Unfair contract terms

Which contracts are covered

Three conditions must all be met for the unfair contract terms regime to apply.

First, the contract must be a consumer contract (for goods, services or land, mainly for personal or household use) or a small business contract. The small business test changed in 2023: it now looks at employee numbers and turnover, not contract value. Which version applies depends on when the contract was made.

Second, the contract must be standard form — one party held most bargaining power and prepared it beforehand, leaving the other to accept or reject it as presented. Once a contract is alleged standard form, it is presumed to be so. The other party must prove a genuine, effective chance to negotiate existed, not just an invitation to comment.

Third, some terms are excluded entirely: the main subject matter, the upfront price, and terms required or permitted by law. These exclusions mean the regime checks the contract’s mechanics, not the core bargain itself.

The test for unfairness

A term is unfair under s 24 only if three things are all true. It must cause a significant imbalance between the parties’ rights and obligations. It must not be reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate interests of the party it favours. And it must cause detriment, financial or otherwise, if used.

For the second limb, the law presumes the term is not reasonably necessary. The party who benefits from the term must prove otherwise. This reversal matters in practice.

Courts also look at transparency: is the term in plain language, legible, clear and easy to find? This is not a fourth requirement, just something courts weigh alongside the whole contract. A clearly written term can still be unfair, but a hidden, unclear one rarely survives.

Terms presumed to be unfair

The law gives examples of unfair terms. These are a guide, not a complete list.

Examples include terms letting only one party avoid or limit their obligations, terminate the contract, or vary its terms. They also include terms letting only one party decide to renew, change the price, or decide if a breach occurred.

Each example shares one feature: asymmetry, meaning one party has power the other lacks. This imbalance is the central theme running through the whole area of law.

Consequences

An unfair term is void under s 23. This means the term is treated as if it never existed.

The rest of the contract still binds the parties, but only if it can work without that term.

Since 2023, unfair terms can also trigger civil penalties. Proposing, applying or relying on such a term breaches the ACL.

These penalties are calculated per term, not per contract. Before 2023, voidness was the only consequence, so this change made the regime far more significant.

The relationship with unconscionability and misleading conduct

These three consumer protections overlap, but each does different work. Keep them separate in your answer.

Unconscionable conduct looks at behaviour. It asks whether someone exploited a special disadvantage, or acted against conscience.

Misleading or deceptive conduct looks at representations. It asks whether conduct was apt to lead someone into error.

Unfair contract terms looks at the content of a term in a standard form contract. This applies regardless of how the contract was made or what was said.

A term can be unfair even if nobody behaved badly. A fairly drafted term can still be part of unconscionable conduct. Pleading all three together is common, but do not confuse them.

What “standard form” means

This regime only covers standard form contracts. Once a party claims a contract is standard form, the law presumes this is true. The other party must then prove otherwise.

Courts look at several things to decide this. These include who held most of the bargaining power, and whether the contract was drafted before any discussion happened. Courts also check if one party simply had to accept or reject the contract as given, without a real chance to negotiate.

A small negotiated change does not stop a contract from being standard form. The contract can still fall under this regime despite that minor variation.

The transparency requirement

A term is more likely to be unfair if it lacks transparency. Transparency means the term is in plain language, easy to read, clearly set out, and easy to find.

Transparency is not its own test for invalidity. A clear term can still be unfair. A term in fine print is not automatically unfair just because it is hard to find.

Instead, transparency feeds into the overall fairness assessment. It often matters most when the term’s practical effect is borderline.

Exclusions

Some terms cannot be assessed for fairness. These include terms that define the main subject matter of the contract. They also include terms setting the upfront price, as long as the price is clearly disclosed.

But this price exclusion is limited. It does not cover contingent charges, like default fees or early termination charges. These fees only apply if something happens later, so they can still be assessed.

Terms required or expressly allowed by Commonwealth, State or Territory law are also excluded.

Some whole contract types are excluded too. These include shipping contracts, company constitutions, and certain insurance contracts covered by their own separate rules.

Applying this in a problem question

First check coverage. Ask whether the party is a consumer or small business, whether the term is standard form, and whether it isn’t excluded. Do this before looking at the merits.

Next, work out when the contract was made. This matters because both the small business threshold and the penalty rules changed in 2023.

Then apply the three limbs separately. State clearly that all three must be satisfied for the term to be unfair.

For the second limb, the onus sits with the party relying on the term. Identify what legitimate interest that party claims to protect.

Treat transparency and the contract as a whole as factors the court must consider, not as extra limbs to prove.

Finally, address the consequences. The term is void, the rest of the contract survives where possible, and penalties may follow.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.