases lose most of their force. 1906 Act case law still matters where the 2025 Act repeats an old provision, where common law survives, or where a hearing remains under the 1906 Act. Until then, use both bodies of law carefully, checking which one applies.
What the uniform scheme does not do
Adopting uniform evidence law in Western Australia does not replace everything else.
The uniform Acts are not a complete code. Where they are silent, such as some voir dire questions or certain privileges, the common law still applies.
Other statutes still operate too. Criminal procedure legislation and court rules keep their own evidentiary provisions. The 2025 Act does not change other Acts directly, but its Part 12 amends many of them, so read those provisions as amended.
Uniform does not mean identical everywhere. Western Australia’s version differs in detail from other states and keeps its own State provisions. Always check the WA text itself, not assume it matches the Commonwealth Act.
The other non-uniform jurisdictions
Queensland and South Australia still use their own evidence statutes and the common law. Once Western Australia’s uniform Act starts, these two will be the only non-uniform jurisdictions left.
This matters for two reasons. First, a uniform provision’s wording differs from non-uniform ones, so case law on it may not help in a jurisdiction with different wording. Students must check where an interstate authority comes from before relying on it.
Second, Western Australia’s shift means its older authority becomes less useful over time. It also opens up uniform-jurisdiction case law that was previously only of background interest.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by checking the proceeding’s date. Confirm whether the provision in issue has commenced yet.
If the substantive Parts haven’t commenced, answer under the Evidence Act 1906 and common law. Say this expressly in your answer.
If they have commenced, follow the statutory order. Check relevance first, then the exclusionary rule, then any exception, then the discretions.
Check if the provision is a carried-over Western Australian one. Its wording may differ from the uniform text.
Where a witness is a complainant in a sexual offence or family violence case, treat the special witness and questioning provisions separately from admissibility.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.